Question about finishing method options for Custom Cabinets

12 years ago

I am planning a kitchen with custom cabinets--a mix of stained and off-white painted. One of the custom cabinet makers I am considering believes that only paint with brush-marks looks authentic. When I think of painted cabinets, what comes to mind is a smooth durable bullet-proof factory finish. (In the purist (brushmarks required) view, I suppose this type of finish would be considered to be crass, tasteless, offensive...Pick one. But to me, it seems practical.)

I have lurked here for awhile, and see many people mentioning certain colors as popular for white cabinets, BM White Dove, Navajo White, etc. I know that there are special paints just for cabinets, however, it seems that even specialty paint, either sprayed or brushed-on would not be as durable as the finishes one sees on pre-manufactured cabinets.

Recently I visited another maker, who finishes his cabinets in his shop. He sprays them, and his painted finishes look like the factory-made painted finishes. He said they are conversion varnish. I thought that conversion varnish was clear, and used only on stained finishes. I am wondering if conversion varnish is applied over paint, or if it is mixed-in, and the pros and cons of using it?

Does anyone have a painted finish using conversion varnish? How is it holding up? Are there any issues like yellowing over time, etc.? How about painted only--either brushed or sprayed--how often do you repaint? With inset doors, do you have to strip the old paint to avoid so much build-up that the doors won't close? What, exactly are the oprions for finishing custom painted cabinets--and is a shop with a paint booth that pre-finishes better than onsite painting? What issues would differentiate the finish achieved by a local shop with a finishing booth from that of a large manufacturer, such as Woodmode? If anyone has anything to share, or links to finishing information, Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

abbeys
12 years ago
Hi Vicky,

I'm sure there are others on this website with more knowledge than I have, but I thought I'd give you my two cents. We are remodeling our kitchen, with custom cabinets that are a mix of stain and painted (off-white). I did a lot of research, and was very impressed with the quality and durability of manufactured cabinet finishes. I think Wood-Mode/Brookhaven painted finishes are considered hard to beat.

After visiting completed projects from a local custom cabinetmaker, we hired him to make our cabinets. Our guy sends the completed cabinets to a finisher, who sprays, glazes, etc... and uses conversion varnish. I thought the conversion varnish was used on the painted as well as stained pieces. We saw a kitchen that was 10 years old, and looked like new. In CA, where we live, there are a lot of environmental regulations, so the finish shops have to have special exhaust systems, etc... to use conversion varnish (some of them don't use it, and some the the locally done finishes don't hold up well - tend to chip, etc...). We were convinced that a "factory like finish" is available from the better local finish shops.

I think that finishes done in the shop are better than those done onsite. Finishing on-site is much more expensive, because they have to tape off the area around the painting, so it's more labor-intensive. (And they may not be able to use the most durable finishes).

I've never heard that only brushed on paint is authentic. I think that is a much less desirable way to paint cabinets - doesn't look as good, or last as long.

