gas vs. electric?
nikkidan
12 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (37)
Chemocurl zn5b/6a Indiana
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoRelated Discussions
Exterior Lighting - Gas vs Electricity
Comments (10)I have heard 15-20 dollars per month per light. So if you have two double that ;) We have been here a few months and don't have ours installed yet but I will be able to know exactly how much they cost in a month or so when they are put in. The other negative is that they give out very little light. We put can lights in the ceilings of both of our overhangs over front and friends porch door for illumination and gas for looks. It goes without saying it is not particularly "green" to do this but those are the facts ;) You can do the electric ignition but our builder strongly discouraged it. He says they are very problematic. Of course, this is the only his opinion but I trusted it. They are also significantly more expensive....See MoreGas vs electric cooking
Comments (56)I'm glad someone finally brought induction into the discussion. I remodeled our kitchen about 10 years ago and put in an induction cooktop and I would echo everything sprtphntc says. It's hands-down the best option. In the last year we've moved to a new place that has a giant Viking gas range, and although many people look at it and say "You're a great cook, you must love that big gas range" Well "love" isn't the word I would choose. It's not awful, like some entry level gas ranges I have used, but in almost every way it is not as good as the induction cooktop I left behind. The Induction cooktop had settings from Low to 1 through 9 to Power Boost, and changing the power level nearly instantly changes the heat output (which is like gas), but the gas ranges highest high setting, compares to about 7 on the induction unit, and its lowest low setting is about a 3 on the induction unit. Plus much of the heat from the gas range goes up the side of the pot, either scorching food on the sides of the pot, or heating the pot handle to hand-searing levels or just heating the room. The burners are hard to ignite, sometimes taking 10 seconds of spewing gas and clicking before erupting in a cloud of fire. Conversely, more than a few times when I've turned the gas all the way down, the flame has simply gone out, sometimes unnoticed by me, and slowly started filling the room with gas. Yay. After ten years of frequent use, the induction cooktop still looks essentially new, except for some minor scratching on the stainless steel frame. Whereas the Viking range is older than that, but from the looks of it, it has never been cleaned....See Moregas vs electric oven side by side tests?
Comments (5)I don’t have a video or even pictures but my sister and I bake the same oatmeal cookies, the vanishing oatmeal cookie recipe from the top of the Quaker Oats box. We both use the same ingredients and pans but she bakes them in a gas oven and I use electric. We have probably baked these 100s of times and mine are thicker and chewy while hers are thin and crispy. Both are good, but they are different. “ I think people have also said that gas is a more moist heat than electric” This was sort of what was taught for many years based on the idea that gas gives off water as a byproduct of combustion. Capital even had the chemical equation on their website at one time. No one was considering the oven as a whole or what moisture was being produced by the food cooking which can produce 100% humidity. it is a very ingrained belief and will still see this on manufacturers websites and it is still being taught by some chefs. There are some videos on YouTube that say this. I’ve heard Alton Brown say this too, so it can get a little confusing. Rather than argue whether one or the other has more humidity, the most important thing is to look at what people say happens to food. These statements show how gas vs electric ovens relate to cooking. You could stop there but if you want to know what is happening as far as humidity, in the last ten years there has been an explosion of information in understanding the science of cooking. If you read about the Maillard reaction, you will see what is required to make that happen. I would strongly consider researching this yourself if it is important and see what makes sense. Don’t take my word for it. These are some of the comments you hear over and over on cooking, baking and even appliance forums. If if you read the fresh loaf forum, people who add huge amounts of steam to a gas oven comment how quickly the added steam leaves the oven. There are threads on how to add large amounts of steam and some people use a cloche for baking bread. This happens because gas ovens require a much larger vent to allow the products of combustion to escape. People complain about the heat and moisture being released into the kitchen compared to an electric oven. Bread bakers want the steam because it produces a certain type of crust because steam promotes starch gelatinization. Beside adding steam, just the steam from what is baking can promote starch gelatinization in cakes or muffins if it stays in the oven. This gives a little longer time period for rising. Baking is complex though and there are recipes that work perfectly well in a gas oven. I think you notice more if you are changing from one type of oven to the other. I have read over time several bakers comment that their cakes did not rise as well in a gas oven. I’ve seen it go the other way where somebody commented that the electric oven had too much moisture. If you read the BS manual about gas ovens, they mention that a gas oven will have condensation on the window initially, but as it heats, it disappears. People say that gas ovens brown