How do you handle this common (I think!) gift-giving problem

15 years ago

Okay, so I know that you're never obligated to give a gift, even if someone gives one to you first. But how would you handle this?

Two of my closest friends give me gifts every Christmas and birthday, always gift cards with something else small, like an edible item. They started it, I didn't. I've suggested several times that we concentrate on the kids and not give to each other. They say, "Yes, mmm-hmm," and then on the next birthday or Christmas, there's the gift card. I don't think it's that they particularly want to exchange gifts, but more that they can't *not* do it.

It's not the money, at all. I love these people, I have the money. So I finally decided to just buy gift cards in equal amounts, even though I think it's stupid.

But I hate giving a gift card to a good friend. I like personal gifts that reflect that I actually *know* the recipient. And I do know these people, so I can find gifts like that, but it means more shopping. Which I don't really want to do.

So, would you stop completely, knowing that they are not going to stop, would you just keep giving the stupid gift card, or would you start buying real gifts for these people?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

OklaMoni
15 years ago
No way would I give gift cards. Just be gracious, and accept.

Some people just don't know, how not to give.

I make a BIG point, of telling new friends, NO gift exchanges! But still I have a friend that brought gifts from her two last trips.

I do enjoy them, and use them. It is her choice, to give or not to give, just like it is my choice.

I choose not to.

