I do NOT understand the fascination with Adam, whatsoever. He seems like an entertainer at a drag club. What is with the high pitched 'singing'? Sounds more like screaming to me. The end of his performance was WAY overdone, and not necessary. Same with Megan, I don't know how she made it this far.

Best performances of the night: Scott, Danny, Kris.

Cindy

As weird a song choice as it was, I like the way he sings.

I liked Chris better tonight, though. Scott was a whole lot better tonight too. Megan definately needs to go home. I can't stand her voice.

I was kinda disappointed in Allison tonight, Anoop too.

I think he is a brilliant singer, but I can't stand his high-pitched singing. I just prefer a deeper more masculine voice.

Kris was really good tonight and I loved Danny as usual. Scott was better this week, I liked his new haircut too.

I voted for Danny, Adam and Kris. Thought they all did really well. Wish Lil would step up to the plate, but I don't think it's gonna happen.

Didn't care for Scott or Matt's performances tonight.

I don't understand why Adam is on American Idol. He's on Broadway. He doesn't need Idol. I'd love to see one of his shows.

Megan bleats her songs. It sounds sort of like sheep.

Adam was amazing. DH said at the very beginning, that he will be in the finals, and I'm beginning to think he might be right. When he combs his hair back, does anyone else think he resembles a young Elvis?

Danny is still my favorite, he was terrific tonight too. I believe his appeal is broader than Adam's.

I agree he resembles Elvis and he could be just as big as Elvis. He's electric and gives an original version of songs every time. I loved when he sang Marvin Gaye. I'm a real fan of his. Easy on the eyes too :-)

Yep, Adam definitely rocked the place last night. Love him his voice and his looks. He can do no wrong. Danny was awesome too! They are my picks to be left standing at the end. Didn't care for Scott last night or Megan. Their voices just don't have it to be an Idol winner. They would be my picks for the bottom 3, along with Matt. NancyLouise

I did not like Adam last night, but I don't like when he does high pitches. I thought he was screeching. And I also thought Megan was horrible, she cannot move without looking really bad, the only reason she remains is that she is the Vote for the Worst pick. Dial Idol has her at the bottom but they still have Scott up there. Their bottom 3 are Megan, Allison and Anoop. Danny is at the top again.

I felt bad for Lil last night but I do think she has peaked and that we've seen the best of her. She seems to have lost her edge. I about choked when Randy asked Allison what was up with the outfit.....LOL!!

He looked good, he sang good. They could have sent the others packing and gave the title to him last night.

Adam is by far the best! I also love Chris, Scott has to go, he should not have even been in the top 12. I still like Megan because she is different. Maybe Scott will go tonight or Matt. I liked Danny in the beginning, but now I think Adam and Chris will be the two at the top.

Still an Adam fan, but the screeching is a little over-the-top.

I think the top four will be Adam, Danny, Allison, and Kris.

I think Matt, Scott, Megan, and Lil are at the bottom.

Who does that leave? Oh - Anoop. I think he deserves to stay this week.

I wonder if/when the judges will use their save? Isn't that only limited to the next three weeks or so? (I think they cannot use it on the top 5, but I could be wrong.) Based on who will likely be the top 5, they should have already used it on Alexis, or even Michael. Both are more worthy than Scott, Lil, and Megan, IMO. I guess I would use it for Anoop or Matt at this point to throw them in the mix with my top 4 above.

I like Adam. He's different.

I think they should only use the save for Adam, Chris or maybe Danny. I still love Megan though. Anoop is good but he is very forgettable, I think he has gone far enough, Scott has gotten too far.

I agree with what Kara said about Adam in that every week she is just waiting to see what he does next. I'm the same way. His performances captivate me, but I do agree the screaching is over the top and annoying at times. But he's a true artist and has amazing talent. No other idol comes on that stage and is as creative with their performances as Adam is. He really does make the song his own.

I'm also an Allison fan but I didnt like her last night at all, but I think she'll be safe.

Anoop, Lil, Megan, Scott are all unforgettable to me. Danny I didnt care so much for either but he did good last night. I love the song he sang though so that might have had something to do with it. And Kris, he is so easy on the eyes. He did really good last night.

I agree with the Adam fans that he is the one to beat on the show. IMO he's the only one with the stage presence strong enough to make him memorable and to make viewers tune in to see what he will do next.
Your right, Stoney about him looking Elvis-ish. It would be neat to hear him sing an Elvis ballad.
I think Meagan's time is up. She is a beautiful girl but her voice sounded so strange last night.
I didn't care for Alison's performance all that much, but I think she'll be safe.
Danny? Meh, forgettable performance in my view.
Anoop? Nothing spectacular.
Kris was very good, and I think Matt's going to be in trouble tonite. Scott sang better but he would not be my choice for an Idol.
It will be interesting to see who goes home tonite.
Suzan J

I love Adam and don't have any problem hearing anything he sings. I think he has a great voice range and I love everything he sings! I also agree that he looks SO much like a young Elvis. At our house, we just call him Little Elvis. Although I definitely love Danny and Matt, I think Adam is the one to beat this season. I think the judges might use their save for Matt, if he makes it one more week and goes back to the R&B sound. Chris is good. I love his voice and think he's a cute, clean cut guy. But...he just doesn't reach out and grab you like some of the others do. Scott...he's good but I think he has peaked and we can't expect more from him than we've already seen. Lil is just another singer with a big voice...nothing stands out as different. Allison is good. but , like Scott, I think she peaked early in the season and can't top what she's already shown us. Anoop could go tonight...toss up between him and Megan. Anoop may go, just because. But...IMO Megan should go because she performs badly!!!

Adam is the best and i think he is the second Elvis...

I think they should only use the save for Adam, Chris or maybe Danny.

But if the "save" is only good until they hit the top 5, and presuming that the above three get there on their own (along with Allison and one other) THEN who should be saved?

Maura, I didn't know that the save was only good until they got down to the bottom 5. I just think that Adam, Chris and Danny are the only ones that would be worth saving.

Meagan is a "bar" singer. I think Lil is too.

Anope will do good in a musical.

Scott, needs to stick to singing in church.

Adam is a rock star.

Danny is just All American Loveable.

Can't believe that people don't see the talent Scott has. And are blinded by looks of another 'singer'.

i think it is funny how everyone has such different opinions.. i think that Scott just doesn't sing well at all. his voice isn't in tune..it is shaky like.. he is SO boring..i LOVE adam.. i go to you tube all the time and watch his broadway videos..he is SO good. I agree that the screaming is getting old..but I am still a fan because of his range and because on the youtube videos i have seen his amazing talent. I don't see what everyone else is seeing in regards to the comments on the drag show on idol. If i didn't already know he was gay.. i would not have picked up on it from watching him on idol.. he doesn't seem that flamboyant to me on the show