Will be interested to see what other posters say on this. Good Luck!
springroz
12 years ago
My antique carriages are painted with brushes. There are NO brushmarks anywhere. It looks better than anything sprayed. I would think that a really good cabinet finish applied with a brush properly would be the same.
Related Discussions
Dilemma about cabinets...Please help me...Lots of questions
Q
Comments (38)
Just a couple of comments from a kitchen designer, if your sink is going to be undermount and it is 33" you will need a cabinet BIGGER than 33" to contain it. I don't see how you can do this even in custom. Maybe they could do 34" or 35"? It's really awkward to reach stuff on a 30" deep counter not to mention cleaning. 3/4" is definitely preferable for shelving. Another factor is the width of the cabinet. The wider you go the more likely you will have sagging. I'd say absolutely do not go over 36" wide if you're using 1/2" shelves. Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchens for Living
...See More
Cabinet finish options.-Waterlox?
Q
Comments (3)
We used Waterlox on our cabinets, wood counter on our island, baseboard, door casings, stairway trim, and our interior doors. My experienced woodworker dh is SO impressed with it. Of course, we used it because I read so many impressive testimonials about it here and on other gardenweb forums. We'd always had a spray lacquer finish on cabinets before and I wanted something that would hold up better, and like you said, be easy to repair if/when needed.
...See More
Question regarding cabinet finish (stained cabinets)
Q
Comments (16)
Sigh, well, it is starting to become clear that custom cabinets just may not be for me given the amount of money that I want to spend. I have been offered by both to come out and see examples of their work, but was waiting on the actual quotes to see if they would even be in the running. And that doesn't seem to be the case (with option 2 for sure). I have been to the showroom. I guess I haven't been wary of birch because we had a lovely stairway bannister custom made and birch was used. It was stained a medium color, and is quite pretty, and has held up nicely. Granted the proportion is much smaller, and it doesn't take near the abuse and wear and tear that a kitchen would. The cabinet maker who would be using birch is a larger local shop, they have been around for 30 years and have a good reputation, so I would expect that their finishers are top notch. In the hands of skilled craftsmen is it still an absolute no go for darkly stained birch? Wht about maple? Somebody posted a pic recently of their darkly stained maple cabinets being installed and I am in love, but I guess day of installation is no test of how they will hold up. I'll be sure to bring these things up when I talk to them today. I may be being completely naive, but the guy we are working with seems like a pretty straight shooter. And if I rule out the custom option completely, and go with the semi-custom option from a national cabinet manufacturer, do the same staining and wood rules apply? Again, I was looking at getting a darkly stained maple. If I absolutely must have cherry to take a dark stain, then I am going to have to change gears completely. Either save money for a few more years or go with a painted cabinet. Once again, thank you for your help.
...See More
Custom Kitchen Cabinet Question and Door Style Input
Q
Comments (43)
OMG I love those Medallion kitchen cabinet doors! I've gone so far as to replicate them. I LOVE LOVE LOve their lines! I've had a pic of them forever, and have not given up on the idea of buying the doors for other cabinetry. My replicas are pretty darned good, though. LOVE them. I also live and breathe for inset cabinetry. It makes me go, "ahhhhooooooohhhhhhaaaaaaaa..." I disagree with FriedaJane that there is "a lot of lost space" with inset cabinetry. This has been beaten to death, but once the inset cabinets are put together, they're brought out to match the 12.75" "standard" cabinets, which makes the inside space the same. I'm here to tell you. Plus, if you were to order them, you can order them as deep as you'd like. (Brian @ The Cabinet Joint.com does it for me, yet the ones I've picked up at the H4H were the same depth!) A couple of commercial (Norcroft) base cabs I bought before I knew any better have really stupid upper drawers: 3" tall. Just look at that and get what you want. I've never heard that independent carpenters can't make frameless. It's so much easier than inset, because there's so much less precision. I'm one, who has no set, follow-the-lines design style. I think you can achieve a combination of the items you enjoy, and it'll look collected, vs. purchased. I feel sorry for people who buy the showroom and talk about their "eye." I must admit, that table is over the top fancy and oh, so fun. Right now I'm negotiating a butt-ugly armoire on CL. It's so ridiculously contrived it makes me laugh every time I look at it. Someone has painted it, so it's fancy-ness is somehow under control, but again, so over the top. If I get it, I'll make it work and love it. I really look forward to seeing what you bring together!
...See More
vickevette
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks for the replies.

I have heard that super-good painters can brush paint without brushmarks but have never seen that rival the factory finishes in terms of durability.

Thanks abbeys, for the helpful info on your research on finishes and conversion varnish. I do have access to a specialty finisher in my area that finishes cabinets in their special facility, so will look into what they can do with conversion varnish. It seems to be the way to go for a really durable finish.
cribbs
12 years ago
I am not a fan of the brush painted cabinets...but maybe it is because we don't have good enough painters around here to make them look good.

Conversion Varnish (CV) is very durable and stain resistant. It is top of the line when it comes to cabinet finishes. It is a two part system that when mixed together starts to harden.

I am a cabinet maker in NC and prefer the cv in a controlled environment booth to a brushed finish.

Travis Alfrey
Aberdeen, NC
vickevette
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks Travis--CV sounds like the way to go. I am not a fan of brush marks either!
abbeys
12 years ago
Hi Again Vicky,

Just wanted to let you know that I talked to my cabinetmaker today - he's still installing our cabinets. He said the same thing as Travis from Aberdeen NC. Conversion varnish is the best finish out there. Apparently, the older lacquer type finishes did yellow over time, but he thought CV was "as good as we have" - so I guess there are no guarantees in life, but it's the best. He also said that they do use CV on the painted finishes. They tint it to match the color of the paint, so you don't see it.

The finisher you found sounds like the same kind of finisher we have - a specialist who does nothing but finish cabinets. I'm thrilled with our's. They look every bit as good as the manufactured ones I've seen in showrooms - and have some custom features that would have cost way more from a mfg. Good Luck!

Question about finishing method options for Custom Cabinets

Comments (6)

abbeys

springroz

Related Discussions

vickevette
Original Author

cribbs

vickevette
Original Author

abbeys

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Question about finishing method options for Custom Cabinets

Comments (6)

abbeys

springroz

Related Discussions

vickevetteOriginal Author

cribbs

vickevetteOriginal Author

abbeys

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

vickevette
Original Author

vickevette
Original Author