Moni
jannie
15 years ago
I buy $25 gift certificates to a local big-name book store and keep these on hand for "surprise" gifts. Everyone reads and has special interests.
Related Discussions
Do you give gifts to your kids' boyfriends/girlfriends?
Q
Comments (43)
I had a couple of holiday surprise guests too--at noon, with the gathering scheduled to start at 2 pm, my son asked if it was ok for his ex-girlfriend to come! They split quite awhile ago (he broke up with her) but I knew they were still reasonably cordial. I'm not sure exactly what the status of their relationship is now but I have always liked that girl so it was nice to see her. And my daughter asked if a close friend could come. Friend is a Jewish vegan so it was a little challenge for me to ensure there was food she could eat. It all worked out and I am so glad I always have a few gift items on hand. Gave ex-girlfriend a Godiva chocolate bar sampler and a nice candle. Daughter's friend got an iTunes gift card and a joke book of the world's worst album covers (she and my daughter are both into the indie rock scene here). They both seemed to have a great time. Son and ex(??) went home to her place together, and my daughter's friend told her afterward 'Christmas is fun-I might have to find a Christian boy to marry!' :). Ann
...See More
Am I crazy? How bad do you think water problem is? Mold?
Q
Comments (27)
I was in a very similar situation a couple years ago. I wanted a midcentury modern home but it had to be in a specific area. Prices were still depressed at that time, but I knew they were bound to increase soon. I had been watching a home online that was built by one of my favorite 1950's architects. I had seen black and white pics of the house from the 50's and it was beautiful then. Unfortunately, the previous owners had altered much of the architecture. The price was much too high. When the price decreased significantly, the realtor and I went to look at it. It had also been abandoned for 10 yrs. There was major water damage EVERYWHERE. The ceiling ballooned out all over the place. The patio overhang and soffit had areas of rot. The carpet had water damage. The realtor and I walked out laughing that anyone would think they could sell the house for the asking price (which was still above my budget). We looked at more homes, but the bones of these homes did not compare to the damaged home. The home had walls of glass, amazing views of the city and mountains and in my opinion had great potential. When I wanted to make an offer on it, the realtor was shocked. He tried to talk me out of it. But I felt it was a matter of time before I was priced out of this area and despite the terrible condition of the home, it had other things going for it. Before making an offer, we had a roofer look at the roof. Like your roof, it had been replaced in the last 10 yrs. All I can figure is that no one had bothered to repair the extensive drywall damage. The exterior soffit damage was from condensation in AC vents (yes- they had AC on the patio!). After haggling with the bank (shortsale), I finally got the house. I remember that night thinking, WHAT HAVE I DONE? The house has taken extensive investment. It is not done, and because of the expense, I am taking my time with it. I did put in new floors, new roof, new electrical, new kitchen, drywall, opened the floorplan up, etc. The house just appraised for much higher than I paid. If I were you, I would have a roofer look at the roof to verify it is intact. Try to get a contractor out there also to give you his/her opinion on the source of the water damage elsewhere and his worst cost estimate. Think about the WORST possible outcome with the water damage and decide if you are willing to pay this for the house. I was fortunate that for my house the water damage, although it looked awful, was negligible for cost. If you really want the house, repairing the issues may be worth it. Dont forget that other things might need repair/replacing - HVAC system, etc.
...See More
Do you give/bring a hostess gift?
Q
Comments (30)
Seriously? Someone invites me to their home for food/fun/party but I should run by Walgreens and buy them a package of napkins or a dusty candle? I, for one, detest "hostess gifts". Flowers!, "How beautiful!" Now I gotta run to find a vase, the flowers for the party are already on the table. I got 50 people arriving so I really can't take the time to cut the ends in my kitchen, already full of food stuff. I'm trying to find which toilet is clean enough, out of the party trail, to put the flowers in until tomorrow. Ohhhhhh, and the candles and trinkets. I've probably already been dusting and cleaning for days for this partay. Someone shows up with a "hostess gift" that is going to need dusting, cleaning, pruning, feeding, whatEVER! I still have to be nice. Think about it, 50 people, say 20 couples and some singles. They all bring a "hostess gift". What are you gonna do with that "stuff" the next day even after you get done cleaning up from the party? Since I got there, I have your address, since I have your address, I probably know your name. I would send a card after the party for a big thanks. That's about as "old fashioned" as you can get. No, I will never "stop off" to get a hostess gift. It's the thought that counts.
...See More
How do you do Dirty Santa and other gift exchanges?
Q
Comments (16)
I host a similar gift swap at a party I do every summer. Out of season right? But the point of the game is to have fun which we always do. I call it the Greed Game, mainly because that's what it was called the first time I ever played it years ago at a Christmas party, but also because that is the whole point of the game: greed! I've found over years of playing it that these things hold true: 1. People LOVE to unwrap a present 2. If you get a low number (one of the earlier pickers in the game) there is a good chance that the game will not be fun for you, in the event that you pick a gift no one else wants to steal. It's not fun to watch everyone else stealing and laughing and having a good time while you sit there with an undesirable gift. So here are the rules we play by, which seem to work very well. Everyone draws a number. Round ONE consists of everyone unwrapping a new gift. Round TWO is for stealing. #1 looks at his/her gift and decides to either keep or steal. If keeping, play moves to #2. If stealing, #1's gift goes on the table and #1 steals from someone else who we will call 1a. 1a can take the gift on the table or steal from another person (1b). 1b can take the gift on the table or steal from another person (1c). 1c must then take the gift from the table. Once the gift is taken from the table, whether it be by 1a, 1b or (forced) 1c, #1's turn is over and play moves to #2 who initiates another round of stealing if desired. Within one player's turn (#1, 1a, 1b and 1c for example) a gift can be stolen only once. However, once that person's turn is over and stealing play moves to the next player, all gifts are again available for stealing. This method allows everyone to open a new gift AND to have an opportunity to steal. The stealing goes on AFTER all the gifts have been opened so that people can decide what they want based on complete information. There is still no guarantee that everyone will go home with the gift they wanted, but that is never guaranteed. The fun of this game is in the stealing, thus the "greed". So when everyone opens a new gift and everyone can also steal, it's the fun of the game that becomes the star instead of what gift you end up with. The gift you end up with is more of a bonus for participating in the game. I will say that the gifts need to be imaginative. If everyone brings a gift card, there won't be much fun in either opening or stealing. And it doesn't matter if the gifts are worth $5 or $50. Again, because the point is the fun of the game and the gift is merely a bonus. I hope you have fun no matter what you decide to do!!
...See More
Chemocurl zn5b/6a Indiana
15 years ago
I too would 'not' feel obligated to give 'something/anything' in return. Could you maybe take them out to 'eat' sometime instead and it be your treat?
heather_on
15 years ago
I like the idea of just taking them out for a meal too. Getting together with a friend is the gift that really counts.
carla35
15 years ago
If it's really gotten to the point of obligatory gift cards, it's really not gift giving IMO.

