Ok, final few questions on acid stain before I try it!

17 years ago

I've read everything everyone recommended that I could find on DIY acid stained floors. I have a few quick gaps to fill before I start it on Thursday.

It's a young slab (14 months old, never lived on). We want a rich color (using Kemiko Cola stain), not a faded pale one you can see through. I've gotten conflicting opinions on how long to leave the first application of stain on the concrete before washing it off. FabCrete recommends 24 hours before washing, and then baking-soda and water. Local pro recommended only *1 hour* after application before washing. (I thought that after 1 hour the stain would still be wet and there would be hardly any change at all to the floor.) He said that after it dries, if i want darker, I can do it again for another hour. That seems like a collosal PITA, doing it one hour at a time, once a day until satisfied. He also said I could cut the kemiko by 1/2 again (instead of 1/1 water, do 2/1) and let that sit longer.

So, first question - how long should I wait on a young slab between application and washing?

Next question - the first time I wash, do I use the baking-soda mixture, or do I wait to wash with that until I'm sure I'm happy with the floor color and won't be applying a second coat?

last question - how hard to you clean the floor after the last stain? One site says you clean until no more residue comes up; Febcrete says you wash gently, don't scrub. Which is it?

Sorry about the long post, but I know I only get one shot at this, and I really want to do it right!

Featured Answer

cat_herder
Original Author

17 years ago

Update! I stained the floors, and they turned out really spectacular. I used Kemiko's cola stain for the first coat, for 1 1/2 hour before mopping. After it dried, I did a second application with 2/3 cola and 1/3 golden wheat. Mopped with baking soda after an hour. The color turned out to be a rich rich rich orangy-brown, with gold highlights. I put one coat of acrylic sealer, then grouted the lines (it was cut into 4x4' squares), and after it dried, did a second coat of sealer. The result is truly unbelievable!

I wouldnt' have even dared to try it without your help. I saved about $6k in the process, and ended up with a result that is prettier than any pro job I've seen in our area (not a lot to choose from). If I can figure out how, I'll post a couple of pictures of the result. Anyway, THANK YOU AGAIN!! You guys are worth the price of admission.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

xposedflooring
17 years ago
Ok as far as how long to wait before applications- after you apply the first coat you will see the concrete start to bubble, that is the acid stain reacting with the concrete etching itself into the concrete, that usually takes about 30min, then wait about another 30min after that, a total of about one hour, depending on how the acid reacts with the concrete.

Second question is you wait until you are done with your final coat to use baking soda, just rinse with water inbetween coats, just remember you might have to rinse 3 or 4 times in between coats.

Third question is after your last coat, you clean untill there is no residue left.

Good luck with your flooring and if you have any questions just give me a hollar.Hope this info helped.

Andy
www.xposedflooring.com
xposedflooring@aol.com
floorguy
17 years ago
The products your fixing to use may not be the same as the product your getting info on from the pros. I'd be more inclinded to go with what the manufacturer of the product wants you to do.

