skip to main content

Home Entertainment

Recording programs

14 years ago

My setup is antenna, never have had cable nor satellite. I really like some of the very old TV shows and some are currently being broadcast. I use the converter box to a VCR, record the program, then later play that tape to DVD recorder, pausing the DVD recorder as necessary to roughly edit out the commercials. What would be a better way for me to save these programs?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

yosemitebill
14 years ago
Hi,

The amount of degradation that you are getting from recording to VHS and then going to DVD must be really bad. I would suggest either recording direct to DVD and fast forwarding through the commercials, or recording direct to DVD and then editing on a PC with a DVD drive, using a DVD editing program to remove the commercials, and then burning a new disc.

DVDs can look great but can never be as good as the original source material... which unfortunately in the way that you're currently doing it, is VHS with only 240 lines of horizontal resolution that is then re-compressed.

Bill
0
bus_driver
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks for taking the time to respond. If such a thing exists, I think I need a DVD recorder with built-in digital tuner and timed recording capabilities. It needs to work with antenna input. Does TIVO have such a unit? Which model? Any other suitable units?
0
Related Discussions
Can't Get CC on Recorded Programs
Q
Comments (4)
Yes, we get CC on live shows. Haven't done the reviewing thing. The display is there on DVDs and live. It's not there when we play anything recorded on the DVR. I'm thinking the DVR is somehow not capturing the CC, so it can't display it. It is impossible to get through to DirecTv or I'd be asking them!
...See More
vcr does not work with dtv converter pls help
Q
Comments (1)
If the converter is connected to the VCR, you can't change the channels with the VCR. You'll eventually need a VCR with a built-in HD tuner if you want the VCR to change channels. You can always use the old VCR to watch any tapes already recorded.
...See More
Less Cost Alternative-Renting Multi-Room DVR from Major Provider
Q
Comments (2)
Instead of thinking about how you can play recorded cable on multiple TVs, you may want to consider if cable is your best option for getting the content you want. We looked at what TV we actually watch and decided it was cheaper to buy the seasons of the few shows we like best from Amazon or iTunes than to keep paying for cable every month. We have a blue ray player bought for $75 that plays Amazon prime and Netflix but there are a lot of options for getting those services to your TV. We cut the cable without a single regret and are saving over a hundred a month from what we were paying to the jerks at Comca$t. Seriously, our cable/DVR/Internet/phone package was $160 a month. Now we pay $40 a month for Internet plus $10 for Netflix. Despite talking about buying three or four season passes to shows, we only ended up buying one. Admittedly, this works for us because we're not big TV people. You'd have to look into other options if you have a sports fan probably, but it is certainly worth considering.
...See More
Less Cost Alternative-Renting Multi-Room DVR from Major Provider
Q
Comments (1)
In it's most basic form, a DVR allows you to record live television. Devices like Roku, Apple TV, Chromecast, etc. allows you to stream television shows, movies, etc. from companies like Netflix or Amazon Video. The list of what is available, especially prime time television, is going to be limited. Now most DVRs and set top boxes provided by the cable or telephone company also allow you to stream media but the choices are almost always limited to what they want to you receive (no Netflix). In addition many modern televisions also have the ability to stream media. I had a Tivo years ago and thought it was the greatest thing since sliced bread. Then the cable/telephone companies decided they all needed set top boxes, which along with DVRs, is a great profit stream for them because the boxes cost very little to make. So it became a challenge to get Tivo to work with the providers and I have no idea what progress they've made in the intervening years but that's something you need to investigate. Tivo also charges for the box plus a monthly or lifetime subscription. So you're not likely to be saving a lot of money going in that direction but do the math.
...See More
yosemitebill
14 years ago
Hi Bus Driver,

Without knowing how much money you wanted to throw at this, I kept my answer simple. Yes, DVD recorders with built-in ATSC/NTSC tuners & timers are readily available. I took a quick look at Walmart's website, since they are so ubiquitous, and they actually have an even better solution... which is what I was initially going to recommend. Under DVD players, in "electronics" they have a Magnavox DVD recorder that also has a built-in HD (hard drive) recorder. Without knowing all the details of this unit, it should hopefully allow you to record the program to the HD and then edit out the commercials as you burn it to DVD, if you wish.

The Magnavox name is licensed to Funai which is a major OEM supplier to many well known manufactures, so it should be OK.

Regarding Tivo, yes that is an alternative but it only has a HD recorder so that you would then use a separate DVD recorder to archive. You also have a subscription fee, as well. Not knocking Tivo at all though.

Hope this helps!

Bill
0
bus_driver
Original Author
14 years ago
I checked the Walmart store. The recorder they had on the shelf was Magnavox ZV 427MG9. Online reviews were not so good. Some owners were pleased but about 50% of those posting had serious problems. I will check the Walmart website.
0
yosemitebill
14 years ago
Here's a link to the example of the Magnavox HDD/DVD recorder I found on the Walmart website.

Here is a link that might be useful: HDD/DVD Recorder
0

Related Stories

GARDENING FOR BIRDS What to Know About Birds Nesting in Your Yard

By Mitchell Parker

Learn how to observe, record data and help ornithologists with NestWatch’s citizen science project understand bird trends

HOME TECH Tech to the Rescue: How to Get Stolen Gadgets Back

Catch any crook who dares steal devices from your home with recording and tracking technology that's easy to use

REMODELING GUIDES Lessons of the Eameses

See how the Eames house's color blocks and modular design has inspired modern home design

MODERN STYLE Out-of-This-World Decorating: Space Age Style for Today

Set starbursts and more around your personal universe for a look alight with imagination

SMALL HOMES Houzz Tour: Rolling With Simplicity in a Tiny House on Wheels

By Mary Jo Bowling

Just 240 square feet, this California home encourages efficient living — but there’s still room for yoga

ARCHITECTURE Have It Your Way — What Makes Architecture Successful

By Spry Architecture

Universal appeal doesn't exist in design. The real beauty of any home lies in individualization and imagination

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING How to Move Your Movies Outside

By Laura Heller

How to get the shows you want to watch to your outdoor TV

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: Dancing, Painting and Family Living in Seattle

By Kimberley Bryan

With a backyard studio and a colorful, lively main home, these Washington state homeowners have all of their creative bases covered

GARDENING GUIDES Great Design Plant: Asclepias Incarnata for a Butterfly Garden

By Benjamin Vogt / Monarch Gardens

Beautiful swamp milkweed makes it easy to help monarchs and other pollinators in eastern U.S. gardens

HOME TECH Hello, It's Your Houseplant Calling

Or even tweeting. Today's apps and gadgets let plants communicate in better ways than with a show of withered leaves

Sponsored

More Discussions

Speakers in Steam Shower

12