skip to main content

What is the best wood stain you can get?

15 years ago

What is the best wood stain a consumer can get, which can give the wood a "furniture like" dark color in 1 or 2 coats? Minwax is not it! Price is virtually not an issue..

Or do the dark stain that we see comes from toned dark coats? Anyways I want something with very fine pigment that penetrate really well and evenly.

It also needs to dry and ready to accept top coat without smearing and melting.

Thanks

Featured Answer

brickeyee

15 years ago

Aniline dye is still about the best colorant for wood.
It is available in 'basic' colors and also mixed shades.

It is actually rather easy to use and forgiving of application mistakes (it cam be lightened by wiping woth clear water, light sanding, or be easily bleached out).

Unlike minwax stain (and most others) it is not a pigment, but an actual dye, really just thin paint.
Especially in darker colors it starts to act like pint and obscure the grain of the wood.

While bobsmyuncle posted the factory finish regimen, many of the steps are actually designed to save time in a factory or allow use of lower quality wood.

Toning is done with colored lacquers to make color uniform after the dye has been applied.
On some furniture they forgo the dye completely and just use toning lacquer followed by a clear top coat.

A lot depends on the type and quality of the wood used.

I do 'one off' work, and use only first & second grade hardwoods.
Factories cannot afford these woods, so they routinely use lower grades and glue up for larger pieces.
They sometimes even leave sapwood and then color it to match the hardwood.

Here is a link that might be useful: J E Moser aniline dye

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

User
15 years ago
You need a wood dye. But, you also neewd to study finishing, there are several good books on the subject---all mine are still packed from the recent move.
bobismyuncle
15 years ago
The first thing you have to realize is that "furniture like" finishes are generally multi-step processes, often as many as 12-14 steps. That is why you are unlikely to receive the same results with one or two coats of #471 out of a can.

The steps may involve:
- bleaching
- sealing / wash coating
- spray stains
- wiping stains
- toners / shaders
- glazes

I could lead you to a number of brands, but since the ones I use are not available on the street, I have not tried too many of them. Look for places that cater to the professional finishing trade, whether it is local or mail-order.
Related Discussions
What's the best stain for pressure-treated wooden deck? ro pls
Q
Comments (9)
I cant belive you dug all that way back,,,2005 ??? Anyway,twp 116 requires cleaning and good weather for the overcoat, I have never had to strip a twp project of mine. I do have a past Wallet that put silkens over the twp I put on,,,now that project will require a lot of stripping. The thing with a project using pt for decking...... no I wont say that..hmmmmm not that either..... Preasure Treated yellow pine is pron to warping twisting shrinking splintering things like that when laying flat to the sun no matter how its fastened or what finish is placed on it. A person can use a bad finish and make matters worst like thompsons,silkins,cwf,aquatroll but really no finish is going to change the nature of yellow pine. J
...See More
What color wood dining table goes best on Jacobean stained floors?
Q
Comments (1)
IMO espresso colored wood was often Chinese junk why not look at something either darker wood not espresso or something completely different like metal and glass.. If you post some pics of the rest of your spaces it will be harder to advise
...See More
Can i get a beachy vibe with orange stained wood, or need to restain?
Q
Comments (3)
Beachy means 'bleachy'. That is to say the SUN will have BLEACHED all the colour out of ANYTHING left on the beach. The blue sofa is fine. It represents the blue of the ocean/lack/sea. The tiles are fine because they represent the colour of sand. The area rug and the wall art are helping. The rest of your furniture is from another style. All the strong orange is more of a mid-century modern vibe (think Eames chairs) OR from the country vibe (the legs on bench and table). The style of the wood isn't as important as the COLOUR. You are aiming for sun-bleached look. If the table/bench are on the low-end of the value-scale, then go ahead and have them painted up. The leather recliner and the leather footstool will be a harder fit.
...See More
Can someone please tell me what wood type & stain color to get this?
Q
Comments (1)
Duplicate post please delete. @Cait Link to other post
...See More
linnea56 (zone 5b Chicago)
15 years ago
Why do you just want to do one or two coats? Are you in a big hurry? The finishes most of the woodworking pros use will not be fast either. I would rather go slowly and build up just the right color I want. I have not heard about any stain smearing unless it was not allowed adequate drying time.
PoorOwner
Original Author
15 years ago
I am frustrated with minwax stain, it does not stain any darker after a number of coats, unless I leave it on, then it takes forever to dry.

