"Safely Remove" Use or not to use?

10 years ago

My son told me that the tech at his work said you do not need to use "Safely Remove" on his W-7 laptop when detaching printers, media cards, flash drives, etc. I'm "Old School" and can't hardly believe this. Who is correct.....Mom or the Tech??

BTW; I have a (new to me) W-7 laptop and there is no Safely Remove Icon. I have checked everywhere for a restore, but no luck. I have to go to My Computer and locate the item then hit "Eject". Is this the only solution?

TIA, MsMary

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (15)

DA_Mccoy
10 years ago
If the attached media is removed improperly there is risk. The three biggest potential concerns are; loss of data, turning the data into read only, and the loss of the use of the media space from which data had just been deleted.

A basic Google search using the keywords "windows 7 safe remove" (sans quotes) presents a plethora of information such as below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Microsoft
Elmer J Fudd
10 years ago
Mom is always right, no matter what the subject!

On this one, I don't have a technical answer but I have a practical one. I use the "remove" step for memory items I care about - cards and external drives. Someone once pulled out a SD card from one of my PCs without doing "remove" and about half the files on it got corrupted and inaccesible. It wasn't in the middle of a read/write operation to my knowledge, it just wasn't ready to leave the dock.

It's a few seconds to, easy enough.
Related Discussions
hard wired cooktop safe removal
Q
Comments (9)
You shouldn't have to open two breakers. The rangetop should be connected to a double-pole breaker (twice the width of the other breakers). If it isn't, it was installed in violation of code. (I've seen a 240v central air-con unit improperly wired to two separate breakers.) To test, set meter on 200 volts range or higher. Touch one probe of the voltmeter to the metal junction box. Touch the other to the red and black wires in turn. You should read close to zero volts, or at least something under about 20 volts. If both are zero or nearly so, as a backup check, set the meter to 500 volts or higher. Touch one probe to red and the other to black. You should again read only a very small voltage reading, if any. It's safer and better, IMO, to test with a test light or Wiggy, for several reasons.
...See More
Old cabs: how to safely remove old paint?
Q
Comments (13)
It's probably a safe assumption that there will be lead in the lower layers given the age of the house, I think---not even sure I'd bother to test it. (They do test for free here, though---I wouldn't be surprised if Portland does too.) Lead was in virtually all enamel/cabinet/trim paint before the late 60s. But you can still sand with the sponges---that's what they're designed for, in part. When they're wet, they'll contain the dust so that it's not all over the place; a mask will also help to make sure you're not breathing it, and then afterwards you wet mop to get up any bits of dust on the floor. We did the whole lead testing and education bit with our county last year, and it was super helpful. One of the more important things I learned was that while lead is icky stuff, it's largely a concern if it's eaten or inhaled in quantities, so you can do a lot to prevent that and to let older kids know to avoid chipping paint and wash hands after touching it. It's also less of a concern if it's a one-time project than if it's ongoing chipping, like with a window where someone's painted the sash so every time it opens or closes, fine dust comes down. Projects can be more easily secured so toddlers and pets are away from the work. The really important thing they drilled into us was that the surface of the paint needs to be intact---you don't need to remove lead paint, but you do need to have it covered with a good layer of new paint on top. It's worse to take some of it off and open up lower layers to chipping/flaking than just to leave them alone and paint over with good quality paint, unless you have the resources (time, energy and/or money!) to strip down to the bare wood. In your case, I'd only touch it enough to get it into paintable shape. The biggest problem we had was our dog---lead paint chips apparently smell/taste sweet, which is what attracts babies too. So we would constantly catch him snuffling in an area where work was going on, trying to find the chips. Finally just gave up on that and shut him out of the room all together till we were done!
...See More
How to SAFELY remove loropetalums. Advice requested.
Q
Comments (10)
Eleven days later, my loropetalums are gone. I kept exposing and cutting roots and neighbor pulled up both stumps yesterday. One hole is about 5'x3', the one near sewer line much smaller. Dave in NVA, I'm working hard now trying to get a large % of the roots removed. They are intertwined with many smaller roots and a web of surface roots. One I got last night was over 10' long. Using a huge pry bar to lift then sever with various loppers or a hand saw. Will be back soon with measurements of the entire area seeking your advice of planting options. It can be a really attractive front area, maybe with a couple of trees planted 12' or so from the foundation. Appreciate everyone's help. Rosie
...See More
Help! How to safely remove lacquer spray from marble?
Q
Comments (8)
laurenjean and paintguy- It''s true that lacquer thinner is a powerful solvent, but 1: If the marble is sealed, all the overspray should be on top of the sealer and the razor blade should remove all of it overspray, making a wipe with lacquer thinner unnecessary. 2. If there is no sealer, a wipe with lacquer thinner shouldn't hurt marble. (Marble is typically damaged by acid compounds, like lemon juice, or alkalis, like drain cleaner. If one has concerns, you could test the thinner on a marble scrap or a small unnoticeable area. However, if it's real marble, and not some man-made composite, there should not be an issue.) 3, Sealer can be reapplied in any case...it's not like trying to match a stain.
...See More
Pooh Bear
10 years ago
My understanding of the process is that using "safely remove hardware" turns off the signal to the USB port. Not turning off this signal can cause arcing of the contacts and burn out of the USB port.

