granite installation issues - please help

11 years ago

Hello! My uba tuba granite was installed on Friday. There were a few issues: the seam near the sink was noticeable from a distance (probably at least 3/16" wide), there are gaps behind sink between 3/16" and 5/16", they left a glob of cement on the side of a cabinet which when removed took of an area of my cabinet finish (can be fixed with the touch up paint, but this seems sloppy), sink cutout was lopsided by 3/8" (noticeable to me, not to others) and the island was not exactly what I ordered (it was off by 1/2" and I realize now that this issue was minor compared to the others.) The installer returned yesterday to look at the issues. My GC said if they could fix the seam, he could deal with the gap. They did something with the seam so it looked much better. Not sure what he did, but it is less noticeable now (our plumber even said it looked better). But now, the area around the seam is a bit duller than the rest of the counter. So the installer came out again today and apparently polished it with a wax (this is what they told my GC - I'm not home... trying to work with all this going on!) GC said when he wiped it down, the surface is not as shiny. I'm concerned they're trying to put a bandaid on the issue and that it will look awful in a week. Is it appropriate to put a wax on the granite to make it shiny, and if so, will it last? This area is right by the sink, so I'm concerned that I will be wiping it down a lot and the shine will go away. The installer also told my GC that the uba tuba needs to be sealed, but everything I read on the web says that uba tuba doesn't need to be sealed. BTW, I put a stop payment on my check that was the final payment, and won't pay them until they've fixed the issues. Thanks for your help!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

