Hydronic Heating Question....

16 years ago

How easy is it to convert from a loop system to a manifold system, using existing 1/2" copper pipe runs and returns from the existing baseboard heaters and getting rid of the 1 1/4" galvanized loop piping which runs in a rectangle in the basement?

The existing system uses an electric boiler with a Bell & Gosset pump hooked into the 1 1/4" galvanized piping.

I would like to be able to control the level of heat in each room specifically as opposed to controlling the level of heat as it currently is being controlled from the thermostat reading in the hallway (one centralized location). At the point in time at which the thermostat reads 68, the closest room would be 68 where the rest of the house is, say, almost 9 degrees cooler.

I am assuming I can do a pex install from a manifold and hook the pex into the 1/2" copper piping at the run starts and return ends. But I am needing information on how to hook up the manifold and whether I can use the existing pump and electric boiler for this purpose or whether I need an alternate system for the heating and water supply.

Additionally, while on subject, there are two electric water heaters (both 50 gal.) in the house. Someone told me I should use the boiler for the water supply for the house. Can this be done as well, thereby eliminating the need for the hot water heaters, where the electric boiler (or some other installed product) supplies both the hot water at a higher temperature for the baseboards and a lower temperature for the house?

Thanks for any information given.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

hendricus
16 years ago
If the loop in the basement is continuos with each room coming from and returning to the main line a thermostat in each room can be hooked to a line valve inserted at the beginning or end of each rooms lines. As the thermostat calls for heat it will open the line valve which in turn will start the boiler pump.

If you manage to go to a manifold you must still find a way to open and close each line when heat is called for.

Domestic hot water from a boiler will be at boiler temp. Also the boiler must be on all the time and all year round to supply the hot water. I had this setup at one time and didn't like it and it was more expensive in the summer because boilers don't have as much insulation as water heaters. At least the ones I had didn't.
ajpdla
Original Author
16 years ago
Thanks for this advice; you sure got me thinking.

Yes, the basement is one continuous loop, with loops running off of the main loop, with monoflow tees along the main loop.

So if I installed these line vales at all points on the outward 1/2" copper pipes leading away from the main loop, would this keep one room from getting hotter than it needs to be while another room is drawing heat? In other words, the non-drawing line valves stay shut?

While I'm typing this, I believe that one line runs to the upstairs of the house and then back downstairs. So basically that could all be one zone, with the thermostat placed in the central location, maybe in the upstairs hallway. And then we could just do the dining room, living room and downstairs bedroom as three separate "zones."

Is this making any sense?

What are the electrical issues with so many different connections from separate thermostats "controlling" the boiler and pump? Is there a surge issue if one is drawing, and another wants to start drawing, or two happen to draw at the same time?

Is this better than installing a manifold system?
Related Discussions
hydronic radiant floor heat questions
Q
Comments (7)
If Thermal Track is made by a couple of companies, that explains it. The brochure I have shows an aluminum face and their recommended installation for tile is cement backer board over the Thermal Track, then an iso membrane on that and tiling on the membrane. Warmboard itself does "allow" you to thinset Ditra directly to the Warmboard, but Schluter won't warranty an installation like that. Schluter recommends a transition material between the Warmboard and the Ditra. Warmboard used to have a bit of double-speak on their website and in their literature. Not sure if they are still that way. They first tell you to install in accordance with TCNA guidelines, etc, or IAW the manufacturer's instructions, etc, but then they give you shortcuts around those guidelines and say "they've never heard of a failed installation" when taking those shortcuts. For those not familiar, the big difference between Warmboard and Thermal Track is that Warmboard in an of itself is a structural subfloor and radiant track combined into one material. Thermal track is installed over an existing subfloor. I installed Warmboard when it first came out. Nice product, but not worth the $$$ or added steps required during installation or in protecting it after the installation. At least not in my book. Mongo
...See More
Burst Pipes Hydronic Heating
Q
Comments (1)
Couple of websites worth careful reading. http://www.robertpowersins.com/Newsroom/newsFrozenPipes.html http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/green-building-blog/jeffrey-gordons-paper-bursting-pipes The second one is actually 3 parts PDF and slow to load. I once had a neighbor whose copper pipes burst and he had no money for repairs. I used a flaring tool clamp to reshape to burst bulges and then brazed the splits. As far as I know, it has been very durable.
...See More
Hydronic toe-kick heat and gurggling noise
Q
Comments (13)
why bubbles when only kitchen zone is active? A theory. Kristi's most peculiar symptom is that the problem only occurs when the kitchen zone is working by itself. I have an idea of why that might be, and this could explain lots of troubling air bubble problems. This has to do with the pressure drop caused by the circulation pump. The pump's job is to generate pressure between its inlet where it is low and the outlet where it is high. The amount of pressure change depends on the resistance of the pipe system. When only one zone is open this resistance is high and the pressure drop is large. The pressure right at the inlet to the pump can then be very low if the pump is powerful and the pipes to the zone are small. If this pressure gets really low, bubbles of water vapor can form. The way to check for this problem would be to put a pressure gauge on the drain outlet on the return side of the system just ahead of the circulation pump. If this pressure is negative, the solution is to reduce the pressure drop by reducing the power of the pump. Any thoughts, Baymee?
...See More
Some questions about hydronic toe kick heat
Q
Comments (10)
I have to run out but will try to answer some (if not all!) of your questions later tonight. Here are some close-up pics of our Turbonics kickheaters: First pic is the side of the island facing our pantry wall and the doorway to the kitchen. Second pic is the side of the island facing the sink wall. We used the black plastic grates supplied with the units--they fade away and are barely visible unless you are looking for them. They do (or did) offer metallic-look plastic (much like the silver pedal on our trash cab opener I'd imagine), but we opted to stick with the ones we had. We have ours hooked up to switches seen here (had the switchplate made to custom specs by arnev.com--took a few tries to get it right, and DH had to carve out the back of the final version a little to fit the switches in snugly, but the end result is perfect): There are various options for hooking them up as you seem to already know; with or without having them hooked up to the switches, including running both (or in your case, all three) units off one switch. We mostly run ours on low speed, unless it's bitterly cold, and we want to jump-start the warming! :-) Anyway, have to run, but will pop in later with more info. FWIW, we are very happy with ours, and our plumber, who tried to talk us out of getting kick-heaters, was impressed with these when he installed them and tested them out. PS If you do a search at the bottom of the Kitchen Forum page, you might find some older threads with some of my posts about Turbonics.
...See More
hendricus
16 years ago
In other words, the non-drawing line valves stay shut? Correct

Sure

Yes

No electrical issues. Last house of ours had six zones on one pump the size of your fist. The most work would be running the low voltage wiring from the boiler to each line valve and then to each thermostat.

It's a beautiful system when you're done, any room can be turned off or set to any temperature that you want.

IMO yes, but I don't know anything about manifolds. Manifolds are basically about distributing water and you want to control the flow of water.

Hydronic Heating Question....

Comments (3)

hendricus

ajpdla
Original Author

Related Discussions

hendricus

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Hydronic Heating Question....

Comments (3)

hendricus

ajpdlaOriginal Author

Related Discussions

hendricus

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ajpdla
Original Author