Have you gel stained your oak cabinets?

14 years ago

We don't have $ in our budget to do a complete kitchen remodel, so we're looking at trying to gel stain our '90s oak cabinets a darker color, putting on new hardware and replacing the laminate countertops with silestone or starone. Have you gel stained your existing oak cabinets and have pictures? How intense was the gel stain application? Did you have to sand everything down, or just apply to clean surface? What kind of countertops are best for existing oak cabinets? I've heard that placing granite on top is not a good idea, because it so heavy.

Featured Answer

HappyCampers

12 years ago

I just wanted to add to this. I just found this thread as we were starting to stain our cabinets. We LOVE Old Masters wiping stain in Rich mahogany! It took a little trial and error to get the right application. What worked really well was to take a white soft bristle paint brush and just barely touch the tips to the stain, wipe that off on the can. I am telling you, you don't want hardly any stain at all on your brush. Then paint it on the cabinets. I went back and forth and up and down to make sure I filled in all the little places on the cabinets. When I was happy with it I went back over it with the brush in the direction of the grain, do not wipe off the stain. Let it dry overnight then repeat to get an even coat. I am amazed at how well this worked and how beautiful it is. I tried the gel stain and it was a mess for me. I couldn't get a consistent finish. With this you can work it until you are happy with it and it is so thin it drys really well. When we get some done I will post pics. The thing that makes me the happiest is that they look stained not painted. You can still see the wood grain but you can't really tell that it is oak at all. The heavy grain just fades into the background. Now I just have to figure out what to use for my clear coat.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

neesie
14 years ago
You heard that oak cabinets can't support granite? Glad I didn't hear that before I replaced mine! The silestone estimmate came within $200 of the granite and to me there was no comparison. Good luck with your remodel, you'll get all kinds of advice here.
desertsteph
14 years ago
add some trim at the top?

i've also found silestone to be in the price range of granite. there are some very nice looking laminates these days. check websites for Formica and Wilsonart...some you can get in different finishes like etched, matt, etc They will send you free samples if you call them. Wilsonart charged 1.00 for the larger pieces. no big deal - worth seeing it in real - and a decent size.

hardware, new counter top and trim (also on backside of peninsula) will make a huge change. so would different paint color. the stain also.

is there a place somewhere on cabs (inside?) where you could test out stain on it?

add some color into the area?
Related Discussions
Do you have Bona finish or stain on your oak floors?
Q
Comments (6)
I wish I had a photo to show you. We used Minwax English Chestnut on our stairs and lower level remodel. It is a rich, deep, true brown with no orange, red, or gray tones. Upstairs, the floors were sanded and given three coats of Bona urethane over no stain. I didn't love the paler color, but the finish wore like iron. On the main floor, we had the existing oak floors sanded and redone, using two coats of Minwax Cherry. Then we put new oak floors in the kitchen and had them matched to the rest. I do have photos showing those floors, if it's any help. They may be more orange than you want. These are the original floors, refinished: The new flooring in the kitchen:
...See More
Where did you buy your gel stains?
Q
Comments (13)
I found the gel stains SO much easier to work with than the thin stains because they were pretty much idiotproof. Wipe on, wipe off. Very Karate Kid. :-) No worries about blotching, lap marks, uneven penetration from board to board, raising grain (almost inevitable with water-based stain), or drips/runs on vertical surfaces. I was even able to get different species and subspecies of wood to come out the same color, which is very difficult to do with the thin stains. Goodness knows I wasted enough good wood trying! A friend and I stained what seemed like acres :-) of oak beadboard and trimwork in my previous house in 2006 with Zar stain and it went very quickly. Cheap brush in one hand (the white-bristled "chip brush" worked really well) to apply, rag in the other to wipe off. I am sure everyone knows this already but rags used with oil-based products will be flammable until they are thoroughly dry. Lay them flat or hang them on a clothesline outside to dry out, don't wad them up in a pile. I ran out of rags in no time and had to buy a boxful at the hardware store; if a thrift store near you has the ratty clothes sold "by the pound" go pick out all the t-shirts you can get and cut them up, but it was cheaper for me to get the boxed ones. Oil-based products will dissolve latex gloves so get nitrile ones - those are labeled "non-latex" and are usually blue or purple. Cheapest by the box of 100 at the drugstore and have a bazillion uses! Recoat time (if it's even necessary) was only 3 hours. The weather was very warm and humid so we opened all the windows and put fans in them but that was almost as much to keep us from dripping sweat all over our work - it didn't smell as bad as the regular oil-based stain, and although I bought a respirator I took it off after about an hour because the sweat was literally pooling in it (ewwwww) and I was able to work with the stain without it with that good ventilation. I did have to leave the varnishing to my friend because I chose an oil-based varnish (SW Fastdry Oil Varnish) for a less "plasticky" appearance than polyurethane and because I wanted the "ambering" effect that you don't get with water-based products, and that was pretty smelly stuff. That was done the next day after the staining just because that's how the timing worked out. You can use water-based poly over an oil stain as long as you let the stained piece sit for several days in order for every trace of the mineral spirits to dissipate. About the "use oil stain to feed the wood" idea - it is a very common myth that you need to "feed" wood with oils. Manufacturers take advantage of this long-standing notion in order to sell you products. Wood does not need to be "fed" or "nourished", it's dead. Humidity and temperature changes, UV exposure, and water are what cause wood to deteriorate, not a lack of oil. Sure, wood will absorb oil (unless you apply it to wood with a film-forming finish such as polyurethane, varnish, etc.) which is also how a penetrating oil finish like Danish Oil or Waterlox works - but wood will also absorb water, alcohol, kerosene, lemonade, or pretty much any other liquid that sits on an unprotected or minimally-protected wood surface. Oily substances can act as a slight protectant by repelling/preventing absorption of water to some degree, although a film-forming finish does so much more effectively, and can impart a somewhat shiny surface (as well as a gummy, dirt-attracting surface if overused), but they do not "feed" that tree corpse.
...See More
Would my kitchen be too dark if I gel stained my oak?
Q
Comments (15)
Sorry to bring up an old post - i'm hoping the OP is still around - my wife and I are looking to refinish our cabinets using this gel stain. It appears your cabinets are the exact same color and construction as ours. Our concern is even though the front fascia and doors appear to be real wood, the sides are laminate paper. Were your cabinets the same way? If so, did you notice a difference in finish color between the laminate and wood? How many coats did you apply? I took an old bool shelf which is the same color as the sides of our cabinets with laminate paper over particle board and when I went to stain it with General Finishes brown mahogany, it came out way way lighter then your door picture above which I assume is real wood. With the attached picture, each quarter in the test piece is a different sand paper grit. Top right is 600, Top Left is 400, Bottom left is 320 and bottom right is 150 grit. The more course, the darker it was we found. I personally like the 400 grit sample, but i'm afraid the doors and fronts won't match once stained. Hoping you can provide some advice! This post was edited by adgjqetuo on Mon, Jan 12, 15 at 15:00
...See More
Granite colors w/Java gel stained oak cabinets?
Q
Comments (1)
Bianco Antico is another one to consider. It looks similar to Delicatus but the darker spots are less angular than Delicatus. I love the General finishes java stain. We used it on a toy shelf. So easy to do and rock solid even after two yrs of use.
...See More
toomuchstuph
14 years ago
There was a member here years ago who did this. The results were absolutely AMAZING. I had bookmarked her photos and managed to dig up an old thread via google. The thread details the steps she took and links to before and after photos.