User
11 years ago
Typical low budget no skills work. You did the right thing putting a hold on the check, but the bigger issue is that they just may not have the skills to make it right. If they tried to field polish with a handlheld, then no wonder it's not shiny by the seam. You've got to use water and much finer abrasives than you can do dry to get an acceptable edge polish. Uba Tuba fabricators are everywhere though. So I'm sure you can find someone else to replace it if you can't get these guys to. I'd expect a decent quality fabricator to charge you $45-$50 a square foot for UT and not leave you with that mess. But you have to actually view jobs that they've done and the seams that they did before you pick them.
Rose1614
Original Author
11 years ago
Thanks Hollyspring, We did pay $50 sq ft. Looking at the dull spot this morning, it's on both sides of the seam (on two pieces of granite.) We're still left with the gap between the wall and granite and now this issue of the dullness around the sean. Is it possible to get a full refund? I don't know if I trust them to take the granite out and replace it.
Related Discussions
Help, please! Subway tile installation issues
Q
Comments (12)
Here's several sources of irregularities in a tile installation: Unless the tile installer shimmed out the backing to compensate for any wavy studs, you will have a wavy backing, and the tiles will follow the waves ... occasionally one will hit the crest of a wave just right and you have a corner like you see. 2 - With a square-edged tile all the tile installer has to do is wipe ALL the grout off the face of the tiles and it's all even. With a rounded edge the visible grout width will vary depending on how much grout is wiped away from the rounded edge to reveal the joint. That's part of the "charming hand-made" look. Had they known that you wanted machine-like precision in the grout lines they may have been able to warn you that the rounded edges of that tile are not conducive to precise grout joint appearance unless you want to pay for someone to use calipers and Q-tips on all the joints. 3 - Tile size variation depending on where they were in the kiln. It's tiny, but it adds up over the course of several rows of tile. 4 - Those spacers are not "machined" they are cast or pressed into the clay before it's fired, and subject to shrinking. They are a help to the tile setter, not any guarantee of absolute precision. ---------------- As for the spacers, unless your walls were perfectly squared and ceiling perfectly level, some of the joints probably needed to be widened a scooch so the tiles would line up properly with the tiles on the other wall. the easy way to do this is to slip a spacer into the joint and twist it. My tile installer (and contractor) had to compensate for a 1 inch difference between one side of the alcove's rear wall and the other. He did it by starting about three rows up from the rim of the tub and widening the grout gaps a tiny bit on the high side, tapering back to normal on the low side. It looks great, but it took him the better part of three days to do all the measuring, marking, and scooching, then letting each couple of rows set up so he wouldn't mess it up with the next rows.
...See More
Granite installed, small issue, too picky?
Q
Comments (7)
Oh Dear you must be really disappointed. You are not being too picky at all. I would bet, you are being very nice and polite. I am disappointed with your installers. They need to fix this today! I demand perfection or pretty dark close from my installers and they deliver every time. A good installer /fabricator will come out with special tools and fix the drawer so it can open. A sander of sorts. At no extra cost. You paid for installation they need to install properly. For the edge on the other area to be level they may need to re-install or lift and place shims to level this. It should be close to perfect. Maybe a centimeter off but not as you describe. If you can post images that would be really helpful. There are some great Granite Gurus on this site who can chime in and tell you how you can handle this. Keep in mind it may take them another full day to fix this but they have to do it. Don't give up, be firm, strong and in your kind way insist they fix this. ~boxer
...See More
Help Please! Granite Install Splotches
Q
Comments (27)
Today the owner, the original salesperson and the original fabricator visited. They acknowledged it looked bad. But, they will not replace the stone as they say this is what I wanted. LOL! I said, "The slabs I personally approved were NOT splotchy and streaked. The slabs I approved did not have machine marks. This is most certainly not what I wanted." I did acknowledge that on the day of approval I saw a small portion near the end of the slab that was duller - as if the leathering did not take. I specifically told the fabricator to not use that portion and he agreed. They said I probably didn't see the splotches and streaks because the slabs were vertical and outside. I said then that is their fault not mine as they are the experts. And they still used the area I said not to use as well. After much back and forth, the owner and fabricator questioned whether or not my counter was sealed. Of course the guy said yesterday that it was. After they left without solution (and promising to get back to me), their secretary called. They are sending some "specialist" tomorrow to try to remove these areas AGAIN. The secretary told me they thought it might be grease marks absorbed into the stone. ??? I do know that when the stone is dry these areas are DARKER. When the stone is wet, these areas are LIGHTER. Stone? Sealer? Grease?
...See More
Issue with Granite Countertops installation...
Q
Comments (33)
I'm glad to hear this, hollr. I know that some of the fabricators here have said that a "fix" is acceptable, but if it were me, I wouldn't have been happy with a countertop that was sitting that far away from the wall, even if they were able to hide the big gap by putting the granite splash over it. Being able to adequately make something "look" right when it isn't is not an acceptable fix IMHO. This, of course, is from a homeowner's viewpoint, not an installers viewpoint. I would want the job done right. Period.
...See More
rocketmomkd
11 years ago
I'm sorry to hear about your problems with the granite install. I can share a bit about what happened with mine- At the time of our install of absolute black, everything looked great to me. But by the next day I found several small scratches in various places. I called the company and they sent the guys out to fix it. I asked if they could buff the scratches out somehow and they said there was no way to do that without taking the shine out of the granite. They used a couple different solutions and they worked to hide the scratches. Since you weren't there you really don't know what they did to your seam. I'd ask for a detailed description of what they did and ask how they are going to shine your granite up again. I doubt they will refund all your money, but keep on them to get it fixed!
Rose1614
Original Author
11 years ago
Thank you for your thoughts. I'm on day 3 (wed, thursday and now friday) with the company not coming out or returning my call. I still have 1/2 of their payment, so they're losing out by fixing the problem. I understand they have other jobs to do, but just return my call and tell me how and when they're planning to fix it. Unbelievable.
debrak_2008
11 years ago
Call repeatedly. Go to the business location. They want you to give up.
PRO
Granite City Services
11 years ago
you might have a better option than a tear out.

it does sound like the fabricator tried to top polish the seam. On darker colors it takes real craftsmanship to restore the factory polish after grinding a seam but is is possible. If you (or the GC) can find another fabricator with the skill to top polish then your problem could be resolved without a tear-out/re do.

Wax should not be considered as an option as it won't last AND it's not acceptable (or legal) for a food prep area anyway.

It's a little late for this but in general it's a bad idea to locate a seam immediately proximate to the sink.

granite installation issues - please help

Comments (6)

User

Rose1614
Original Author

Related Discussions

rocketmomkd

Rose1614
Original Author

debrak_2008

Granite City Services

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

granite installation issues - please help

Comments (6)

User

Rose1614Original Author

Related Discussions

rocketmomkd

Rose1614Original Author

debrak_2008

Granite City Services

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Rose1614
Original Author

Rose1614
Original Author