I do know, if you want that aged leather look, DON'T spray the room like you would be painting a wall. Skip around and spot the floor all over, overlapping some places and not other places. Hard to explain.... but don't get a pattern going, make it random.
Related Discussions
A few questions from another poster regarding B& B pickles
Q
Comments (3)
I have tried baking soda with little effect a mix of ascorbic acid and water may also help a little. The mildew happens rapidly and once you see a single yellow leaf, it has begun. I spray with a fungicide called Serenade, which works quite well. Its done every 7 days during the bearing of the cukes. Bees love the blossoms and I usually have many bees busy all day long. I go out and pick at sunrise as its a little cooler and easy to find them on a vertical trellis. The honey bees must be local as they are busy all day and the area sounds like a huge bee hive. They usually are just fine even if I am out there picking right next to them, as they are not very aggressive. I posted links above to web site for pickling cucumbers, and if you don't know how to get these links copied to an internet browser, just simply point at an end or start of the HTML line (above), and hold down the left mouse button and move to the left or right to highlight the whole line. Once highlighted, press the control key down while you then press the C key. Open a new browser page and remove the text at the window at the top. Or point to what text is there, and then its highlighted, press the delete key. Position the mouse pointer in that window while you hold the control key down and presk V to paste the previously copied text. Press enter. Then it will show you the web page link. I made it easier to show you the Jung pickling cucumber seed assortment. Here is a link that might be useful: Jung Seed- pickling cukes
...See More
I finally got my new W/D... But have a few ?'s...
Q
Comments (2)
I really know nothing about these machines but I will say I would think that you should be able to set any spin speed on the Normal cycle anyway. With towels, jeans, sheets you need a fast spin. I would call them and ask about this.
...See More
Finally! Inspection done...moving in...a few pics
Q
Comments (27)
gldnfan, I'm curious what you say about switching out the lights...now that they are required to be pin lights, how does one "switch them out"...are there other lights that use pins? Or do you mean they have the electricians come back and change the fittings? Our understanding is that with the new law it's not easy to switch...I have the same green countertop and yellowish glow on my "cream" cabinets when the lights are on...I suppose as KD's and GC's get more familiar with this people will be advised about the combination prior to choosing it! Oh well, I find I'm starting to get used to it already so maybe eventually I won't even think about it. Gary, my understanding is that the current requirement is that you must have 50% fluorescent, i.e. if you put in one pendant as in our case which is rated for 3 100 watt bulbs, you must have at least 300 watts of fluorescent...the result being that we have LOTS of fluorescent lights. Congratulations, gldnfan...sounds like ahead of me in terms of getting moved back in. Amela, I will let you know about the insets. I love the look and because my kitchen was reconfigured, I think I gained some space to help make up for any lost due to the insets. But I haven't really been able to start moving much back in as I've had a sick DS at home all week as well as a sick DH so not much energy around here. I think it's a sign that it was really time for the remodel to be done! I'll let you know what I think as I go along about the space. The insets do look really good in my house, though, as it was built in 1931.
...See More
Vote please - should I try this? Need answer before the morning.
Q
Comments (38)
Thanks all. Well, UE came through and the dog and I took a drive up the road about 3 miles (I drove) to get to the gas station with the better prices. This gas station was 6 cents cheaper a gallon than the closer station. Geez, I have not bought gas for quite a while. The prices are going back up. The price was like $2.73.9 a gallon for unleaded. Some days I have not even left the house except to water the plants, feed the birds and get the mail. What are you all paying in your part of the country? So if my body behaves tomorrow morning I will head on down the road. I am not sure if I should take the freeway since that might be jammed up. I will listen to the radio before I leave the house. They give the traffic report so you know what's stopped up. Oh, and the weather channel local on the 8's and its website show the road slowdowns too. Ok, if I make it there I will report to you all tomorrow and let you know how my 1st day went. Another thing to worry about - health insurance. I have to make sure I ask about that tomorrow. Oh, and I have to remember to stop at Ikea for an application.
...See More
arkansaswifey
17 years ago
cat_herder:

Please post pics of your floor! We are in the process of trying to decide if we will do acid stain for our den after falling in love with a friend's floors. I would love to see how yours turned out. I don't think ours will be a diy project because our floors are old and currently have carpet and vinyl flooring. The pros seem to be concerned with the glue residue and tack strip holes. From what I've been told we will have to do an overlay process which produces a thin layer of new concrete that can then be colored, stamped, etc.
cat_herder
Original Author
17 years ago
Another update! The paper will be removed from the floor (after painting) early next week, and I should be able to get some good pictures of the floor then. Sorry about the delay, but the floor has been covered since we finished sealing it. (all except the kitchen, which the idiots didn't cover becuase they "ran out of paper." (ARGH!) We'll have to reseal that part of the house, but I guess that's a small price to pay, comparatively.) Pictures will come!
rjinga
16 years ago
hey cat herder...did you ever get around to taking photos? I know this is an old post, but I'd sure like to see how it turned out...
cat_herder
Original Author
16 years ago
Yes I did! Not sure how to post pictures, though. Is there a FAQ link for how to do that?
rjinga
16 years ago
do you have an account on photobucket? if not it's free, go there sign up, and then you can upload the photos from your computer.

On the main page (after you set up an account) you will see 3 tabs, and you will probably us the upload photos from my PC option, then just below that are 3 buttons that say browse..click on each one of those one at a time, find your photos on your computer and then tell it to upload (when you are through adding all the photos you want).

Once uploaded there will be 4 links directly beneath each photo you have uploaded...you will click on the 3rd one down (HMTL tag is what is says) higlight it or however you do a copy option with your mouse...once you have it copied, you will open back up the post from GW that you were typing then paste it right into text box.... before you submit the GW post you can preview and you will actually see it.

I hope this helps...if it's clear as mud, let me know...

www.photobucket.com
breezytoo
16 years ago
Bump
mdc08
15 years ago
Cat- I want to stain our floors and we are pouring a slab next week.... please post pictures!!! I can't wait to see them!!!! BTY, did you dilute the 1st application?

Ok, final few questions on acid stain before I try it!

cat_herder
Original Author

Comments (10)

xposedflooring

floorguy

Related Discussions

arkansaswifey

cat_herder
Original Author

rjinga

cat_herder
Original Author

rjinga

breezytoo

mdc08

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Ok, final few questions on acid stain before I try it!

cat_herderOriginal Author

Comments (10)

xposedflooring

floorguy

Related Discussions

arkansaswifey

cat_herderOriginal Author

rjinga

cat_herderOriginal Author

rjinga

breezytoo

mdc08

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

cat_herder
Original Author

cat_herder
Original Author

cat_herder
Original Author