Personally, for abundance of flower throughout the season, I would choose Scepter'd Isle, I love its musk scent as well as its arching habit. For knock out perfume but an upright growing bush, then Sharifa Asma is worth considering. I have both.
Both are good roses, but have different habits. In my garden, Sharifa Asma is compact, while Sceptre de Isle is a definite climber, with lots of flowers, very fragrant. Photo is Sharifa Asma.
triciac
rexedwardfairy
Related Discussions
Sceptre d'Isle is never without a flower!
Q
Suggestions for a David Austin Pink?
Q
Most fragrant David Austin roses
Q
Show us your PINK Roses
Q
rexedwardfairy
VitaS
dutch88
tuppitoo