Stained Baseboard vs Painted

13 years ago

We have a typical 70's house in that all the trimwork and doors are stained. We recently painted the bathroom vanity white (looks so much better). We have 5" baseboard that's stained as well as the window trim, linen closet doors and trim (you get the idea). What I would like to do is paint the baseboard (either same color as walls or white). But since I would still have stained everything else I'm wondering if that's a good idea??? Also, I've considered painting the window trim & door trim, but leave the doors and window stained? To me the stained baseboard just stands out and doesn't do a thing for the pale gray walls. This would only be for the one bathroom (not the entire house) Any ideas?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

rj56
13 years ago
Dear Southerngal,
My typical 70's house also had stained trim. It was beat up and not very attractive. As I redid rooms, I sanded it, primed it, and painted it. When we added on, I decided on stained trim, as I noticed that I was always having to "touch up" the painted trim and we had 3 boys by that time. So, my house is a mixture. It seems most decorators see that as a no-no, but personally, it doesn't bother me. In the master bedroom, the trim around the window is stained (because we replaced the windows when we added on)but the other trim is painted. I'm too old now to think about having everything match.
creekylis
13 years ago
I have asked this question myself over several years and have finally come to a conclusion...

My house has stained trim (previous owner's choice). I personally don't care for stained trim, especially on horizontal surfaces such as base boards, because IMO it draws too much attention--like a person wearing an all-white outfit with a brown belt. (Again, just MY opinion.)

I have wanted to paint everything, but hesitate to paint the windows because I am afraid they will have issues opening, and quite frankly it just seems like too much work. So, I got the idea to just paint my base boards and door trim, leaving the windows, window trim, and doors (for now) stained. (I do not currently have crown moulding, but I would paint that too.) My thought is that the windows will be okay as an accent, sort of like a picture on the wall. Picture frames don't have to match your moulding, right?

Personally, I think this is one of those things that, if you point it out, people will always tell you the "rule" that all trim should match. However, if you DON'T point it out, no one notices. In fact, after I first asked this, I started doing some work in my own dining room and noticed that the previous owners had actually painted the base board and chair rail in the dining room to match the walls already---I was living here and didn't see that until I started preparing to redo the room myself.

So... I say, "go confidently in the direction of your dreams". I bet it will look GREAT! (And I'm right behind you!)

Lis
Related Discussions
pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork
Q
Comments (19)
I like a bright house. We have lots of windows and french doors and lighter shades of paint. Only our entry door is stained, and it is in a surround-sidelights that is painted. All our doors, frames, window casings, baseboards, etc. are BM 'white linen'. We are empty nesters in a traditional style house (not craftsman, etc.). The only 'little destroyer' visiting frequently is one grandson, age 3.5. I think our less expensive but solid manufactured wood doors and our trim can be repainted many times for what we would have spent on wood worthy of staining. An FYI about your cherry kitchen cabinets: I was told they tend to darken with age.
...See More
can I paint over stain splotches on baseboard?
Q
Comments (2)
Talk to the floor refinisher ... he should not be leaving stain splotches "all over the baseboards" A coat of primer, followed by repainting in the original color is all it needs, but unles you are also the refinisher, it's his mess.
...See More
Stained baseboard and the rest of the trim painted???
Q
Comments (3)
I had this in my living and dining of my old house. I did have base and crown be dark, doors, window and door casings were white. Here are a few pics. Floor, crown, base, and window visible a closer pic and a wider one. (sorry couldn't find one that showed a door.)
...See More
Paint or stain baseboards ?
Q
Comments (4)
You dont want your floors to match your doors anyway. What you have is a very nice contrast between the darker floors and the lighter doors and trim. It looks very good together. Its hard to restain doors and trim anyway, without removing every bit of finish. Stain doesnt sit on top, it has to be absorbed into the wood.
...See More
cat_mom
13 years ago
Our house is a hi-ranch/bi-level built in 1967, so it's a similar style and era as yours.

Our doors and jambs are stained oak, and our pine windows and window moldings are stained to match the oak. Like you, we hated the thought of chipped paint and the endless round of touch-ups (been there, done that!). If the stained moldings, doors, or window frames do happen to end up with a scratch or nick, the Minwax stain markers work really well (our MB door and window took a beating during a recent reno--I went to work on them with the marker pen and they look as good as new--really!).

For our base molding though, we opted to paint that the same color as the walls, but used a satin finish (instead of the matte finish on the walls). One, the cost of solid oak base molding for the entire house would have been astronomical. Two, we felt that the rooms would have looked shorter with the molding visually "cutting off" the bottoms of the walls.
callie25
Original Author
13 years ago
Do any of you have photos you can share with the changes you mentioned? I do think you're right, If you paint the baseboard the same color as walls, no one would notice. I would also paint all of my home's trimwork, BUT what a project that would be (and I'm through with home projects for a while). The baseboard in the one bath would be my last thing to do. Also, in that room I'm trying to go with a little bit of shabby chic (not there yet).
rj56
13 years ago
This is the window in our bedroom with the new stained trim.

In the same room, the original baseboard is painted white, but I also did the trim around the new closet stained

The baseboard is very narrow, so really do not want to accentuate it.
someone2010
13 years ago
I think the combination in jilljohn's bedroom looks very good because they both relate to another part. The windows and trim relate to the floor and the molding relates to the wall. It appears thoughtout neat and clean. Something a decorator would do to accent each area yet not delete from the total, rather add to it.
Beth Claxton
6 months ago
Thank you all!! I’m appreciative of this conversation. I have a 70’s home and asking the same question. Remembering the scuffed up white baseboards in my old home is making me reconsider and I’m investigating staining the baseboards to match the new wood flooring.