Hardware for a stranded door....horizontal handle? Vertical?

13 years ago

We have one solitary door in our kitchen layout (okay, more doors in reality but one true "door" that is functioning like a door) and I'm really stuck on what kind of hardware to use for it.

Has anyone encountered this, and if so, what did you do? Pics? Here's our situation:

- Half of our kitchen (on a separate wall) is flush inset cabinetry, and those doors are on the uppers and all getting latches, so they're set.

- The other half of our kitchen is frameless cabinetry, so can't use latches since there's no frame or paired door to attach the other side to.

- We have three physical doors: two on the sink cabinet, and one right next to it on a blind corner unit. Here's the catch: one sink door and the blind corner unit are actually pullouts, though they look like doors. This leaves just one actual door, sandwiched in between the two (and half of the sink cabinet).

DH is a believer in function over form, and in general I agree. We both want the pullouts to have centered horizontal handles.

But...what do we do with that last door? Function says we put the handle on it vertically, and I would be okay with this if there were another door in the kitchen, and if it weren't half of a paired set. But I'm worried it's just going to look strange if it's the only door in the whole kitchen done this way! That leaves centering it horizontally like the pullout handles, but that's strange for opening it.

Is there another solution I'm missing? Anyone do this one way or another and like/dislike your decision? Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

palimpsest
13 years ago
I have a finger pull mounted in the middle of the only two doors in my entire base cabinet set up and it is not that weird opening them. You get used to it immediately.
breezygirl
13 years ago
I'm probably mentally challenged tonight, but I can't picture your set-up with half a sink cab. Do you have a photo?

Are you storing something in there that you will accessed often? I remember reading a long time ago that some people put horizontal pulls on doors and said it wasn't awkward opening. I've never had mine that way, but I agree that it does sound strange for opening/closing. Maybe if you won't access it often, it wouldn't bother you.
Related Discussions
Inexpensive "build on your lot" builders?
Q
Comments (63)
I built a beach house with Hiline Homes 2 years ago. I actually blogged about it specifically so people could see what our experience was like because I too could not find anything online. I haven't updated the blog with what the house has been like since we moved into it because I got burned out. But overall, I think the house was pretty solidly built. The build experience was far from perfect but that is also true of my sister's super high end build that I got to hear about going up as well. I will say the fixes and responses to getting things fixed on the higher end home were a lot better than what Hiline has done. But our house itself seems like a very good value to me. All inclusive with our land, permits, driveway, excavation/ground prep, etc, we paid about $118 per sq foot. With the builder we quoted with, the cost would have been $160 per sq ft. and the quality at that price would have been comparable to Hiline's since the builder also would have been using similar materials to get their quote that low. (By similar materials I mean the finishing touches like countertops, carpet, flooring, etc. They would have used the same construction materials, and in some cases, Hiline's construction materials were actually nicer.) So, I think you could go with one of these companies and come out okay, though I can only speak for one of them. We had a terrible project manager but he was fired after our build. Hopefully their next one is better.) Here's a link to my blog if you want to read about it. I always meant to go back and pull out the salient details that people would want to know, but I never did. So it's mostly an online journal, I'm sure it's incredibly painful to read! http://myhilinehome.com/
...See More
Down to the last three choices for garage door..need input
Q
Comments (13)
Ah, thanks for responding, lyban :) Well, we need 4 windows because we found a residential ribbed door that is *better* built than the "commercial" door I first found (except for insulation--but it's got a lifetime warranty on *everything* including springs, and is thicker steel--it's the Amarr Heritage 3000, if anyone's interested), and it comes with 4 windows rather than 3. I really wish we could do 3 but we can't. 3 would have made it unique. What I mean about painting the stiles and rails on the Westfield is that what happens a lot is, instead of painting the whole door the same color, painting the raised crosspieces the same color as the house trim color. So it sounds like the many directions of siding and ribbing don't bug you--I just wanted to make sure that it wouldn't have the effect egganddart had mentioned--but now I think it will actually work, since it's not an interruption of the lines of the house but rather a continuation. I guess the flush panels could be seen as more of an interruption, actually, since we don't have any flush areas on the house. lyban, I owe you one :) (and spanky, and eggandddart, and scottmel and kswl and mimi and squirrel and lindybarts and amysrq and so many other folks here -- I feel like my soon-to-be-restored house facade should have a credits page :))
...See More
Can I see a picture of your trash pull out ?
Q
Comments (38)
schicksal- what kind of garbage bins are those? I really like them! oh, to answer the original question. no pic yet because my pulls are on backorder, however I chose an extra long pull for my garbage/recycle pullouts (12"). There is no drawer above it (I have outlets above my trash pullout). I chose the extra long pull for two reasons: 1) easy to pull open (I guess I was thinking no matter where you grab the handle is there) 2) can hang a towel on it the pull does match the other pulls in the kitchen though, as far as style
...See More
where to use knobs vs handles--pix requested
Q
Comments (7)
In trying to keep it mimimals we went with only pulls, vertical on doors and horizontal on drawers and pull outs (this may be a good way to determine where to place the pulls and knobs as buehl has done). Mix of knobs and pulls can be a great look. This cabinetry product comes with the split top drawers and while my Mom initially thought she would do two handles on her 30" pot drawers she opted for just one in the end (a vignette with just a knob on 30" drawers tipped the scale). She also opted to place the pulls on the deep drawers at the same distance from the top as on the shallow drawers. For symmetry she had the handle on the recycling pull out placed at the same height as the ones on the adjacent drawers. With the reduced rails on the drawers of this product the pulls would not have looked right installed on them. On her 4 drawer bank.
...See More
artemis78
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks! No photos yet sadly as cabinets aren't in quite yet, but if you imagine a normal-looking sink cabinet, the door on the left side has a pull-out trash can inside it, so inside there's a track for it (with concealed hinges on the right-hand door, so you can't tell that the functions on the two halves of the cabinet are different from the outside). I'm thinking the non-trash side will probably house cleaners and such (plus the plumbing's all on that side so there's not a huge amount of space left)---but dishwasher tablets would also live there, so daily use likely.

