We did it several years ago: replaced all door on our cabs, which had been typical builder-grade thermofoil construction. We use simple flat doors with only modest detailing, had them painted on site. They were relatively inexpensive and looked quite good. It was enough of an improvement to convince us to put off the kitchen renovation (which we are now beginning) for several years.

I would say, absolutely go for it! I kept most of my existing cabs and had them refaced (new doors and stain). Since it was a matter of staining and needing a new section of cabs built, I had a local cabinet maker do it all. But, in a painting situation, it would be so much easier.

I have read many good things about Scherr's and don't think you could go wrong with that one plan of yours. Call them up so you can be advised as to the best hinges and bore holes for the doors so ordering the doors and hanging them will go smoothly. They will make the holes for you.

Good luck and let us know what you decide to do!

I am not positive but I think kitchen magic is a franchise, and with that, they might vary from franchise to franchise. I would check specifically in your area - maybe to see a few actual kitchens and definitely check with better business bureau. I think someone here did use them and it was a great job (it was quite a while ago, the new cabs were white and I think she had pale green walls... if anyone else knows what I am thinking of)... but the key is to make sure the one in your area is good as well.
good luck and as others have said,,, keep us posted.