If you have the time and money, then I'd find personal gifts (even inexpensive ones) are usually the best ideas for Christmas time. But I think gifts should be given with no expectation of receiving anything in return.

I think there are 2 kinds of people... those who like to give gifts and those who don't (or don't have the time or money to). Kind of like there are 2 types of people that bring stuff to Pot Lucks.... those who take the time to bring something homemade, and those who just bring swing by the store on the way and pick up some soda. There's not really a right or wrong; but there's two types of people. If you don't like giving gifts, that's fine but you should be able to accept a gift graciously. And those who like giving gifts should know not to over do it on those that may not want or be able to to recipricate.

To me, Christmas is about giving, but because you want to not because you have to... and NOT just for the kids (when you make it just about kids and their toys, it commercializes it IMHO, and it also teaches the kids they don't have to recipricate). If it's a time of love and sharing, everyone should be in on it and it's nice for kids to see that (and for them to be able to help pick out a gift for Uncle Tony). Now those gifts don't have to be expensive... they can be cookies the kids make or homemade ornaments or cards...oh wait, that may take too much time.

It's sad that the spirit of Christmas is lost... because people simply don't have the time to put any thought into anything... But they have time for other things.. Sorry, but I think a lot of it is about priorities and selfishness. God forbid you should have to pick out a real gift for your mother!

Quite honestly, I think the gift card people have won...they almost make you feel bad if you do get them anything other than a gift card. And, I know all the teenagers want is money or gift cards... but Kuddos to those aunts and uncles who think outside the box and get them something else on occasion. And, if it's really at a stage where all a kid will be happy with is cash/gift card, then maybe they should fall into the adult-no-gift category.
carla35
15 years ago
Sorry for my rant...

If you want to know how I handle it, this year, I'm getting gift cards for those people who give me gift cards, and investing the time in real gift giving for those who do the same for me. Funny, but those I'm investing the time in real gift giving are the people I love the most anyway... so it kind of works out. Maybe that kind of explains it all...
joann23456
Original Author
15 years ago
To me, Christmas is a spiritual time, a time when I like to reflect on Jesus coming into the world. (I totally get that it's also a secular holiday, and don't think people ought to think of it the way I do.) I do give gifts, but Christmas is not largely about gift-giving for me.

I do see what you're saying about letting children have the joy of helping to select the perfect gift for someone special to them, but that's not my friends.

I love the idea of dining together. In fact, I started a yearly tradition of having a special Christmas lunch with one of the friends, specifically saying that it could be our gift to one another, and she agreed - but she still got me the $35 gift certificate from CVS at Christmas.

Ah, well, I know it's not a big deal, and I'm so fortunate to have these two women as friends.
Georgysmom
15 years ago
You can do what I do with my friends. We started a Birthday Club. The Birthday Girl gets to pick what restaurant she wants to go to and we buy her lunch. Everyone brings a card and that's it.....no gifts. None of us needs or even wants anything anymore so this takes the place of all that. At Christmas, we go out for a special lunch......and I have a special group that goes to the club for dinner with our husbands. On that night we each have a small gift for each other and I mean small. This year I'm making Kahlua fudge sauce for everyone. Last year it was the Rolo pretzels. Just a little thought.
rosepetal2
15 years ago
what about making your own gift cards on the computer stating that you would treat the recipient (and you) to a meal at her favorite restaurant, she can arrange the date with you. Possibly add a little verse about friendship with her being such a special gift and how much you treasure her as a close friend.
Diane

How do you handle this common (I think!) gift-giving problem

Comments (9)

OklaMoni

jannie

Related Discussions

Chemocurl zn5b/6a Indiana

heather_on

carla35

carla35

joann23456
Original Author

Georgysmom

rosepetal2

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

How do you handle this common (I think!) gift-giving problem

Comments (9)

Related Discussions

joann23456Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

joann23456
Original Author