skip to main content

Sewer line replacement options?

15 years ago

I've gotten some great info over in the HVAC forum, so now it's time to confront my sewer demons.

I'm currently under contract to buy a gutted (down to the studs) home in New Orleans, with the intention of rebuilding it and moving in over the next few months. I had the sewer line scoped last week and found major issues, now trying to identify my options to determine whether I can close the sale.

The house is one story, monolithic slab foundation. Generally, there is a kitchen on the right exterior wall and two bathrooms on the left exterior wall. The existing sewer line runs from the kitchen across the width of the house to a main line, which runs from the back bath straight forward to the street. We've found 2 breaks on the main line: one above the junction with the kitchen line and one below. The kitchen line is also obstructed about 15 feet from the drain by debris from demolition after Katrina. That leaves about 1/2 of the line that we can't get to with a scope (between the two breaks and the obstruction).

I've gotten three suggestions:

1) Tunnel underneath the house along both lines replacing all sewer lines with PVC. This would require one tunnel that would almost completely cut the house in half from front to back, then a second to come up the center of the house and replace the main line.

2) Run new lines up each side of the house to provide sewer access to kitchen and both baths... requires demo and replacement of driveway and tunneling to existing drain locations to tie in. I've been told (without explanation) that this solution (which was mine) isn't feasible.

3) Cut channels through slab w/ concrete saw to lay new sewer line from front of house (where current line is intact) to baths and kitcen (essentially carving a V into the slab).

Needless to say, the thought of cutting the slab into three sections and then patching it makes me EXTREMELY nervous, but two contractors have told me it's nothing to worry about.

Can anybody with any experience in this offer thoughts or suggestions? I can provide add'l details if necessary.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

tim45z10
15 years ago
How about raising the house?
politicaux
Original Author
15 years ago
Raising the house costs $30,000 and upwards... it's going on every day by those who got FEMA grants, but unfortunately it doesn't look like we'd be able to. That amount breaks our budget, and we'd still have to fix the sewer lines (although they would be easier to access). If you were thinking of the ICC elevation grant, we're still chasing that tail but it looks like we're not eligible (the seller/owner during Katrina didn't file anything to claim any of her allowances).
Related Discussions
Sewer Line-replace pipes for belly in line & breaks from roots
Q
Comments (3)
Modern plumbing codes generally forbid double trapping. Since each individual fixture has it's own trap, the DWV piping has none. Toilets have built-in traps.
...See More
Pipe bursting or re/splip-lining to replace sewer main
Q
Comments (2)
Currently working for a sewer district we dont even allow slip lining in our district due to some poor experiences. There has been a few pipe bursted laterals done and will only be allowed if they have sufficient grade otherwise it will follow existing dips and belly's. We will allow it also if it's an unusual circumstance such as a building over the lateral or a well manicured yard. Although we prefer open cut replacement if your local Sewer District will let you pipe burst I would go for it. I would certainly speak with them first and ask for their preference and once its done make sure the line replacement history goes in your file. You might also check your home owners insurance because there was a few out there that was paying for replacements.
...See More
Sewage backup in basement Open hole in sewer line Toilet gurgles!
Q
Comments (12)
I live in Chicago and have a condo in a 6-unit complex. We just had our main lines and side gangway all rodded out about a month ago but we had sewer back up come up in our boiler and laundry room drains. Anyone have any idea why it would be backing up? Do we have to put a backflow preventer down by our catch basin to prevent this from happening again? Where does that water go then, stay out by the city sewers? Besides for our drains backflowing our whole building has problems with the back area flooding. Our roof tilts towards our backyard. There are 2 downspouts which flow away from the building. I guess we had the downspouts directly into the catch basin but that always overflowed our laundry and boiler rooms. Heavy rains still flood our basements; through walls, through drains. We have no idea where to put this water until it has time to drain slowly through the catch basin out to the city sewers. Any suggestions at all would be appreciated.
...See More
Sewer Line Query
Q
Comments (2)
yes, I learned the hard way on this one and I wish I had given more thought and research to the question the first time through. I let a plumber talk me into doing the relining and was persuaded that this would save the yard from getting torn up. Now 5 years later I find that I can get a new sewer line put in for much less than I thought. I got a bid of about $2k for 42 feet of sewer, house to street, 7 to 8 feet down. That's a lot of digging. I found a good company, though Angie's list. They have done the work and cleaned up very thoroughly. I am going to have my own mason come in and do the concrete work on the walkway; he knows how to match what he did earlier. I'm poorer but wiser. I think the lesson here is to avoid doing the lining. I just don't see any good reason to do it that way.
...See More
llaatt22
15 years ago
Happened to trip over this convention announcement. The 2008 section has big lists of websites that might have the experienced contractors or contacts you can reach.

