pressure tank problem, water hammer plus

13 years ago

Hi There,

Admittedly, I live in a shack in the desert and our plumbing would best be described as eclectic, but I could use any help and advice anyone can offer.

Our water system consists of above-ground water tanks that go into a recently-installed pump and pressure tank that goes into 3/4 inch copper pipe. We have two outside spigots, one a couple feet away from the pressure tank, and one about 20 feet away from the pressure tank, each with a 1/2 inch hose bib. About 3 more feet of 3/4 inch copper pipe gets you to the bottom of the sink where it splits into a short section of 1/2 inch pipe that connects to the two hoses that connect to the kitchen sink. Theoretically, one of these will someday be hot water but we haven't gotten that far yet.

Here's where it gets weird. When you turn on either of the spigots, everything is fine, the pump/pressure tank kicks on and water flows normally at a good flow. However, if you turn either of the kitchen sink faucets on, the pump immediately begins to stutter on and off rapidly and because our system is so ghetto, major water hammering also ensues. We are working on getting everything strapped down better, but we aren't sure how to fix the pump stutter when you use the kitchen sink.

We went to Home Depot and bought the cheapest new faucet we could find, thinking maybe our old one just couldn't handle the power of the pump, but once installed, the new one did exactly the same thing. We did find that when we removed the hoses and just sent water through the half inch pipe after the split, the problem ceased, so it seems that it is the hoses that connect to the faucet or the faucet itself that is causing the problem.

What it seems like to me is that not enough water is getting through the sink fast enough so there is excess pressure which tells the pump to kick off, but then there is not enough pressure, so the pump turns right back on immediately, then repeat at a pretty fast rate. Does this make any sense?

Can you get larger diameter hoses for the faucet, or have we done something horribly wrong? Any help or suggestions would be gratefully accepted. I haven't had running water in nearly a year, and it sure would be nice...

Thanks!!!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

joed
13 years ago
If you have a pressure tank the pump should not kick on imedeately. The pressure inthe tank should drop some before the pump kicks on to bring it up again. Typically the range is on at 20 psi off at 40 psi. It sounds like your tank is full of water(waterlogged). There should be an air head in the tank. The air compresses to give this pressure range. WAter can't compress. this causes the pump to rapid cycle on off as the pressure goes up down fast.

The outside spigots probably use enough water to keep the pump from reaching the cut off pressure.

