Primer over joint compound results and update

10 years ago

So I used zinsser smart prime. Sanded, did a little touch up and vacuumed the walls. Then a second coat with fresh start. Then 2 coats of paint. Looks great. Went to take the tape off the window trim and it pulled the paint right off the wall along the edge of the paint--a ragged line, down to the joint compound.

I took a piece of blue tape to a low area of solid wall I know will be covered with furniture. Took it all off down to the joint compound.

So depressing.

I did vacuum walls and ceiling thoroughly twice before priming.

Do I need to use a different product for priming? What did I do wrong? And what do I do now? the walls look great other than that. Maybe I need to take an exacto knife to the edge of the paint to get a clean line before removing the rest of the tape.

And I have a second room to do next. I need to know what I did wrong before tackling the second room.

One note: I didn't stir the fresh can of smart prime before doing the first coat because I came straight from the paint store where they shook it. But upon the second coat I went to stir it and there were solids at the bottom. They replaced the pprimer and noticed the same thing in some of their product in the store. They substituted fresh start for what I brought back. But they said it shouldn't affect what I already put on the walls. Not sure if that is the culprit but felt I needed to put that up front.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

nap101
Original Author
10 years ago
Another note: I have raw window and door trim that still needs to be primed and painted. How can I do that if I can't tape the walls? I can wait a couple months if that will make a difference.
PRO
Christopher Nelson Wallcovering and Painting
10 years ago
First off there was no need to prime twice, none. Second, you need to remove the tape while it is still wet. If need be, run a blade of some sort along the edge of the tape and the sill to break the bond. The tape pulled off the primer because paint still takes weeks to cure. From what I can see you did nothing wrong.
One coat primer,2 coats finish paint, run a blade along the tape edge, move on.
Better yet, forget the tape and paint neatly.
Related Discussions
Joint Compound
Q
Comments (8)
A couple of weeks ago my DW and I did a venetian plaster faux finish on our livingroom wall, using Durabond90 mixed with latex paint. The Durabond looks a bit like portland cement, but doesn't act like it. It's a bit like the drywall compound too, but is too hard to sand (according to the instructions on the side of the bag). Cost in Ontario is about $15CDN for 15kg - should be about $12US for 30lb, more or less. There was some left over, and I had some perlite handy too, so I mixed equal amounts of Durabond & perlite, added enough water to make a squishy mix (note the scientific term denoting a tufa-like consistency), and pressed it into a small yoghurt container. I then pressed a glass oil lamp bulb into the mix, and let it set overnight. The result looks like a portland/perlite/peatmoss mix, but is a bit heavier and a bit stickier - I had to cut the mold open, which I don't usually have to do when I make tufa. It was well set by morning, and hardened nicely during the next week. It occurred to me that this might give some relief to tufaneers who suffer from withdrawal symptoms during the cold weather. I know it's not real tufa (no portland cement and no peatmoss), but it might make a winter substitute. Another possible use is as a quick prototyping material - sets a lot faster than tufa. And the way I used it originally, it mixes nicely with latex paint - just dulls the colour a bit. I'll try to post some pictures later this week.
...See More
drywall compound over backerboard
Q
Comments (12)
Kevin, I'll be a little more specific, and since you've done a bit of drywall work you probably already know this, but I've already gotten a couple of emails from readers asking what "setting compound" is. So...there are essentially two families of drywall compound. Premixed mud in the infamous drywall bucket that hardens by drying, and "setting compound" that hardens via a chemical reaction. Premixed mud is water soluble. If that's what you have on your cement board, I'd take a sponge to wet and soften it and a bristle brush or taping knife and get rid of it. If what you have is not water soluble (it doesn't soften when wet) then it's a setting compound. Setting compounds come as dry powder, you add water to them. Add water, mix, and the chemical hydration reaction starts. Some are designated by a certain amount of working time, like "20-minute mud". You have about 20 minutes to get it on the wall before it gets to tough to work with. It's also referred to as "hot mud", I always figured that's because the chemical reaction gives off heat after it's mixed with water. So...if it's water soluble, get it off your cement board. If you tile over water soluble compound, the moisture in your thinset can be absorbed by the compound, which can soften the compound and destroy the bond between the tile/thinset and the wall. If it's a rock-solid, non-water soluble setting compound, I'd say it's okay to tile over. Mongo
...See More
Sanding Joint Compound
Q
Comments (21)
You are so right! lol It's sanded smooth, niiiice!, and then somehow it isn't smooth anymore when the angle changes. Big scratches and a blump. I guess the funniest part is that I actually like imperfection. Pleasantly imperfect. But this house has such a history of sloppy it's ridiculous and quite sad. I want things done nicely this time! I am working on letting go of things. But it is not easy! I will not do a bad job though. The ceiling did need work. It had over 30 mud pops over the screws that had to be sanded down, along with slopped up corners and lots of rough unsanded edges around the perimeter. Not to mention glops of mud splattered here and there. The walls were no less than terrible repairs. Honestly, I had a contractor here and we were just talking about other things and he told me the drywall guy did a complete BS job. Like I hadn't noticed, lol. This home stretch is a bear though. I am on the learning curve what is good enough to look nice and professional when done. So far, the paint in the bathrooms and backsplash look really good! But I did obsess, lol. I will loosen up in the closets and see what happens. I think Faron understands!!?!? lol. He has a perfection thread out there somewhere, with a little repair kit to get the textures just the same! Thanks all.
...See More
Primer over joint compound and painted wallpaper
Q
Comments (9)
Well, it's not an option at this point to remove it. We have wallpaper in all the rooms in our second floor, and the walls would need to be rebuilt behind the wallpaper. We can't rebuild all our walls on the second floor right now, for financial and other reasons. We plan to do one room at a time eventually. For now, unfortunately, we have to make the best of it. Can you recommend a good acrylic general purpose primer? (For what it's worth, the person at my local paint store said I should use Gardz, which sounded a bit like overkill to me, especially, as christophern noted, the wallpaper is already painted. But I haven't been able to find any good information about whether Gardz is appropriate for surfaces that are already painted). Whenever I go to prime, do I spot prime first over the joint compounded areas, and then go back over the wall? Or should I just do the whole wall in one go? Thanks for the advice!
...See More
Pines Everywhere
10 years ago
I am going to suggest stuck-tape removal a little differently than christophern (as an alternative for you to try).

