Debating between Chesnee and Fincannon House Plans

11 years ago

Hi,

My husband and I are reviewing both Don Gardener's Fincannon #1234 and Chesnee #1290 house plans as we prepare to build our first house. I would LOVE to see pics if anyone has built either of these plans as well as hear pros/cons you see by looking at each.

One thing I know we would do is build in a bench with a table in the breakfast area of the Fincannon plan since the space alotted would not be enough for a decent table. There is a Hearth/Keeping room with this plan too and I think it would be a nice addition but my husband is concerned it would not get used.

We also see no point in adding the sitting room attached to the Master room in the Chesnee.

We have a 2 year old daughter if that helps with analysis purposes :)

Thank you so much for any insight!!

Featured Answer

virgilcarter

11 years ago

These are huge houses for a married couple with one small child, ie, a 4-bedroom house with large ancillary spaces.

I don't know where you live and what construction costs may be there, but are your prepared for $150-$200/SF (or more, depending on finishes, applicances, equipment, etc.) X whatever the area of either house may be?

Here's another issue to consider: any house plan that is deeper than two reasonably sized rooms will result in a very large roof and very bulky proportions for the exterior of the house, as viewed from any elevation. Are you prepared for a very large proportioned house?

Good luck with your project!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (21)

BuildingSoon1
Original Author
11 years ago
And the Fincannon:
BuildingSoon1
Original Author
11 years ago
Here's the Chesnee Plan:
Related Discussions
Final debate between kitchen layouts...which would you choose?
Q
Comments (12)
I'm with rhome in tossing B first. There are things I like about A and C, but I think I'd have problems working with either. If non-cooking traffic is a major concern, A could be a problem, especially if you are having to carry pots of boiling water or pans with hot grease across that end of the kitchen to get to the sink. That layout needs a prep sink in my mind and the island would make more sense than giving up limited counter space in the cooking area. Also, make sure you'd have room to get into the corner cabinet -- the dog dish and shelves look like they are too close. The fridge is too far removed in C -- I'd want to put in some fridge drawers near the range so you have a tight work zone there and let the large fridge store food to the table and extras. But that would take away storage for pots and pans unless you want them under the top of the work table. Without it, I'd have a very hard time working in that kitchen. If it were me, I'd keep working on DH and working with mock ups of the layout (tape, boxes, move tables and chairs, take notes about every move you make in the kitchen during the day -- and try to walk through planning a big dinner party, birthday party, etc. I think the sink island and shallow storage idea or the prep sink in the island give you your best use and function of that space. Is DH afraid of the cost or just saying it can't be done? I moved gas to my island when we bought the house, then capped that off and ran water and electricity to the island to have a prep sink when we remodeled. We have a slab foundation, no basement and a bathroom above. That aren't a lot of arrangements more limited than that and I used to think it was not a possibility for us, but we did it and it wasn't that expensive (about $500 for running lines under the slab). We got so much out of it too. We also closed off a doorway (we had 3 going to the driveway and garage along one wall of the kitchen and breakfast room) and gained a hutch with refrigerator drawers and and espresso machine that has turned out to be a popular favorite -- but we almost didn't do it because we thought it would be too difficult and expensive. The cost wasn't that great (spent more in cabinets and the fridge drawers). The challenge came when both reusing and matching brick were more difficult than we expected. Instead of a brick wall, we put in a faux barn door that ties in with the garage door. There are ways to work around many things that are less trouble and expense than you might think. I'd at least ask those questions before you close doors on possibilities.
...See More
Could you please review my parents house plan? Based off the Fincannon
Q
Comments (11)
You mention the possibility of a paid caregiver, indicating that aging in place is one of their concerns, yet the whole house is anything but age-appropriate. First the good: - Great sight lines at the front door. - Nice layout for great room, kitchen and dining area. And the bad: - The master bath is a study in inefficiency. Excess space in the middle of the room, yet a person using the sink must stand practically on top of the tub. An oversized shower (good idea for aging in place), yet the window is a problem. A toilet closet with a door that can't be closed once a user enters the room (and toilet closets are difficult for elderly to enter, as well as being difficult to clean). Your parents have allotted plenty of space to the master bath /closet, but this needs a whole re-do. Personally, I'd start by placing the closet in the spot that's now the shower; that takes care of the window, and it'll allow the shower to move "in" rather than being on an exterior wall. - The 90 degree turn into the bedroom does allow for privacy, but it can be difficult for an elderly person to manage. - The island prevents good flow in the kitchen, and your work aisles look narrow. In general, square kitchens don't work well. In a kitchen you want cabinets /countertops /space for your appliances; thus, rectangles, with