skip to main content

2nd floor needs leveling

12 years ago

Hi all

I'm new to the site, so I apologize if I'm over lapping a topic or writing in the wrong area.

We are just waiting for a closing date on our first house which is an 1852 fixer upper ( I know great idea for a first home!)

At some point an extension was built, we think walls were built over an old staircase to the basement without adequate support. Over the years the floors have sloped to the left to the point where now there is a 5 degree angle from the center of the bedroom to the left side of the room.

My question is: How do I level the floors on the second floor? Should I just put up support beams in the basement to make it secure and then fake the level floor using plywood of something?

I'm going to be asking lots of questions over the next few months, my dad always says " there's no such thing as a stupid question", I have a feeling some people may disagree once they see some of mine!

Featured Answer

sombreuil_mongrel

12 years ago

Only a structural engineer can make determinations (that would hold up contractually or in court) as to the cause or the solutions. If you are determined to fix it permanently, the remedy could be very far ranging and costly.
We had to delve very deep into the structure of an 1815 house to fix the 7" of sag (over 11 feet!) that was the result of bad original design and made far worse by a 1920 remodeling, that removed bearing walls from an already-underbuilt floor. The solution included gutting two floors, eight footers in the basement, a new first floor system, 5 steel columns and even one steel Ibeam in the attic floor.
But the structure was saved. And the new owners are very happy with the results. And, as the preservation carpenter on site, I was very happy to be implementing an engineer's plan that I had been involved in and could stand behind. The idea of "winging it" without a very detailed plan to do structural remediation of that scale is to me unthinkable. If it only involved replacing a few members that had degraded and failed, that's one thing, but you usually don't realize the scale of a job until you tear into it.

A picture, mid-job:

Casey

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

User
12 years ago
After you make the foundation and supporting structure sound the most commonly used options for leveling the floor are:

1. Jack up the structure from the basement using hydraulic jacks and timber cribbing that house movers use and replace the supports. Sometimes this can cause more problems that it solves so get advice from an experienced contractor.

2. Remove the flooring and sub-flooring and shim the tops of the old joists or sister new level joists along them then add a sub-floor and finish flooring.

3. Remove the finish flooring and add a second sub-floor shimming it to be level then add finish flooring.

All of these methods require any stairways to be carefully evaluated and modified so they will still be usable and code compliant.
randy427
12 years ago
If the walls aren't cracked, the floor may have been that way for many years, and leveling it now will cause other problems (walls, roof, etc).
I'd find someone experienced in buildings of that vintage to evaluate the entire structure, starting with the foundation.
Related Discussions
Radiant Floor Heating on 2nd level
Q
Comments (1)
While I cannot answer your question, will this be heated water in tubing or electric heat mats? This information will help others to formulate a better answer.
...See More
2nd Level Floorplan Help
Q
Comments (10)
No need to yell.It may have been a good thing to note that you were gutting the house in the OP.Say I took the time to help you out and drew a plan for you and the stairs cam down in the middle of your first floor kitchen or someplace you did not want them?I have just wasted my time for your lack of info while asking for help.If you want me to put MY effort into YOUR project for FREE it would not hurt for you to invest a bit time into yourself with getting pissy. I'm done here.
...See More
Followup to my 2nd fl placement post. Best FL brand for 2nd floor....?
Q
Comments (18)
Thanks, Kate's. I will definitely get the pads for next washer. And will look into barn mats. Thanks We have two as well. Now the downstairs Duet sport is displaying "Sd" ...think pump needs to be cleaned... has never been done....why would they put behind panel needing to be lifted and Unscrewed! Never ends... may need TWO Washers!
...See More
Adding 2nd level to side of dutch colonial
Q
Comments (5)
We are starting on a similar project for our Dutch colonial, but have to wait for the city to approve a special exception for distance to the lot line. Our existing structure is a one story side porch with a concrete floor and foundation, but our architect's plan assumes we will remove the entire existing structure and pour new footings for a two story addition. Although you have an existing basement you will still have to verify it is sufficient to support a two story structure. It sounds like a simple question, but city engineers want you to prove everything. You may have to pay someone to excavate and verify the existing footings before they approve your adding another story. They will also want to know how the design will properly transfer the extra weight through the existing structure and to the basement footings and beams. If they are okay with all that, and you meet all the setback, FAR and height rules, the addition should not be that complicated. All of this gets much easier if you have a good architect who understands the rules and how to communicate with the city. My experience with the code and permit office is that they are generally friendly, but must always calculate everything, even if it seems to be a no-brainer. It gets a little more complicated if your property is old enough to have gone through a couple of zoning ordinance cycles. Even if you have existing construction that met all zoning rules when built, it may no longer be allowed under new rules, and they do not have to grandfather anything. Bruce
...See More
User
12 years ago
I've seen them torn out and replaced, jacked up in place and shimmed in place. It's all a matter of degree and the condition of the frame and the stair configuration. No one can tell you more without visiting the site and making a full assessment.
claire1980
Original Author
12 years ago
Thank you for all your comments a feedback! Very useful.
sierraeast
12 years ago
"I'd find someone experienced in buildings of that vintage"

Reputable/experienced period renovating contractors in your area.

Related Stories

KITCHEN DESIGN The Kitchen Storage Space That Hides at Floor Level

By Toronto Interior Design Group

Cabinet toe kicks can cleverly house a bank of wide drawers — or be dressed up to add a flourish to your kitchen design

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: 3 Levels of Marvelous Modernism in Mexico

By Mitchell Parker

Building up gave this home a party-ready terrace, plenty of room and a 3-story vertical garden that's a wonder to behold

Level Changes: Defining Spaces

Change a Mood and Differentiate Living Areas With a Few Steps Up or Down

CONTEMPORARY HOMES Houzz Tour: Split-Level Home Uses Every Square Foot

A staircase connects levels that share views and light. The result is separate rooms with an open-plan feeling

LIVING ROOMS 15 Decorating Moves to Take Your Living Room to the Next Level

By Laura Gaskill

These tricks with furniture, lighting, color and accessories go a long way toward making a space fashionable and comfortable

BASEMENTS Basement Becomes a Family-Friendly Lower Level

By Becky Harris

A renovation creates room for movie nights, overnight guests, crafts, Ping-Pong and more

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Garden Levels Transform a Steep Slope in Australia

By Elements of Style

From unusable to incredible, this outdoor area now has tumbled travertine, water features and mod greenery

REMODELING GUIDES These Split-Level Homes Get the Style Right

A suburban architecture style gets a welcome update with open floor plans and chic design touches

TILE Why Bathroom Floors Need to Move

By By Any Design Ltd.

Want to prevent popped-up tiles and unsightly cracks? Get a grip on the principles of expansion and contraction

REMODELING GUIDES Step Up Your Split-Level Spec House

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Three off-the-rack split-level homes, three dramatically different renovations. Let your favorite be your guide

Sponsored

More Discussions

gap fill in prefinished hardwood flooring

9

help!!! need ideas!

25

Self leveling basement problem

12

Brava roof tile

3

Any idea which shingle this is?

5