I think your kichen would look spectacular with the darker cabs and granite!

Here is a link that might be useful: CelticMoon's stained kitchen
hamsundm
14 years ago
I did! This is what we started with...

After gel stain:

very difficult to get good photos:

We've made additional changes to our kitchen so I should get some newer photos. The gel stained cabs have held up extremely well. The process was pretty easy. Just cleaned well, lightly sanded and used general finishes java gel stain. Let me see if I can find a link to my 'directions'...
hamsundm
14 years ago
I pretty much followed celticmoon's steps... (THANK YOU celticmoon!! :)

My process:
Remove doors. Remove hardware. We did leave hinges on and taped them off. (DH was afraid he'd never get them back on and didn't want to mess with getting new -- I picked my battles and went with it! ;)

I lightly sanded mostly using sanding sponges which allowed me to get into the cut-outs better. My doors were VERY shiny so I sanded enough to get the shine off. Then tack clothed them, then mineral spirits.

I put on a thick layer of General Finishes Gel Stain - JAVA. This stuff is so awesome. Then I wiped off. I left it on pretty thick... too thick. If I was to do it over I would definitely wipe off more because it took a loooong time to dry. I was trying to skip steps but I think 2 or 3 thin coats would have been better. It was a rainy weekend, too, so drying was tough in the first place.

DH had rigged up a way for me to hang the doors by the hinges so I hung them to dry which enabled me to do fronts and backs. When they were finally dry I did a thin layer of General Finishes Gel Clear Coat. I spread it on until it all looked wet but wiped away any drips. Once dry I very lightly sanded, then tack clothed, then we put the doors back on. I did another clear coat with the doors up and left the doors open to dry.
I've done a few touch ups here and there with a stain and a clear coat.

I would highly recommend general finishes gel stain! I babied the cabs for a few days but my 3 and 5 year old kiddos have not and the color seems to be holding up perfectly.
desertsteph
14 years ago
oh - that looks great!
toomuchstuph
14 years ago
projects - if it wasn't for the general layout, I'd swear that wasn't the same kitchen. Gorgeous work!!
bcnebunch
Original Author
14 years ago
Still no progress. We wanted to hold off until we decided on the countertops. We began leaning toward Wilsonart HD laminate, but that has come up to around $2600 installed...a little expensive in my opinion.
hale_izoom_net
13 years ago
Hi, this looks great! @ projectsneverend- what color are your original hinges? Mine are 20 yr old brass, but messing with hinges is a step I would gladly skip if I can get away with it. Any tips? Thanks! I plan on using Old Masters gel stain- probably a rich mahogany over my 80's oak cabinets.

Have you gel stained your oak cabinets?

HappyCampers

Comments (10)

neesie

desertsteph

Related Discussions

toomuchstuph

hamsundm

hamsundm

desertsteph

toomuchstuph

bcnebunch
Original Author

hale_izoom_net

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Have you gel stained your oak cabinets?

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

bcnebunchOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bcnebunch
Original Author