greater wall area are superior. In contrast, squares allow for empty space in the middle, which isn't particularly what you want in a kitchen because that means your "important players" are farther apart from one another. I think I'd drop the two-island concept and instead go with a simple row of cabinets against the wall and a large island dividing the kitchen from the great room. This would be very affordable to build, and it would look great with that layout -- as well as increasing the size of a modest great room. - I like the dining room except for the door to the porch. Once you insert a table, it'll block access to the door. The great room doors are only steps away, and this door isn't needed. This dining room would look great with a banquette against the wall, and that would make the dining room more spacious. - The dining room must serve as a walkway to the secondary bedrooms, and you have a "bottleneck" in the spot where the kitchen and the dining room meet at the corner -- keep in mind you're going to have to bring bedroom furniture through that narrow spot. - I like jack-and-jill closets, but this one seems cramped and is just doors-doors-doors everywhere. Imagine if you ever needed to replace that tub - a new one could never be brought into that spot. - Do they need the e-space near the secondary bedrooms, or would that be better as a large storage closet? If you ever do have a paid caregiver in the house, a good-sized closet would be an asset for that person. OR, if they have lots of grandchildren who enjoy spending the night, that little spot could be a cool little built-in bunkbed right in the hallway. OR, you could move the half-bath to this position, allowing for a more comfortable laundry room. - The laundry room suffers from the same problem as the kitchen: The walking area is quite narrow, which is not age-friendly. Moving through that narrow hallway with a basket of clothes may not be so easy as your parents age. Note, too, that when you open that door, it covers up a portion of your folding area. All that wasted hallway space could make a nicer laundry room. It'd be nice if it could be closer to the master bedroom closet.
...See More
Debating between single wall oven or range. Please weigh in!
Q
Comments (19)
I don't know how much baking or cooking you have time to do, or if you have special diet needs for your family that might be a bit more intense, but your wall is so nice, a great wall oven would fit nicely wherever it is easiest and efficient, like do you do alot of pot roasts or long term baking? if you do, you will love the wall oven on that wall your frig is on. IF you wonder what to do, given my experience with the drop in unit not being as quality overall typically as a cook top and wall oven, but the oven is larger than a built in oven,I think, typically. So, if you really wonder, and if you enjoy baking things for the family like a roast and a pie at the same time or pies and cookies that require alot of in and out, you might consider a drop in unit, just for the economics of getting the 2nd oven area, as well as the wall unit oven on your pantry/frig wall cabinet area.... Than you get the effect of that table top cooktop, and the wall oven, and you have the lower oven for less money than a 2nd built in oven would ever be! Find yourself the best quality built in oven you might want, for the wall where the frig is, and than, knowing that a larger oven is typically part of the drop in range unit, get the nicest one you can either afford or tolerate LOL. That to me, IF YOU DON'T need the lower storage below the cooktop, of course, would be heaven. You have the 2nd built in oven, they typically will hold a standard roaster, but not a roaster and a sheet of brown n' serve rolls, or muffins also.....and you have the oven below the drop in range unit if you need it. Than, you can dedicate all the island storage on the dining room side of your island to the oven and stovetop cookware. If you haven't thought of that before, well, that's what you get when you go asking for help. Too many good ideas!? LOL I worked full time, and loved to have company for all the occassions that go with kids growing up, and to have that 2nd oven, just in case I needed it to keep the covered dishes warm that folks brought or to catch the overflow on the days when all 4 of us were feeling like baking projects for bake sales or food competitions with 4 H or the like.. What a nice kitchen you are going to enjoy! no matter how you determine in the end. I don't care for convection ovens too much, unless you want to bake something covered well(not home made pizza. HAHA) but a gas oven and an electric oven, would be nice options too. If you have a gas drop in unit, get an electric oven built in on your pantry wall, maybe??. I have no experience with the units where the cooktop is gas and the attached oven is electric or vice versa..tho I have seen them in stores the past 10 or 15 years? if that long..
...See More
Building a Home / House Plans
Q
Comments (64)
Some people really like to do-it-yourself. I do. For example, I trim my own bangs. It's a money saver and I think I do a pretty good job. (And if I make a slip, in a few weeks they're long enough to trim straight again!) And if I was looking for a pretty standard type of house, I might just find some standard plans that worked for me. But if I had the kind of non-standard wants that the OP did, and was laying down $$$ for a house, I'd want someone who had the right training to do a custom job for me. Especially if I'd been looking at standard plans and finding nothing that suits me.
...See More
sanctuarygirl
11 years ago
Hi, there! I, too, have these two plans on my list of possibilities and have been studying them both for some time.