Loosen the tape very slowly from the loose/floppy edge (hopefully you left one) toward the stuck edge -- try do a whole segment or length at a time if you can. This should minimize what comes off at the edge line. For any tape splotches that are totally adhered, use a blade to loosen the far edge and pull off toward the wall edge. Flick off anything that is clealy a peel, sand that with fine grade paper, prime the splotches, paint the spots free hand.

In the future -- try priming and first coat of paint with no tape. A little trick is to deposit paint with a good, angled brush (1.5") at your edge line in a perpendicular fashion (yes, crosswise and short strokes for about two feet along your window edge or moulding). Then, gently swipe with the grain (now parallel) along the edge using the side of the brush and WITHOUT reloading your brush and WITHOUT touching the edge itself. This technique will first "deposit" the paint close to your edge via the 1.5" bristles, followed by smoothing the paint along the grain with a normal stroke. Repeat as needed. Never put a loaded brush (bristles or side of brush) close to an edge!

Even if you use tape with the above approach, you will rarely get paint on your tape ... if you do it will be light bristle touches during your cross-wise load .... or a swipe wisp with your parallel smooth-outs. In either case, you won't be putting any significant amount of paint onto your tape and the protected adjoining surface (which is usually the culprit for any sticking).

Finally, if/when laying tape, use two/three foot segments and run your fingertip LIGHTLY on the edge you are protecting (1/8" or 1/4" adhesion at the most) -- leave the rest flapping loose. The light touch will minimize any chance of the tape stickum penetrating an under coat (which is shouldn't anyway) and the little stuck line (1/8" or so) will minimize the tape edge available for paint-oopsies. Then -- like Christophern said, take the tape up when your top layer is still wet.

This post was edited by PinesEverywhere on Wed, May 8, 13 at 8:52
nap101
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks for the feedback. Good to know I didn't completely ruin it.

I have tried the cutting in method a few times with mixed success. I used that technique on the ceiling edge and it looks really bad right now and took a really long time. Maybe I just need more practice.
Pines Everywhere
10 years ago
Nap Wrote:
"I have tried the cutting in method a few times with mixed success. I used that technique on the ceiling edge and it looks really bad right now and took a really long time. Maybe I just need more practice."

You'll get it, don't be frustrated -- even try again on your bad spots. Cut cross-wise and then you can even use your roller (lightly loaded) to blend/fix (side-ways first getting close to the edge then short up & down rolls). When you're up on a ladder, you think nobody will see this way up here and in actuality the ceiling edge and corners are the MOST noticeable!

I'll leave you with a revised old adage: A stroke in time saves nine --

Hang in there - you'll fix these splotches just fine and the next room will be terrific. :)

Primer over joint compound results and update

Comments (5)

nap101
Original Author

Christopher Nelson Wallcovering and Painting

Related Discussions

Pines Everywhere

nap101
Original Author

Pines Everywhere

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Primer over joint compound results and update

Comments (5)

nap101Original Author

Christopher Nelson Wallcovering and Painting

Related Discussions

Pines Everywhere

nap101Original Author

Pines Everywhere

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

nap101
Original Author

nap101
Original Author