Asphalt shingles vs. Metal roofing
Bossy vossy
8 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (22)
Alisande
8 years agoravencajun Zone 8b TX
8 years agoRelated Discussions
got bids for new roof....either shingle or metal..need to add ins
Comments (1)My best suggestion is that you figure out your priorities. You may want great insulation and a durable roof that looks good, and you may want it all for cheap. You probably won't get all of this. If you don't prioritize then you won't know where to compromise, and you'll keep going in circles. Also, try and find a professional to work with who actually understands the way your roof is supposed to work, or else you'll just be throwing money away. For example, if your roof is ventilated then any insulation you put on top of the existing sheathing will be pretty much useless. You probably need a smart general contractor, not a roofing company....See MoreYes or no --- putting a metal roof over one layer shingles
Comments (11)There is not " a single "correct " way of doing a metal roof but here are a few thoughts for your consideration. I am taking you at your word about being familiar with construction because much depends on your ability to apply experience to which way to go. Be certain the one saying two layers is honest as well as experienced before sighning a contract with him. Most properly installed composition shingles look like 2 layers at drip edge because of starter strips. Can you install metal over one layer of composition? Maybe. The main consideration is wherther the deck and frame will support the extra weight. Then there is the question of how smooth and level surface the shingles afford. Regardless of other underlying material,decking must be capiable of holding screws. 1x deck is strong but usually has many gaps between edges and ends of boards that if a screew gos through,a leak is likly. OSB and plywood are flat and smooth but must be thick enough to prevent flex between rafters. I have installed metal over a few compostions with no problem after several years. On a couple where shingles were aged and deck was strong, we layed tar paper between the shingles and metal. Another had heavy truss framing with questionable decking so we installed 2x4 laths over tar paper making certain to hit rafters with lath fasteners. If your husband is a healthy 70 yo,you might consider hireing laborers to work under his supervision. I agree with Hollysprings about metal not being difficult compared to other construction tasks. A word of warning about roof tearoff. Think twice about putting old shingles in anything without dump. The shingles interlace and make the intire load act as a single blob that resists shoveling off. If you use a non-dumping truck or trailer, lay a cross tie or similar on floor at front with heavy chain on it. If bed is more than 8 feet long, put another drag half way to back and leave enough chain slack between the drags to alow first to move a few feet and pull some material off before chain tightens on other drag. In farm and ranch country you may find people who have installed metal as part of thier farm work. A farmer or rancher who has built thier own barns might welcome extra or off season work. If that sounds interesting,in addition to other means of asking,check out the people on "Yesterday's tractor forums". The board you want is "tractor talk" . If you go with diy ,you can buy or rent the specialized cutters. If your husband decides to supervise labor and isn't comfortable on a ladder and/or walking on the roof,rent a lift to alow him safly going to roof level as well as saving time lifting materials....See MoreValley flashing and drip edge for a low pitch asphalt shingle re-roof
Comments (9)Ichabod, we're in the desert southwest, but I probably should have expanded on that comment! Our annual average rainfall here is under 10". Snow does happen but is not common. Ice dams are not a problem here, for example, so local code does not require ice and water shield at the eaves, either. We recently had a wet 6" snow but that is fairly remarkable for us, down here in the southern part of New Mexico. Also to you and tlbean2004, thanks for your thoughts on the metal flashing. We may request metal valley flashings, with ice and water underneath. Metal flashings got the roof through 17 years with no problems, so I'm not sure why to abandon them now...unless the technology of modern underlayments has rendered metal valley flashings obsolete. I thought that was what the roofer was implying, and we weren't sure if that was correct. I'll admit I am also a bit more worried about this roof than I would be if it was not such a low pitch. So you folks are a big help. klem1, thanks for your explanation. Nope, no interest here in removing the 2x2 trim to try to treat the rafter tail end grain (DH would leave me if I suggested that) so it looks like the consensus is to keep a very wide metal flashing. I guess it will be less distracting when painted to match the wood. Our house was built in 1965 and I sure don't want to make uninformed decisions that lead to damage...all for the sake of looks. (As much as I dislike the look of the big drip edge.) I guess a smaller drip edge and rotted wood would not be very pretty, either. I need to figure out which ice and water shield product will work in our hot temperatures, if we want it under the metal valley flashing. One bid specifies GAF Weatherwatch (but the contractor isn't local.) I don't know how heat resistant that product is. I know Grace Ice and Water has the best reputation, but I was surprised to see the Grace website says that only their most expensive product, Grace Ultra, should be used in the desert southwest: Grace IWS Contractor's Guide So if the esteemed Grace Ice & Water Shield (regular product) will not stand up to desert southwest heat, I wonder how any of the (much less expensive) GAF ice and shield products would work. There are a few scary stories in some roofing forums about "bitumen bleed" when ice and shield products are used in higher temps than recommended. (Roofing is not for sissies, have you noticed?)...See MoreAsphalt vs fiberglass shingles
Comments (1)Ask local roofers their opinion. They will be familiar with your weather condition and their opinion will be backed by experience that you will most likely be experiencing....See Morenicole___
8 years agoravencajun Zone 8b TX
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoAlisande
8 years agosweet_betsy No AL Z7
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoUser
8 years agosusanjf_gw
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agochisue
8 years agoredtartan
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoElmer J Fudd
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoredtartan
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agobossyvossy
8 years agobossyvossy
8 years agojoyfulguy
8 years agoworkoutlady
8 years agoJasdip
8 years agoAlisande
8 years agoredtartan
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoPKponder TX Z7B
8 years agoredtartan
8 years ago
Related Stories
ROOFSNo Substitute for the Natural Beauty of Wooden Roof Shingles and Shakes
This natural, renewable roof option brings weathered character and nostalgic appeal to traditional-style homes
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESMaterials: The Advantages of a Metal Roof
Metal reigns in roofing style, maintenance and energy efficiency
Full StoryMODERN ARCHITECTUREDesign Workshop: Modern Metal Shingle Style
Steel, copper and zinc shingles take siding to new heights, with less maintenance than their wooden cousins
Full StoryROOFS8 Alternative Roof Materials to Buck the Mainstream
Looking for something to raise your roof in the neighborhood? Consider synthetic tiles, recycled composite shingles, green roofs and more
Full StoryARCHITECTURERoots of Style: Shingle Style Is Back — Here's How to Spot It
Intimate or rambling, in the coast or by the sea, Shingle homes are seeing a revival. Has your home joined in?
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDES5 Places to Love Corrugated Metal in Your House
It’s budget friendly, versatile and even colorful. Is it any wonder this popular exterior material is making inroads indoors?
Full StoryROOFSRoof Materials: Get an Old-World Look With Clay Roof Tiles
The ancient roof material of choice remains the modern-day ideal for authentic Italian, Mediterranean and Spanish home styles
Full StoryLANDSCAPE DESIGNHow to Incorporate Your Roofing Into the Landscape
Choose hardscape and plantings that work with your roof’s color, texture, shape and line
Full StoryMATERIALSThe Most Popular Roofing Material is Affordable and Easy to Install
Asphalt shingles, the most widely used roof material in the U.S. are reliable and efficient, and may be right for you
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Traditional Shingle With a Modern Soul
A home’s shingle-style exterior fits in with the neighborhood and allows for an open, harmonious flow inside
Full Story
marilyn_c