I prefer the Chesnee for the following reasons: 1. I dislike the guest br arrangement in the Ficannon, in particular, the J&J bath. Like the hall bath in the Chesnee. 2. Don't like the hearth/brkfst/kitchen layout of the Ficannon, as I have jumped on the single eating area bandwagon, as illustrated in the Chesnee. The dining area combined with the seating at the long island is sufficient. 3. I like the outdoor porch spaces much better on the Chesnee. They have much more usable space. 4. Like the kitchen and its window on an outside wall on the Chesnee. 5. The utility room, mudroom, and pantry in the Chesnee is much superior to that in the Ficannon.

I agree with you about eliminating the sitting area on the mbr space. That would bring the square footage down another 100 ft.
Houseofsticks
11 years ago
If your children are not of nursery age I'd pick Fincannon. I would reverse the stairs (enter by the bedrooms and hearthroom.). I would also change the Jack and Jill to a common area bathroom. Add a hall entry door (pocket door to make it more private. This with the changes would fit MY family perfectly but, you need to share with us more about your needs/family.

There are alot of fireplaces $$ and Don Gardner plans seem to be pricey to build. I'd sooner eliminate the dining room than the hearthroom and use it as dining as the light will be fantastic there.
dpusa
11 years ago
For my I prefer the Chesnee - we have two children so it would fit my family. That being said, I would turn the bedroom in the top right into an ensuite for your daughter as unless you have guests then she should be the one who benefits from it.
A word of caution, a LOT of folks have experienced high building costs from Don Gardner plans.
BuildingSoon1
Original Author
11 years ago
I appreciate the feedback so much!

I forgot to mention in my previous post that we intend to nix finishing out the bonus room but add an unfinished basement (to be completed in time). My husband and his family build homes and my husband is a project manager so what he/family does not complete, we will contract out the people he knows so that will decrease some cost. We live in Kentucky and this home will be on a one acre lot, so we should be fine with proportions. Building cost in this area are $75-100 per sq ft when self contracting the house construction.

We do currently only have a 2 year old but would like to have 3 kids so we're trying to plan for the future. We also have family that come stay with us often so we need guest quarters. When the basement is finished, I would like to put the guest room there but could use the study for that purpose in the meantime.

I think we are leaning towards the Chesnee but are open to any ideas regarding how to decrease sq footage (other than eliminating the sitting room)without changing the overall floorplan. Also wondering about the lack of linen closets and if you see good places to put those. Thanks!!
kirkhall
11 years ago
Re: linen closets:
Turn the "storage" area in the garage to the hall side of the house for a reach in closet.
In the Master bath, there can be a linen tower to the left of the left vanity.

Will you have a basement? You can use under the stairs as additional storage/closet space as well.

I'm not a fan of the kitchen in the Chesnee, but there is a lot of room there. Just take the dimensions to the kitchen forum and get feedback on a proper, safer, better utilized kitchen space there.
JDMoore
10 years ago
Hello. I will be building the Chesnee house plan. I agree to remove the sitting area from the Master BR, not sure it adds any value. I found a few pictures of finished houses for the Birchwood model on Don Gardner's website. This will give you an idea of what it will look like finished. There is one being built in Hendersonville, NC. I will be going to see it this Friday. Did you decide to build the Chesnee, and if so, is it under construction now. I'd be curious to see know how it's going.
JessandWes Jarriel
10 years ago
JDMoore can you give me details of where the home was built in Hendersonville, NC? My husband and I are looking to build this plan and would love to go see this home. Did you see it?
Erinrenee
9 years ago
I love both of these plans, the Fincannon for the hearth room and the Chesnee for the kitchen with windows. Unfortunately, my husband hates them both, but has agreed to walk them if ican find themnanywhere in the SE within 500 miles of Jacksonville FL. PLEASE respond to me if you have one of these plans being built or that is already built that we could tour. Much appreciated!!!
musicgal
9 years ago
I love the Chesnee plan for a young family. Here's why-

1) The bedroom/ study that is adjacent to the foyer can be built to be walled off from the foyer and used as a nursery for the second baby. In both plans, using the split places parents and small children on the opposite side of the house. Doable with monitors but not optimal for late night treks through the home.

