Strange brining results--advice?

14 years ago

I cooked a couple of chickens on the rotisserie last night. They were nice fat ones--6 to 7 pounds.

I had brined them using the recipe in Ruhlman's 'Charcuterie'--basically, 1 cup of salt per gallon, plus whatever herbs & spices I wanted. The recipe called for 1/2 cup of sugar, but I didn't have any so I didn't use it.

Brined them for about 8 hours, then rinsed them off. Put them back in the fridge, in the now-empty brining pot, oriented vertically--tail up, neck cavity down--for about another 10 hours until it was time to cook them.

Trussed them, then covered the breasts with foil at the beginning of the rotisserizing, removed the foil after about 45 minutes. Took about another 45 minutes for the breast meat to get to 165 degrees.

They came out picture perfect beautiful, golden brown. The breast meat came out exquisite: juicy, flavorful, perfectly seasoned, not at all dry. The dark meat came out excessively salty. Not so salty that it was inedible, but far saltier than I would have preferred.

My question is this: does dark meat have a special affinity for salt compared with white meat? I'm curious as to why one came out perfect, and the other didn't.

Next time I'll halve the salt, use the sugar it called for, and lessen the time in the brine to 4 or 6 hours.

(By the way, this reminds me of a Churchill story. Winston was at a Georgetown dinner party at which chicken was served. He asked the hostess for some more breast, and the blushing hostess informed him that here in the US we used the term 'white meat'. The next day Winston sent her a corsage along with a note that read, 'I would be most obliged if you would pin this on your white meat.')

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

rob333 (zone 7b)
14 years ago
Arley, your story made me laugh!

I'm going with Lars/Annie's discussion on his smoking vegetables. He posited that when he added fat, they more readily "absorbed" (is that right?) smoke. So, the fattier something is (and dark meat is fattier than white (breast) meat), the easier it absorbs ______________. Maybe he's on to something. I've dry brined, but not soak brined, so I can't say for certain.
jadeite
14 years ago
Arley, I always brine chickens using 1 cup kosher salt (not table) and 1 cup sugar per gallon of water. Brining time for a big chicken, like your 6-7 pounders, is a couple of hours. I've never brined a chicken for 8. Cook's Illustrated gives brining times of about an hour for an average (3-4 lb) chicken. My chickens end up juicy but not salty, at least no-one has ever said so.

I would guess that your brining time of 8 hours is too long. And if you used table salt rather than kosher, it was too much. My preferred kosher salt is Diamond, but I've also used Mortons and generic. Rough conversion is 1 cup coarse kosher salt = 1/2 cup table salt.

Cheryl
Related Discussions
Copper Rasbora suddenly hiding
Q
Comments (1)
I think you might be onto the reason. Fish have a habit of getting into a regular way of going through life. Try placing food into more than one spot in the tank so the shy fish gets some. Sometimes water quality can change the behavior too.
...See More
Would you live above burglars?
Q
Comments (5)
I lived in a terrible building for my first apartment because it was cheap. We had a ton of drug activity. What kept me safe was minding my own buisness. I made sure that I covered up my tv and electronics when moving in and out, so that nobody knew I owned nice things. Most of all, mind your own buisness. Don't tell anybody which apartment you live in or who lives with you. if anything, say that you have several people living there. Don't put on your fancy earings or expensive shoes etc until you get to your car, so nobody thinks you have money. And install whatever locks on the door. Don't forget to make complaints to the HOA and the landlord, if your complaints are filed legally then you can have control over your lease, which is a contract that says the landlord is responsible for providing a safe and clean enviroment. If they can't hold up their end, then you have the right to break the lease and leave. You could try and make annonymous police calls, but if they figure out its you, then you're painting a target on your back, and you want to remain under the radar. Save up, get a second job if you have to, do anything you can to get out of the building. Our building finally had several drug raids with dogs and guns and a new landlord who we suspect was an undercover cop himself took over, and he treated us all like criminals. Ask your landlord to put up security cameras as soon as possible, and to actively call the police. It is the landlords responsibility to keep their tennants in a safe enviroment under penalty of law. The housing authority can help.
...See More
harvesting grape leaves
Q
Comments (1)
Forgot the photo... And the scapes, a total bust. Hard as pencils. Had to research the allium forum to find out why...my garlic bed was overrun with rudbeckia a few years ago and i often just let nature enjoy itself. The scapes are everywhere but allowed to run wild. I made a new bed and transplanted and will have the proper harvest next year...
...See More
How to adjust a strange softener
Q
Comments (17)
Hello- The tech departed a few hours ago, I had the brine tank empty and ready to go, I wanted to have it clean by the time he showed up, but he actually showed up early. He cleaned out the brine tank inside and out in my driveway, and took the valve off of the resin tank to show me the condition of the resin beads. They were round, an off orange color, and also had flakes of carbon inside as well. He found a piece of trash blocking the drain orifice, and fixed a leaking plastic fitting as well as installed a few new o rings and gaskets. He also showed me how to adjust all of the settings on the control panel, and set them the way they need to be setup. No water sample was taken, because the softener was not working 100% so it would not be 100% accurate. He left the hardness setting where it was the last time they were out, about 3 years ago. He then came inside and tested my RO and I had 14 ppm at the RO and a few hundred at the regular faucet. So he concluded that the membrane does not need to be replaced. He also showed me how to work those silly plastic fittings and tubing under the sink. All for $147.50 Not too shabby. Should I bother using that "softner cleaner" they sell at home depot? The stuff that you pour in the brine tank?
...See More
arley_gw
Original Author
14 years ago
Cheryl, thanks for the info. Last weekend I made a brine of 1 cup Diamond Crystal (which as you pointed out, by weight is about the same as 1/2 cup table salt), and 1/2 cup sugar per gallon. Brined the 6 pound chickens for about 2.5 hours.

They came out perfectly, except the wings got a little too browned. Dunno whether or not it was the amount of sugar or the fact that they came a little closer to the rotisserie element. Next time I'll protect them with a little foil.
jadeite
14 years ago
Congratulations! So glad to hear of your success. I'm a definite brining convert. I do all chickens, turkeys and even pork (after reading that David Chang does his pork this way). No dry meat for me.

Cheryl
annie1992
14 years ago
arley, we just processed 30 broiler chickens, between 5 and 8 pounds dressed, and I'm brining one overnight tomorrow for the rotisserie on Saturday.

I'll sure watch the salt content, I know I'm out of kosher, so maybe half as much. Or maybe I need to go to the store tomorrow for kosher salt....

Annie
arley_gw
Original Author
14 years ago
IIRC, Diamond Crystal kosher salt is around 5 ounces by weight per cup, Morton's kosher salt is around 7 or 8 ounces, and regular table salt is around 10 ounces. I did find that using a cup of Diamond Crystal per gallon was just about right.

Strange brining results--advice?

Comments (6)

rob333 (zone 7b)

jadeite

Related Discussions

arley_gw
Original Author

jadeite

annie1992

arley_gw
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Strange brining results--advice?

Comments (6)

rob333 (zone 7b)

jadeite

Related Discussions

arley_gwOriginal Author

jadeite

annie1992

arley_gwOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

arley_gw
Original Author

arley_gw
Original Author