Some people don't care, but personally I prefer American made products. If that's the case for you, GE is the only one making SxS fridges here (not any of the models you listed though). The rest are hecho en Mexico. So because of that if it were me I would go with GSH25 (not counter depth, msrp 1400). But that's just me. If you don't care about that I'd just pick on appearance, price, and features and don't worry about online reviews too much. Most are just people who had a problem and have axes to grind. The ice maker and thru the door dispenser are achilles heels for the units that have them, and none of the brands seem to be immune to issues with those things.

We've had the Jenn-Air side by side, (built in and paneled) for over 6 years now. It has been trouble free with the exception of the ice maker, which failed after about 5 years. A new ice maker cost me about $145 and took me about 10 minutes to change it. We like the fact that 3 different temps can be set in the fridge compartment, one for the meats, one for the veggie and fruit keeper and one for the main fridge. Being older, we like the fact that the stuff we use the most, in either the fridge or the freezer can be kept at height that is convenient for us. We like the crank up and down shelves, the digital readouts for temperatures (4 of them) --meat keeper, veggies, main fridge and freezer. It is very quiet, and the first time I have ever heard any noise whatsover out of it was a few weeks ago after cleaning the condenser area and changing the water filter. I did not get the cover back on correctly and it was blocking air, the fan for the condenser kick on to full speed, still not very noisy but I could hear it. I put the cover on correctly and all was well, again and silence. The JA uses a variable speed compressor as I think most fridges in the Whirlpool family do, along with Miele and Liebher. These allow for better temp control, are more efficient and quieter than the old on/off compressors. In fact, I believe that Jenn-Air now quotes a temp accuracy, (being able to stay at a set temp) of +/- half a degree "F". This of course is "Overkill" but it does give you an idea of what some of the new technology can do. Good luck with your decisions. The best way is to go and look at them in person. that's what we did and the JA won out over the SZ and GE, which back in 2005 were the only 48" built in fridges made. Gary

5 years old? My Kenmore is 12 years old and going strong. And I gave away the older kenmore to a friend as a beer fridge 12 years ago (it was 'old' then) and it ran fine in his garage until last spring. But neither had ice makers, which are the first thing to go.

I placed and impromptu order for one to go with my Bosch DW and range, and promptly canceled the order when I got home. I couldn't get past the consistently negative reviews - I didn't see many but those I did read were bad.