It's hard to tell from your pictures but that may be a ZZ plant. That's actually the abbreviated name but if you google it you can find the full name.

Does it have a trunk with side branches, or are all stems coming from the soil? If trunk, is it lignifying (turning woody?)

Its beautiful whatever it is.

Its not a ZZ plant. The middle branch has side branches but the 2 outer stems are coming from the soil. This plant is in a 2in pot and is about 5 inches tall.

I was thinking it looked kind of ficus-y.

Was it definitely being sold as a house plant?

Yes, or actually as a "terrarium" plant. It does look ficus-y to me also, but i can find a cultivar that looks like this.

Do the leaves look like a humidity stressed coffee plant?

http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/z/coffee-beans-leaves-coffee-tree-24112393.jpg

http://i00.i.aliimg.com/wsphoto/v0/1388562200/Small-bonsai-coffee-beans-coffee-tree-flower-mini-plant-indoor-small-desktop-plants.jpg

I keep going back and forth, but I don't think that's it.

It looks too big to be a terrarium plant.

There's also a "name that plant" forum here.

zzackey it is in a 2x2 inch pot. The plant is only 5 inches tall. It is not a coffee plant.

It does look like a coffee plant.

Did you post it in NTP?

I'm gonna do that now!

So? Are you going to link us?

Did you get an ID over there?

I sent an email to the nursery that i brought it from and this is what they responded with-

Hello! That is a serissa, most likely the foetida species. Thanks for coming to The Good Earth! Please let us know if you have other questions and have a wonderful day!

When i looked that up, i still did not find a plant that looks exactly like the one i have with the wavy-like leaves.