The solution is to drain all the water out of the tank and let it fill with air. Then pump water in again. Some tanks have a bladder in them. If the bladder is broken then the tank needs to be replaced.
sagebrushsally
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks so much for the advice. That makes a lot of sense to me. I will try to sort this today and will let you know the results!
Related Discussions
Pressure tank problems?- air in faucets
Q
Comments (8)
Put a garden hose onto the drain faucet of the water heater and run it over to a drain or out a window. Open the drain valve and take a look at the water coming out of the hose. If it's muddy, then run it until it runs clear. Get a glass jar and fill it from time to time during the draining process. Looking through the filled jar will tell you how clear the water is. No matter what the problem is, flushing the water heater is a good idea. You didn't say if you had a deep well or a shallow well. It may be that the dirt is coming from the well. Let's hope not. If the bladder in your pressure tank ruptures, then the bsrrier between the water and the air in the tank no longer exists. The water will absorb a certain amount of air but it takes a long time for that to happen to any great extent. Eventually, all the air would be absorbed and the tank would become "water-logged". When that happens, the well pump cycles on and off at a rapid rate and if not caught quickly, it can be damaged. It is quite possible that, in spite of the recent replacement, this bladder has ruptured and released the charge of air behind it. The excess air may be finding it's way into the plumbing pipes and into the hot water tank. That air can stir up any sediment on the bottom of the tank. Top load washing machines can use upward of 70 gallons per wash cycle and depending upon the temp setting, much of that can come from the water heater. Once the excess air is gone, you may form the belief that the problem doesn't exist but you could be wrong. I think that you need someone to test the pressure tank to see if the bladder is ok or not. My two cents.
...See More
Persistent water hammer problem
Q
Comments (0)
Hi all, In a major renovation, we replaced most of our old plumbing, and, added a new floor with new plumbing. The water hammer took about 2 weeks to show up. It only occurs when faucets are shut off quickly. Our plumber [after ripping open some walls to look for loose pipes (!?!)] installed a pressure reducing valve where the water enters the house. He claims it took the pressure from ~130 to ~60psi. No help. Then he added a large hammer arrestor just inside that valve. Nope! Then he installed smaller hammer arrestors under each sink & behind the washer. Still no luck... I read that ceramic-valve faucets can cause water hammer due to the abrupt shut off. Interestingly, our 2 "old" upstairs ceramic faucets now cause water hammer, but the same faucets didn't when we had only a single story house. We have 2 Takagi tankless water heaters mounted outside the house. The plumber thinks they must be responsible for the hammer. Any other suggestions? Thanks, Pableau
...See More
Water hammer problem
Q
Comments (26)
Well, I didn't read the whole thread but if you have low pressure and are getting some pipe banging I can almost guarantee its a loose pipe somewhere. Long story short I've been in my home for 15 years. Always had pipe banging whenever I would shut off a tap, regardless where it was. My pressure is about 65psi so I installed hammer arrestors everywhere. No difference at all. I also have the air gap pipes but they made no difference either. A month ago I was replacing a bathroom faucet and noticed the pipes coming into the cabinet were loose. I could move them several inches. I checked the other water supplies and low and behold same thing, even the toilets! I took some expanding foam and sprayed it around the pipes where they enter the cabinet. I know its not ideal but I'm not removing cabinets and drywall to secure a pipe. The foam expanded, dried and essentially secured the pipes. I did this on all the pipes and my plumbing is now quiet as a church mouse. I lived with that for so long and all it took was a $5 can of Great Stuff to fix. Tell your GC to fix it. Its his problem not yours.
...See More
Does a pressure regulator/reducer eliminate water hammer?
Q
Comments (1)
If you have excessive presure coming into your house a reducing valve should help, in the USA most codes have a maximum of 80 lbs. you should be running your system at approx. 60 lbs. So-called air chambers are a waste of time, they have to be serviced often, your best bet is to use the self-contained ones, they have to be installed as close to the fixture as possible. Hope this helps. Lots of luck "If all else fails, read the directions"
...See More
ramona1976
13 years ago
Make sure the pressure tank pressure is set about 2 pounds below the cut-in setting of the pressure switch. In other words, if the pressure switch is 40-60, the tank setting should be 38. Be sure to set the tank pressure when the system has no pressure on it, otherwise the setting will not be accurate.

I would also check out the pressure switch to make sure that the cut in and cut out points are not too close together. I like a 20 pound spread, but some people don't like that much variation in their pressure, so they set the switches with a smaller range. That can cause cycling as well.
sagebrushsally
Original Author
13 years ago
We just washed dishes with running water from our sink for the first time since last winter. Joed, you were absolutely correct. I suspect we had a faulty tank from the factory because we have had a problem with a small leak since we installed the pump and pressure tank. I ordered a new pressure tank (which was only about $14) last spring to see if I could get the leak to stop, but didn't have time to install it before we left for the summer.

Today, we removed the old pressure tank and replaced it, and as soon as we reconnected the lines and turned on the pump, it pressurized, then kicked off. We turned on the sink faucet and it flowed in a clean, beautiful stream of water with the tank maintaining utter silence for nearly a minute before it kicked on again.

It is so nice to have running water again.

Thank you so much for your excellent suggestions. We did not have a super accurate tire gauge (2 out of three were stuck and one did not go high enough) but we think we got it ballpark and will double check with a new gauge. The manufacturer's suggestion was 28 psi, so we aimed for that and everything seems to be working dandy.

Thanks a ton, we really appreciate it!!!

sagebrushsally and her sethsquatch

pressure tank problem, water hammer plus

Comments (4)

joed

sagebrushsally
Original Author

Related Discussions

ramona1976

sagebrushsally
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

pressure tank problem, water hammer plus

Comments (4)

joed

sagebrushsallyOriginal Author

Related Discussions

ramona1976

sagebrushsallyOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

sagebrushsally
Original Author

sagebrushsally
Original Author