skip to main content

Mud Set vs. Thin Set

13 years ago

My interior designer is telling me that I need to decide quickly whether my ceramic tile backsplash will be mud set or thin set as this apparently has some impact on the electrical work that needs to be done to add outlets to the kitchen. The electrician is coming in two days. What are the pros and cons of the two installation methods? Will the final backsplash have a different appearance depending on the installation method?

Your thoughts are very much appreciated.

Featured Answer

sombreuil_mongrel

13 years ago

The only way I could see doing a mud job in a kitchen on the walls, is if the entire wall surface was to be tiled, floor to ceiling. Some commercial kitchens, with unfitted stainless steel work stations are built like this so the entire room can be steam cleaned as needed. But for a backsplash? Do you want to lose another 1" of counter depth? That's how thick a mud job is going to be.
casey

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

plllog
13 years ago
I think this is a good explanation. If Bill is around he'll have a more specific answer for you.

I have tiled counters and walls that aren't straight, so it wasn't just a backsplash issue for me. Mine is the cured mud with thinset application version. My glass tile backsplash in my laundry is as well, with an anti-fracture membrane. My floors are on a floated levelling layer of cement goop and anti-fracture membrane.

If you have mud and a good tiler, you have a nice, smooth, level continuous surface. Always with tiling, the better the substrate the better the tile job. There are other ways to treat a wall which give perfectly good backsplashes, however. If you have traditionally wet set tiles they'll never ever come out. Ever. The only way to remove them is to break them, though I suppose, if you were patient, you could dig out the grout, then use wires to wiggle in and dig out the mud until you loosened a tile, or something like that. That's also where you'll get a crack in an earthquake because tiles don't bend. With the thin set, you can get cracks along the grout instead of right through the tiles. No one really does wet set anymore, however. Certainly not for a backsplash. I think mud sets may be thicker than "thin" sets, seeing as how those are thin, but that depends on how the wall is prepared.

That's my experience, anyway.

You'll have to talk to your tile setter to really know what's up.
judi82
Original Author
13 years ago
Thank you, plllog, for your comments and the link. They helped inform my decision. I never thought there would be so many decisions to make with a kitchen remodel! It has really been an education for me.
Related Discussions
Pros: Advice on waterproofing and mud set shower walls?
Q
Comments (0)
I am remodeling a bathroom and I want the shower to be flush with the drywall so a chair rail can run all the way through it. A tile guy wants to do a mud set right on the studs. Is this possible in the 1/2" thickness of the drywall so it can be flush? He would put tar paper then the lath, scratch coat and mud. It would have a vinyl pan (he says that is easier to do with mud walls vs hardibacker) and he said he would put Redguard on the walls up to about 3 ft off the shower floor for extra waterproofing protection. Would that create a "moisture sandwich" with the tar paper as I have read about, or is it OK if the redguard doesn't go all the way up the walls? I find the whole distinction between vapor barrier/moisture barrier/waterproof confusing. Also, are mud set walls worse for efflorescence stains on the grout than hardibacker with redguard on top? Thanks!
...See More
mud job vs. kerdi
Q
Comments (3)
If he does mud walls, is something else needed though (on top), besides the paper behind it? No, just as with a thinset installation, all that's needed is the vapor barrier, which is what the tar paper is. This where the advantage of the Kerdi comes in. WIth a standard mud or thinset installation, the sub surface still gets wet. With Kerdi, being that it's a waterproofing membrane that sits on top of the mud of cement board, the only thing that gets wet is the tile and grout. And by a conventional pan on the bottom, do you mean doing a mud preslope, membrane, then mud again?, then thinset and floor tiles? Do I have this out of order or is there some other layer that needs to happen in there? no, you've got it right. OR, we could see just how good a mud mechanic he is, and see if he'll set and grout it the same time as he floats it the second time! :-) That's a TRUE (monolithic) mud job. *stirrin the pot* I got to proof reading this, and I had to add this disclaimer-- If he's doing thinset over the mud, that's the normal way it's done today, and there's nothing wrong with it, so don't get scared if he brings in the bags of thinset!! :-)
...See More
White marble tile on top of dark gray thin set...help
Q
Comments (3)
I don't think the color is a problem as your thinset should cover the color of what's under it. BUT ... metal mesh? It requires a thick (1.5" mud bed). Since you initially confused what he used with thin set, I'm guessing that you've got what's called a "scratch coat" with your lath. That's a big no-no..... If you're not doing the mud bed then the alternative is Ditra, not scratch and mesh. I'd try posting over on bathrooms and asking Bill V or Mongo to weigh in since they're the tile experts. I know just enough to be dangerous. :) Good luck!
...See More
Stainless steel vs. anodized -- buying first set, need advice
Q
Comments (3)
I own both anodized and stainless (high end) cookware. I prefer to use the anodized because, well, it performs better. Why is that? Aluminum simply conducts heat better than stainless steel. Manufacturers of SS cookware will either sandwich a thin sheet of aluminum between two sheets of SS ("clad" or "Tri-ply"), or bond a thicker sheet of aluminum to the bottom of the cookware, in order to get the benefits of aluminum with the aesthetics of SS. These processes vastly improve the performance of the SS cookware, but solid aluminum will always provide superior heating properties. And, that's why anodized is becoming the "rage". Purists and those that know and understand these properties prefer the performance of anodized. But most of today's stainless steel cookware can boast very good performance characteristics, and for those who prefer the aesthetics of SS, are a good choice. If you love the look and feel of stainless, go for it. Both sets you're looking at should perform well. But it will be in YOUR kitchen, YOU will have to look at it, YOU will have to use it every day. Easy, huh?
...See More
bill_vincent
13 years ago
The difference is with mud, the wall is built from the studs out with mortar, whereas with thinset, either sheetrock or cement board is attached to the studs, and then in either case, it's the tiled over. The mud job is definitely the stronger installation. It's usually also much flatter, as it's one continuous surface, and doesn't depend o the studs all being perfectly in line. But usually, thinset is adequate in all respects for a tile installation. Alot cheaper, too, being that not very many installers any more know how to float mud walls, and those that do, usually charge a hefty premium.