brown better and meat is moist. If you read about the browning reactions(Maillard is one), you will find that you must have superficial drying so that the temperature of the surface can rise enough for the browning reactions to take place. This is true if you are stir frying, searing meat in a skillet or roasting in an oven. As long as you have moisture evaporating, it has a cooling effect. Gas has more air moving through, removing both products of combustion and moisture from what is cooking. I’ve seen articles written that say “gas ovens have moist heat so things might not brown as well” but in actual cooking and baking forums people say the opposite. Why is meat moist? It is complex but the amount of water remaining in the meat fibers is dependent on the internal temperature of the meat. External moisture will not help that. This explains what happens at different temperatures. Also read “Amazing Ribs” website. j Kenji Lope-Alt has also written about this subject. https://blog.thermoworks.com/beef/coming-heat-effects-muscle-fibers-meat/ Many people judge meat’s doneness by its appearance. If your meat isn’t browning as well, it stays longer in the oven until it gets “done” in appearance. It can be very over cooked and dried out by the time it looks “done”. Gas heat browns faster so looks done faster Leaving the inside not over cooked. I use a thermometer any time I cook meat. Looking at electric ovens, if you add a convection fan, this accelerates the rate of heat transfer so is drying and promotes browning in those ovens giving them a little more flexibilitY. Convection is a whole other topic as to what it does in baking. There is a professional baker that I read about that uses electric ovens for cakes at home and bakes standard bake the first half and then opens the door briefly to let the steam out and flips the fan on to get more browning. I do that when I think of it. The ovens with the most control of the cooking environment are combi ovens. If you read the use and care manuals for Gaggenau and Miele, you can learn a lot about what levels of humidity are beneficial at what stages of baking and roasting. They talk about the fact that a cake baking provides enough steam, that it is equivalent to the 30% setting. The down side is that they are smaller than many 30” ovens. Next would be electric ovens that have multiple directions of heat and fan speeds. There are a few gas ovens trying to do this too. These vary tremendously so even if you did have a video to show the difference in a particular gas and electric oven, it would only be a good comparison for those two ovens....See MoreGas vs. Electric Range Preheat times?
Comments (3)There are several factors that come in to preheating an oven other than just the fuel source. It includes the size, but in addition to the oven volume you have to account for what's in it (other than air), the seals (not just the door) and insulation, and the maximum power of that fuel source -- not all ovens offer the same. So there may be anecdotal stories of one person's oven experiences, but to really know you'd have to account for all those other things....See Morestooxie
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agostooxie
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoSeeBuyFly
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agogeo91324
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoweissman
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoweissman
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agotubeman
12 years agoCaddidaddy55
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoCaddidaddy55
12 years agojscout
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agofoodonastump
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoweissman
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years agoCaddidaddy55
12 years agoNunyabiz1
12 years ago
Related Stories
DECORATING GUIDESDecorating With Neon: It’s a Gas
Illuminated letters are lighting up interiors. What would your sign say?
Full StoryLIVING ROOMSHow to Convert Your Wood-Burning Fireplace
Learn about inserts and other options for switching your fireplace from wood to gas or electric
Full StoryKITCHEN APPLIANCESFind the Right Cooktop for Your Kitchen
For a kitchen setup with sizzle, deciding between gas and electric is only the first hurdle. This guide can help
Full StoryACCESSORIESEasy Green: Cut Electricity Use With 15 Unplugged Home Devices
Crank up the energy savings, courtesy of household items that come into power the old-fashioned way: manually
Full StoryHOME TECHPlug Into Home Power Monitors That Pay for Themselves
Stop throwing away money on wasted electricity with help from new monitors that work with your phone or computer
Full StoryFIREPLACESRibbons of Fire: 10 Artfully Minimalist Fireplaces
Long and lean and sleek to the core, these gas-burning fireplaces make a powerful contemporary statement
Full StoryOUTDOOR KITCHENSYour Guide to Grills and More for Great Outdoor Cooking
Learn the pros and cons of gas versus charcoal grills, and about neat add-ons that let you do more
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESClean-Burning Woodstoves Ignite a Greener Heating Trend
No need to rely on oil or gas to heat your home — new woodstove designs burn cleanly and are beautiful to boot
Full StoryLIFEHow to Prepare for and Live With a Power Outage
When electricity loss puts food, water and heat in jeopardy, don't be in the dark about how to stay as safe and comfortable as possible
Full StoryDISASTER PREP & RECOVERYMore Power to You: How to Pick the Right Generator
If your home's electricity goes, don't let it take your necessities with it — keep systems running with this guide to backup power
Full Story
foodonastump