The more I think about it, the more I think they need to match, regardless of orientation. I'm thinking it will be easier to get used to a horizontal handle on a door than to a vertical handle on a pullout (though I remember a thread where people did that and thought it worked fine too....just seems odd!) Hmm....
breezygirl
13 years ago
Darn! I wanted photos! ;) I understand it now. I think you're right about what would be easier to get used to. I'm usually more function over form, but I would probably do horizontal also.

I'm curious about what Palimpsest mentioned.
artemis78
Original Author
13 years ago
Oh, believe me, I wanted photos too...our cabinet install was originally supposed to be today, but got bumped to Monday. *sigh* (Actually a good thing since we are way behind on painting and everything else in the DIY arena, so it meant we could finish the painting pre-cabinets---yay!---but still a little sad since I really want to SEE the cabinets already!)

We have everything but the kitchen sink now, though (I'm totally using that line for as long as I can, which is hopefully just until Monday afternoon, when the sink is supposedly getting delivered...) so the end is finally in sight. My neighbor asked how it was going this afternoon, though, and I excitedly told him we had the dishwasher at last, and he said "Oh, so it's all hooked up?" Err. C'mon, do you really have to rain on my parade?? :)
breezygirl
13 years ago
Having to wait until Monday must be torture! But you're so close! I love the kitchen sink line! I'm so going to steal it. We won't rain on your parade around here. Congrats on the DW.

So you HAVE to post pics on Monday. You must. You must!

Hardware for a stranded door....horizontal handle? Vertical?

Comments (6)

palimpsest

breezygirl

Related Discussions

artemis78
Original Author

breezygirl

artemis78
Original Author

breezygirl

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Hardware for a stranded door....horizontal handle? Vertical?

Comments (6)

palimpsest

breezygirl

Related Discussions

artemis78Original Author

breezygirl

artemis78Original Author

breezygirl

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

artemis78
Original Author

artemis78
Original Author