The reason your GC needs to know is that the electrician needs to set his electrical boxes according to how thick the wall will be. With cement board or sheetrock, that's 1/2". With mud, it's usually closer to 3/4-1".
plllog
13 years ago
Oh! Casey pointed out something I'm too used to. My laundry backsplash goes to the ceiling. The wall was very slanty. It's flat now. :)
judi82
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks, all. Given that my walls are flat, I've decided to go with the thin set. I have a small kitchen and really don't want to loose that extra inch of counter space.

Related Stories

BATHTUBS World of Design: 12 Soothing Bathtubs in Rejuvenating Settings

From baths with ocean views to tubs set amid lush gardens, these spaces are designed to relax mind, body and soul

DIY PROJECTS Dining Set Makeover: Paint and Tea-Tinted Fabric Make Old Chairs New

By Sarah Greenman

Reclaim dated dining chairs for far less than buying new, using spray paint, modern fabric and a handful of tea bags

URBAN GARDENS A Dynamic Backyard Design Embraces Its Urban Setting

By Annie Thornton

A New York City outdoor space comes to life with a curvy new brick patio, thoughtful outdoor furnishings and evergreen foliage

COLOR Set the Mood: 5 Colors for a Calming Bedroom

By Jennifer Ott Design

Stressed? Can't sleep? Consider one of these cool, soothing hues for your walls

KITCHEN DESIGN How to Set Up a Kitchen Work Triangle

By Vanessa Brunner

Efficiently designing the path connecting your sink, range and refrigerator can save time and energy in the kitchen

LIGHTING Decorating With Antiques: Set the Stage With Lighting

By Mike Dietrich

Complete a vintage scene or create contrast with lamps, sconces and chandeliers that have traveled through time

HOLIDAYS Luxurious Holiday Table Settings for Less

By Apartment 46 for the Home

Pair colorful glasses, gorgeous garden finds and hand-stamped napkins for a holiday table that looks positively rich

COLOR PALETTES Set the Mood: 4 Colors for a Romantic Bedroom

By Jennifer Ott Design

Bring your love of color — and the colors of love — into your master bedroom

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Set Your Shade Garden Aglow With Light

By Jay Sifford Garden Design

Invite brightness to the dark corners of your garden for a magical dance you won't want to miss

DECORATING GUIDES Set the Right Mood With the Right Lines

By Design With Science

Soothe with curves or go straight-up efficient. Learn the effects of lines in rooms to get the feeing you’re after

Sponsored

More Discussions

can anyone share picture of Silestone Lusso countertop

1

contractor chooses kitchen

33

Are counter installers covering a mistake?

8

Pendant Suggestions for updated kitchen

1

wood wrap for under the island

2