Here is a link that might be useful: No dig technology
pjb999
15 years ago
There are such things as no-digs but I guess it depends on the condition of the pipes - if they are too far gone or not, but there is a sleeving/relining technique that allows the pipes to be repaired in place, with only a small access point. Expensive I'm sure but designed to be competitive with a full dig and relay.
politicaux
Original Author
15 years ago
I looked into the trenchless options, they don't really work for our scenario. First, the existing line might not be in good enough condition to support trenchless replacement. Also, while we can dig a whole at the city side, the lines terminate under the slab so there's no way easy way to create an entry point for the new line. There's also several joints under the slab, and we'd have to tear out the driveway to get to the existing line on one side.

So far, our estimates are $12k (to tunnel to the two known breaks and replace only those portions) or $20k (to tunnel the entire width of the house and replace the entire system).

A SEPARATE OPTION: I'm admittedly no expert, but I see a way to run two new lines - one up each exterior wall) which would serve the entire house with minor tunneling. The disadvantage is that the sewer line wouldn't be under the house, it would be buried under the strip of grass on either side. One company says they wouldn't do it that way because the line isn't protected by the house and could break more easily. To that, I say that if it breaks, it would be a MUCH easier fix than if a line were to break under the slab again.

Is there any reason a new line can't be run outside the exterior walls of the house?
hendricus
15 years ago
I had a small business that hooked to city sewer. The original line came out of the back of the building. A trench was dug from the back, along the side, thru the front yard to the street. About 150'.

Our previous house had the sewer line come out the side of the house and then to the street. Lots easier to repair and/or replace.

If you bury it deep enough it won't be a problem.

Related Stories

FURNITURE Old Furniture: Clean, Reupholster or Replace It?

By Becky Dietrich, Interior Designer

A veteran upholstery cleaner weighs in on the options for found, inherited and thrift store furniture

REMODELING GUIDES Replace vs. Restore: The Great Window Debate

By Lindsey M. Roberts

Deciding what to do with windows in disrepair isn't easy. This insight on the pros and cons of window replacement or restoration can help

GREAT HOME PROJECTS How to Replace or Revamp Your Garage Doors

By Laura Gaskill

Boost curb appeal and maybe even security with new garage doors. Find out cost ranges and other important details here

MOST POPULAR Kitchen Evolution: Work Zones Replace the Triangle

By Jennifer Ott Design

Want maximum efficiency in your kitchen? Consider forgoing the old-fashioned triangle in favor of task-specific zones

GREAT HOME PROJECTS How to Replace Your Lawn With a Garden

By June Scott Design

New project for a new year: Lose the turfgrass for energy savings, wildlife friendliness and lower maintenance

DECORATING GUIDES Lose It: How to Reuse, Recycle or Replace Your Sofa

By Vanessa Brunner

Follow these tips and tricks to keep your worn-out couch from ending up in a landfill

BATHROOM DESIGN Bathroom Details: Show Off Your Sink Line

By By Any Design Ltd.

You heard right. Exposed sink traps have gone stylish, with more materials and matching fittings than ever

UPHOLSTERY Furniture Clinic: End the Curse of Slouchy Couch Cushions

By Shelly Miller Leer

Prolong the life of your couch with this inexpensive fix that’s so easy, even a beginning sewer can do it

KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS Kitchen Counters: Plastic Laminate Offers Options Aplenty

By Ivon Street Studio

Whatever color or pattern your heart desires, this popular countertop material probably comes in it

KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS Kitchen Counters: Concrete, the Nearly Indestructible Option

By Ivon Street Studio

Infinitely customizable and with an amazingly long life span, concrete countertops are an excellent option for any kitchen

Sponsored

More Discussions

Changing shower fixtures

2

Can't decide gold fixtures what would you do

28

Does a countertop immediately behind hot range vents crack over time?

8

Fotile In-Sink Dishwasher

0

Can anyone help me ID this ~20 year old Rohl faucet finish?

0