I agree with not matching the recliner with the sofas. When I purchased La-Z-Boy furniture for my family room 3 years ago, I did not get matching recliners with the reclining sofa. All 3 are in the same line, design wise and fabric line, but my sofa is a light beige and both recliners are a charcoal gray. They look great together!

This is a crude drawing but goes with what I described below. Floating furniture and making two seating areas will eliminate the waiting room feeling. You'll need more pieces. Here yellow is seating and blue is casegoods (more or less) plus lamps, plants. "X" is just not in that location. Added TV to the big wall end of the space. The description starts at the top of this illustration and works through to the bottom of it. Hope it is helpful and you have some budget for added items. Angle your two chairs flanking the console. Hang art 5" above the console and keep it within 75% of the console's width. Add 1-2 lamps to the console. Then turn the loveseat to face the console and two chairs. Put the coffee table with that group (12-18" from all the seats) and you have one sitting area Push the larger sofa up behind the loveseat to face the big empty wall at the other end. Back to the console side of this, fill in the area where the big sofa overlaps the smaller one with a pair of plants that do well in low light like ferns or palms in nice baskets for some texture. Buy two more matched small coffee tables, a backless sofa, and another pair of swivel chairs. Float the backless sofa with the two small coffee tables either side of it. Add the swivel chairs on the side of this group nearest the large wall. The two small coffee tables serve all 5 seats so allow 12-18" between each seat and the tables. Buy a credenza and TV for the big wall. Flank it with two large scale floor lamps. Hang a gallery wall opposite the window. Here is a backless sofa. The two smaller coffee tables would be on either side of it, all three between the larger sofa and two new swivel chairs.

I would get a sideboard for the back wall with a nice piece of art over it. Get your chairs and then re-evaluate the space to see if you have room for/need another piece. The sideboards & chairs are crate and barrel. For art look at minted.com bigcanvas,com etsy.com Make sure the art is at least 2/3 the width of the piece of furniture under it

Also, why don’t people put ceiling fans over islands? I really want a ceiling in the kitchen, and the only natural place for a hanging fixture is over the island. I got pushback for not wanting pendant lighting.