Most of them liked Casey, but I agreed with Simon, he was horrible last night.

Still like Siobhan. Paige was absolutely horrible, as were the other two you mentioned. I also really like Aaron. Not sure what is going on with Andrew but he has been horrible after the great beginning. Lee's got a good voice too, his song last night was ok.

The only one that really stuck out was Crystal, she's got a great voice, probably going to win, although, some of the teeny boppers might not vote for her and she may lose because of that.

I agree...Paige, Tim and Di Di....all bad!!
Also, after Siobhan performed,(her famous scream) I told hubby that she needs a new gimmick, and thought it was funny that Simon mentioned the same thing.
I liked Lee, Casey, Crystal,and Aaron.

I like Casey
I think except for Simon they should get new judges. What one says the rest usually follow suit

I thought Paige was awful, but then I usually think she is pretty bad and she continues to hang in there. I said the same thing about Siobhan, Ritamay, I like her but that screaming is getting really old. Casey looked so 'stiff' last night, I really like his voice but he needs some showmanship.

I agree with everyone else. I thought the other guy on stage playing the guitar with Casey was actually more entertaining than Casey was. I've never understood Kara and Ellen's fascination with him. LOL.

Crystal will have a singing career whether she wins or not. She is awesome and we can't wait till she makes a CD. We will be buying that one.

I also like Aaron.

I may be old but I'm not dead. I think Simon is a very sexy man. Does anyone else think so?

I still like Crystal the best but like who was sent home tonight. No surprise there.

I find this year quite bland and uninteresting, compared to other years ; as attractive as Casey is, he does not have any showmanship, he just stands there.
I also see Crystal as the best one.

I wonder if they are coached from week to week, not by the celebrities we see,
but by experts who help them practice and figure out their song choices, we never see what goes on behind the scenes.

Myley Cyrus as a mentor??? Everyone of them can sing better than that kid!!! Her voice is so irritating! My picks are Crystal and the blond long haired guy,forgot his name. That girl is sooo talented!!!! And OH YEAH,Simon is sexy!!!

Caroline....I agree about Miley...she's much to young to be playing a role of mentor, and besides, she can't even sing. I can only assume she got her start because her Dad's a "so-called" star.

I hope Crystal takes it all the way. She has a natural, genuine talent, and the rest of them don't even come close. I could listen to her all day. She has a very relaxing and beautiful voice, IMO.

OK...Crystal is good but there are gals all over the place with her voice. There's a gal at our Legion that sings karaoke every Friday night and she can belt out a version of Bobby McGhee that would stop Crystal dead in her tracks. This gal also has a great personality and that is something that Crystal has absolutely none of. I'm still thinking that she believes she's got this competition won and her attitude shows it. I love Lee, Aaron, Casey and Siobhan. IMO, Lee has the best voice in the entire competition and should win. Casey has a good voice and the looks to go with the voice. Aaron has a very good voice and he will appeal to both the teeny boppers and the grannies like me. He's just so cure and innocent looking.

I have just realized that I am a little sexist when it comes to singing voices. I prefer females to have a crystal clear tone to their voice (like Shania Twain, Faith Hill and Dolly Parton) as opposed to a more throaty voice like Melissa Etheridge, Janis Joplin, Bonnie Raitt, etc. However, I prefer male singers to have a bit of raspiness to their tone, like former Idols Elliot Yamin and Chris Daughtry. I know that raspy voiced females and clear voiced males are equally talented, but my ears just don't appreciate them as much. So although Mike and Crystal may have technically better voices, I prefer Lee Dewyze for the guys, and Siobhan for the girls, if she can stop ending her songs in a scream.

Really thought that Lee showed more personality this week in his performance and I just really LIKE him. Love Crystal's voice and she seems to have the kind of old soul to go with the songs she sings.

Twinkie and I both were laughing when DiDi did You're No Good. We both kept saying to the tv - well, neither are you! LOL (Doesn't take much to keep us entertained! LOL)

Have never thought Andrew was that strong a contender. I like Aaron. Think he is wonderfully talented and especially for his age - really poised and has stage presence.

Sioban is so funny. She gets on stage and she's a wild woman. They interview her and she's this little "funny little thing", as Simon called her. She does have a good voice.

If it weren't for the Vote for the Worst Idol site, Tim Urban would have gone home weeks ago.

My favorites? Crystal, Siobhan, Lee. Casey will probably be in the top 3-4 but I don't know if he should be, or not.

If it weren't for the Vote for the Worst Idol site, Tim Urban would have gone home weeks ago.
And now Tim gets to tour in the top ten. *sigh* Should have been Lily or Alex. We can only hope that he will improve as the year goes on.