2) That sitting area can become a lovely study with access to nature and the backyard, instead of a pretentious showplace room up front. You would not necessarily have to have all your papers off your desk when company came over... and could read back there in your pj's when your spouse is entertaining friends in the public areas. I love that sitting area as a retreat!

3) The lines of sight and outdoor space are awesome and promise a young family the ability to supervise the heirs from the comfort of their domicile.

It is a wonderful family home. When the front bedroom no longer is needed for little ones, it will become a great guest bedroom.
musicgal
9 years ago
I love the Chesnee plan for a young family. Here's why-

1) The bedroom/ study that is adjacent to the foyer can be built to be walled off from the foyer and used as a nursery for the second baby. In both plans, using the split places parents and small children on the opposite side of the house. Doable with monitors but not optimal for late night treks through the home.

2) That sitting area can become a lovely study with access to nature and the backyard, instead of a pretentious showplace room up front. You would not necessarily have to have all your papers off your desk when company came over... and could read back there in your pj's when your spouse is entertaining friends in the public areas. I love that sitting area as a retreat!

3) The lines of sight and outdoor space are awesome and promise a young family the ability to supervise the heirs from the comfort of their domicile.

It is a wonderful family home. When the front bedroom no longer is needed for little ones, it will become a great guest bedroom.
buildingverysoon
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Hi BuildingSoon1 , which house plan did you decide to go with? We are leaning Fincannon ourselves, but will rearrange the J&J back into a hall bath. btw Houseofsticks we are trying to reverse stairs to enter from hearth room, but are struggling with the 2nd floor. the entry to bonus room is looking awkward.
Scott Sauder
6 years ago
My wife and I are looking to build the Chesnee as well. If anyone has built this and is willing to talk to us about it please email me at scsauder@gmail.com or call me at 419-612-5185. Thanks!
Pam Craig
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
We are building the Chesnee! We just got our plans back today. We love the kitchen, that there isn't a formal dining room and the our door space. We are using the sitting room as an art room for my husband. If he didn't want it as an art room I would remove it. The back of our home will face a huge lake and mountains. We also flipped the plan. I only wish the master bath was laid out different and a little bigger. It lacks enough linen closet space and counter top space. We are currently looking at changing the master bath layout.

You can follow us building it at: https://www.facebook.com/BuildingOurNewHomeTheChesnee/
PRO
Highlands Homes
6 years ago
Hey there - I tried to follow your page, but FB says it’s not there. We are getting ready to build the Chesnee as well and I’m interested to watch your progress!
Scott Sauder
6 years ago
I was following them on facebook and I believe they decided to build a different home.
Scott Sauder
6 years ago
My wife and I are also planning on building the Chesnee. I would love to take to you about it. Email me or text me at
rjinga
4 years ago
resurrecting this tread, would love to hear from anyone who built this home...we are looking at the Chesnee as well, considering a few changes overall: In the master bath we will change the layout, also will make larger walk in closet longer and will use smaller walk in for a sauna. We are converting the 2 rooms at the back of the right side to an oversized gameroom/office/gym (removing closets between them). Since it's just the 2 of us, we can do this easily for the best use of the space and best views of the lake, this would be a space we would be in a lot. I also will not have the second island/bar on the outside of the kitchen, so will extend side cabinets on the left side of the kitchen equal to where that bar was and instead will have a larger square shaped island (as big as I can get that will fit the space properly). Also want to make the pantry larger and convert E space to a butlers pantry facing the dining room. Garage storage turns into inside linen cabinet. perfect since it's right by the laundry room. We want the bonus room to be above the back 2 bedroom areas facing the back instead of over the garage.
Gaye Barks_Cox
3 years ago
I’m obviously very late finding this thread, but we did build the Chesnee plan and would be happy to share pictures, etc. email me at gayelynncox@yahoo.com

Debating between Chesnee and Fincannon House Plans

virgilcarter

Comments (21)

BuildingSoon1
Original Author

BuildingSoon1
Original Author

Related Discussions

sanctuarygirl

Houseofsticks

dpusa

BuildingSoon1
Original Author

kirkhall

JDMoore

JessandWes Jarriel

Erinrenee

musicgal

musicgal

buildingverysoon

Scott Sauder

Pam Craig

Highlands Homes

Scott Sauder

Scott Sauder

rjinga

Gaye Barks_Cox

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Debating between Chesnee and Fincannon House Plans

Comments (21)

BuildingSoon1Original Author

BuildingSoon1Original Author

Related Discussions

BuildingSoon1Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

BuildingSoon1
Original Author

BuildingSoon1
Original Author

BuildingSoon1
Original Author