skip to main content

How to refinish a dresser that's meant to be painted

16 years ago

Hi. I am usually on the garden side of things but was delighted to see this forum too!

Ok, here's the situation..

-Dresser 5 drawers hight b-eautiful ornate brass handles.

-Beautiful curves to the fronts of drawers.

-Beautiful claw foot legs

-Nice wood beading details

It had been painted. I stripped it to within an inch of it's life, and got it down to the bare wood with no damage/knife marks etc. (My toothbrush method is awesome).

I wanted to stain it cherry or mahagony, and got going on that, but the worst of my fears was realized. The dresser appears to be constructed of several different kinds of wood which all take the stain differently, some parts barely take the color, others parts take deep color wherever the sanding left a little roughness. I'm guessing this baby was never meant to be anything other than painted with paint. -Or what we call "paint grade" wood.

Ok, but I am not a big fan of painted wood furniture.

Is any attempt to refinish it futile?

I did pull out a small can of the dreaded "polyshades" (Bombay mahogany), and believe this will leave a wood stain "like" color evenly on the wood, especially if I do a few coats. I would 00000 steel wool it at the end so it wasn't excessivly shiny.

Anyone have advice for me? If it's bad news or advice that I am wasting my time,.... bring it on, I can take it.

Thanks so much!

Kate

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

randy427
16 years ago
You could check out the faux finishing technique of 'graining'. You apply paint with combs, brushes and rollers in such a way that it looks like wood grain.
lindac
16 years ago
How old is the piece? Could it be a piece of antique "cottage furniture"...or perhaps you have not stripped it as well as it should be.
Can you post a picture?
Linda C
Related Discussions
Repairing finish on dresser without completely refinishing
Q
Comments (1)
Wood stain pens are a better choice than a Sharpie. I believe Minwax has a line of them. They come in a number of colors and go on much more thinly; you can "feather" them to blend and add additional layers to get the color darker. Most paint stores and the big-box home stores carry them.
...See More
refinishing dresser with laminate top
Q
Comments (13)
Whew! I'm glad I found this post again. .I had forgotten where it was!. .I went to Lowe's today and looked a the primer. Bin is made by Zinsser. My furniture is not a semi-gloss. .it's more like eggshell. You can certainly get a semi-gloss, it would look great. What I painted was actually a bedroom suite I had when I was growing up, my daughter used it then I painted it for my granddaughter, daughter did not want it shiney at all. It really was not hard to do at all. Just took a little time. While I am thinking about it. .you can e-mail me if you have any other questions. .DBFireWife@aol.com Just in case I have trouble finding my way back here again. .Debbie
...See More
Help me refinish my great-grandmother's dresser
Q
Comments (3)
The wood looks to be birch. I would apply a preconditioner, and then use a gel stain which gives better coverage than the oil base. With gel stain you kinda buff it on, rather than oil base that let soak in.
...See More
How to paint dressers and director's chairs?
Q
Comments (3)
I would also do spray paint on the chairs (I spray paint my outdoor chairs each season). I haven't had luck with painting dressers -- but I have seen the dressers beekeeperswife has painted and they were gorgeous! She used high gloss paint and a paint sprayer (vs spray paint). I will invest in one if I ever have the need again. Another option would be one of the many chalk paints. They seem to have a much more forgiving finish than traditional paint.
...See More
poodlepup
Original Author
16 years ago
I am guessing this piece is from the forties or fifties.
It looks like it was originally painted a cream color with gold (metallic) details. It was also sprayed, not brush painted.

I am just not a big fan of painted furniture.

So, here's what I've done.
-Just testing it out on 1 drawer. If it sucks, I'll just paint the thing white & be done with it.

It's completely stripped.
I did 1 coat of "polyshades" -Bombay Mahogany
Then 1 coat "polyshades" -dark walnut
Then final coat of polyshades -Bombay mahogany.

Steel wool the hell out of it between coats.

After the last coat I will sand it with 220,
then put 2 coats of oil based varathane.
The handles are solid brass, and look nice agianst the dark color.
I know everyone hates polyshades, but I don't know what else I could have done, except paint it with paint, and that would not have looked good with the brass handles.
The paint store guy told me polyshades is crap, (which I know) but if I use a good oil based varathane over it, it will just be providing even color.

It's still not too late to talk me out of it. I have only done 1 drawer.
I'll take pictures
homer_zn5
16 years ago
Even if the piece was made entirely out of maple, different maple boards will take stain differently than others, resulting in the problem you were having. In order to even out the stain, a lot of woodworkers/refinishers will first give the piece a "spit coat" of shellac, which seals the wood and allows for an even color of stain. If you want it to look dark and even, I would probably use a gel stain (Varathane makes a decent gel stain), or else you can just keep brushing on your oil stain like paint and let it dry until it is as dark as you want it.

I've used polyshades before, and can't say that I'm a fan. You're more likely to go nuts before you get a decent finish.

Related Stories

LIFE Reluctant DIYer’s Diary of a Dresser Makeover

By Becky Harris

Weekend project: Glossy new black-and-white dresser, hold the sandpaper

GREAT HOME PROJECTS What to Know Before Refinishing Your Floors

Learn costs and other important details about renewing a hardwood floor — and the one mistake you should avoid

GREAT HOME PROJECTS How to Refinish a Wood Deck

By Christine Tusher

Keep your deck looking its best — and save feet from splinters — by applying a new stain and sealant every year or so

COLOR Happy Color: A Rainbow of Dressers

By Jen L'Italien

A dresser is the perfect place to experiment with a bold shot of color for your mix

VINTAGE STYLE Flea Market Find: Vintage Dressers

By Michelle Gage | Interior Designer

Think beyond the bedroom when searching for your next dresser

DECORATING GUIDES Decorating With Antiques: Chests, Dressers and Buffets

By Mike Dietrich

Pretty, practical and versatile, antique chests add history and character along with storage

PAINTING What to Know About Milk Paint and Chalk Paint — and How to Use Them

By Karen Egly-Thompson

Learn the pros, cons, cost and more for these two easy-to-use paints that are great for giving furniture a vintage look

TRIM What Color Should You Paint Your Trim?

By Toronto Interior Design Group

Learn the benefits of painting your trim white, black, neutral, a bold color and more

DECORATING GUIDES Wake Up Tired Furniture With Paint, Paper and Fabric

Give ordinary pieces a new spin with crafty updates, like a fresh tabletop, decorated sideboard and wall-size pinboard

ANTIQUES Decorating With Antiques: Painted Furniture Brings the Eye Candy

By Mike Dietrich

Too much brown got you down? Lighten up with antique furniture decorated with artistic designs or awash in a lovely hue

Sponsored

More Discussions

Handrail paint advice needed

5

Architecture/design help for open concept 1st floor

4

Advice Needed on Installing a Wood Accent Wall

2

are these kitchen cabinets worth keeping?

2

Off topic question for the cabinet makers/woodworkers

6