just looking for something better with finer pigments (or dye)
Kamara
11 years ago
I completely agree that stains such as minwax etc. are really not the best you can get. Believe me when I say, I stain a lot of wood, and honestly, the best staining product that I have found so far; at a reasonable price is a product called Keda Wood Dye. This product comes as a kit, with 5 colors, and let's you make your own wood stain colors by simply adding hot water. The kit creates an exotic finish, based on the wood's graining. Check them out; it is a really good product for $9.99, with free shipping.
Good luck!
Kamara

Here is a link that might be useful: Keda Dye Inc.
sombreuil_mongrel
11 years ago
Tell us what species of wood, what the desired shade and effect is, and we can go from there; because as asked, there is no answer.
Casey
sloyder
11 years ago
gel stain might be a better option for you. Miniwax has always been a terrible stain.
jduren
11 years ago
You can have the best stain on the market but its not fool proof. The best stain will always be a users opinion and when a painter/finisher has mastered it its priceless. But even then there can be problems, non of us are immune.

I would suggest trial and error on scraps. If you want a deeper color with Miniwax you must leave on till it gels and blend in with a rag.
Kamara
11 years ago
The issue that you are experincing with the canned stain is that you cannot control the concentrations, or how it absorbs into the wood. That is why you are having to apply multiple coats. Pigments usually do not penetrate the wood fibers; instead they cover the wood's surface. That is why the color will fade faster using a stain like minwax etc., than if stained with dyes. Wood prep is crucial too, but if you are looking for more control, better finish results, and a longer lasting color in your stain, then try a kit like Keda Dye, or someone offering powder wood dyes. I have tried several stain types with my Grandpa, and they do yield the best results.

Thanks again, it is nice to share the info.

Related Stories

KITCHEN DESIGN Trending Now: 25 Kitchen Photos Houzzers Can’t Get Enough Of

By Mitchell Parker

Use the kitchens that have been added to the most ideabooks in the last few months to inspire your dream project

LIFE The Polite House: How Can I Kindly Get Party Guests to Use Coasters?

Here’s how to handle the age-old entertaining conundrum to protect your furniture — and friendships

MIDCENTURY HOMES Houzz Tour: How Can We Get Invited to This Awesome Midcentury Home?

By Mitchell Parker

A redwood-clad gem in California’s Marin County features a dreamy outdoor oasis with an open-door policy for the homeowners’ friends

HOUSEKEEPING How to Clean Grout — Stains and All

If your grout is grossing you out, this deep-cleaning method will help it look new again

HOUSEKEEPING Get Those Carpet Stains Out: Best Nontoxic Methods for Spot Cleaning

Banish blotches the safe way with pantry staples, to get your rugs looking as clean as the day they came home

DECORATING GUIDES Get Clever With Area Rugs for Warmth and Beauty

By Tiffany Carboni

Give feet a soft landing, protect your floor, hide a stain ... with area rugs in your arsenal, you can win any flooring battle

KITCHEN CABINETS Get the Look of Wood Cabinets for Less

No need to snub plastic laminate as wood’s inferior cousin. Today’s options are stylish and durable — not to mention money saving

REMODELING GUIDES Laminate Floors: Get the Look of Wood (and More) for Less

See what goes into laminate flooring and why you just might want to choose it

STUDIOS AND WORKSHOPS Your Space Can Help You Get Down to Work. Here's How

By Laura Gaskill

Feed your creativity and reduce distractions with the right work surfaces, the right chair, and a good balance of sights and sounds

ART 8 Ways Vermeer’s Work Can Make Its Mark in Your Home

By Karen Egly-Thompson

Go Dutch with stained glass, Oriental rugs, checkered floors and delft tile

Sponsored

RTS Home Solutions

3 Reviews

BIA of Central Ohio Award Winning Contractor

More Discussions

varathane vs DuraSeal

14

What type of oil on new floors

3

Window well preservation

5

Kitchen drawers - is this normal?

15

Matching wood stain to prefinished flooring

13