I use the option every chance I can, but sometimes a flash drive refuses to disconnect so I just unplug it. Never had a problem so far.

Pooh Bear
owbist
10 years ago
I use the option every chance I can, but sometimes a flash drive refuses to disconnect so I just unplug it. Never had a problem so far.

That is not an option with Windows 7. Myself I go to Windows Explorer and right click on the USB drive then click Eject.
jane__ny
10 years ago
I never use it on my old desktop, XP - it never worked. If I clicked 'safely remove.' I would have to restart my computer to put another drive in. Never shut off.

This machine is 6 yrs old and I never lost anything and used it almost daily for 6 years without 'safely.'

I guess I was lucky!
Jane
burnchar
10 years ago
Here's the technical answer:

When you *write* a file to a USB drive (or any drive) and Windows/Mac says the copy is finished, it's not finished.

To speed things up, part of the file is "cached" in memory -- the copy finishes shortly after. You can disable this, but I wouldn't recommend it.

"Safely remove" ensures that the data is completely written to the drive. If you haven't written anything to the drive, or if the file copy finished more than about 10 seconds ago OR the "busy" light stopped flashing (or whatever it does on your device, if such a light exists), then it's perfectly safe to remove the device with a few rare exceptions.

If you did write a file and remove the device too early, that file will simply not be written to the disk. This is a slight oversimplification which involves the file system journal and other details which I'll discuss if anyone cares, but I'm just trying to give a rule of thumb here.

It's never "wrong" to "Safely remove", but it wastes a little bit of time.
msm84
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks everyone! I guess I'd rather be "safe" then "sorry" and continue doing what I have always done ((grin))

Still don't have the icon so I'll use My Computer and stop the drive from there.
jane__ny
10 years ago
At the end of the workday, I would back up my files to three different drives. I never hit 'safely' because I would have to restart the computer each time. I would plug the drive in, back up, pull it out, put the next one in and so on.

If I shut off the drive from My Computer, it wouldn't start again when I put in a drive. I would have to reboot. So I just gave up, could never figure out what the problem was.

Never lost anything although I realize it was a risk.

This desktop is now used at home and I still do the same thing although it not work related, just photos and standard backups.

Jane
DA_Mccoy
10 years ago
Jane,

The noise you hear is the clock of fate ticking. If it happens I will assure you it will happen at the most inconvenient time. Been there.

DA
jane__ny
10 years ago
No noise.

Computer has always worked perfectly except for 'safely.' I'm not complaining. Just wanted to point out that not using 'safely' hasn't caused me any problems.

Planning to donate this computer whenever I get the 'urge' to learn Win 8.

Jane
kanooka
10 years ago
msm84.....the icon is there, it just set up a little differently in windows 7.....

If you go down to your taskbar, near your clock you'll see the icons that run at startup....there is a little upward pointing arrow, just at the end of that list.....if you put your pointer on it, it will say Show Hidden Icons, left click on it & then left click on Customize....find the entry for Windows Explorer & set it to "Show Icons & Notifications"......click OK.....

Now the Safely Remove Hardware icon will appear when you insert a usb drive....

Hope this helps,
Kanooka
DA_Mccoy
10 years ago
Jane,

W8 isn't tough. Just different.

Go for it.
msm84
Original Author
10 years ago
Kanooka Thanks...That worked!!

Just one more question: So I have a usb port open I have a hub I plug in for my mouse and keyboard (hate the laptop keyboard) and it doesn't show up in "Safely Remove". Is there an explanation for that?
msm84
Original Author
10 years ago
Jane, There should be choices of things to stop. I know with my external card reader I just select the card in question (the blue light goes out next to it) and not the entire card reader. Sounds like you are turning off the "Drive" not just the "Device". Maybe one of the techs here can verify that.
DA_Mccoy
10 years ago
M,

You are right on point.

DA

"Safely Remove" Use or not to use?

Comments (15)

DA_Mccoy

Elmer J Fudd

Related Discussions

Pooh Bear

owbist

jane__ny

burnchar

msm84
Original Author

jane__ny

DA_Mccoy

jane__ny

kanooka

DA_Mccoy

msm84
Original Author

msm84
Original Author

DA_Mccoy

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

"Safely Remove" Use or not to use?

Comments (15)

Related Discussions

msm84Original Author

msm84Original Author

msm84Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

msm84
Original Author

msm84
Original Author

msm84
Original Author