Q-Seal to permanently seal stone - anyone use?

11 years ago

While in a tile store today, I saw a brochure for Q-Seal which supposedly permanently seals stone including marble. Anyone have any experience with this? The saleswoman was of course very positive about the product. She said it's about $3.50 per square foot for the process. Process involves applying sealer and tiles are baked in an oven to make the sealer permanent.

I would really love to use carrara marble in my shower but I'm afraid of the upkeep and the marble staining over time. I've been looking but haven't found a porcelain look alike that we like. If I could do this to the stone and it works, it might be my answer.

Has anyone had this done to their stone or know of anyone who has?

Here is a link that might be useful: Q-Seal website

Featured Answer

bill_vincent

11 years ago

And start looking at the faux marble from 3-5 feet away instead of 6" away!

I actually did a project last summer where every person on the job, even close up, thought the tile was real calacutta gold.

Our stone vendor said that spilling something like nail polish remover would kill the tile even with q seal on it but I figure that's what the guarantee is for.

And this is exactly why I'm so against these lifetime guarantee sealers. To many things can happen way beyond the company's control that would be well beyond the sealer's capability to protect the stone, and therefore void the warranty. It's my opinion that this stuff, Granite Shield, they're all the same-- they're not selling you a sealer, they're selling you a warranty, that can easily be voided later.

And as for this statement:

Marble and limestone and other porous stones may be all the designer craze now, but just give it 5 years and the fad will have passed and some other something will be the new fad.

This month makes 32 years I've been in the trade full time (but I've been in it all my life, with my father and grandfather also being tile contractors), and stone showers have been extremely popular with the upscale crowd that whole time. I think that just might be a little more than a fad.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

bill_vincent
11 years ago
I would not want to permanently seal stone. Sooner or later, moisture will get into the stone. With the solvent based sealers, moisture is allowed to transmit back and forth through the membrane (what's called a "breathable" sealer) so that it doesn't get trapped in the stone, causing mold or mildew to get started INSIDE the stone. I've never heard of this stuff, but there was another one a few years ago in here and the kitchens forum trying to push a very similar product. She threatened to sue me unless I ceased putting her product down. I told her to prove any one of my accusations wrong and I'll stop. She couldn't.
User
11 years ago
Marble and limestone and other porous stones may be all the designer craze now, but just give it 5 years and the fad will have passed and some other something will be the new fad. You're the one who has to live with all of the maintenance for the next 15 years.

So, if you want faux stone, get faux stone. (I certainly would!) It'll look better and perform better than faux stone made with real stone coated in plastic and baked in an oven.

And start looking at the faux marble from 3-5 feet away instead of 6" away! It's not meant to survive a close up inspection, but to look okay at normal viewing distances such as on the floor or wall or in the shower without your glasses.
Related Discussions
Q re: seal on milk jugs being used
Q
Comments (5)
Don't worry about the seal. I used both small pieces of duck tape in the corners, and also punched holes and used twist ties to close the gallon milk jugs. There was no "seal" in that case. They do fine! The condensation is a good sign, because that means the soil is moist. If they are placed outside in a location where they get precipitation fairly regularly, you will not have to worry about watering them until weather warms up in the Spring. Having a loose seal around the middle allows a little more moisture to get in, which is a good thing. You will be amazed at how much sprouts! There will inevitably be a few that don't sprout, for whatever reason - dud seeds, seeds buried too deep, who knows? I sowed 158 containers last year, with a germination rate of 86%. Maybe a little higher because there were a couple containers that germinated in the summer!
...See More
Marble bonded to porcelain permanently sealed
Q
Comments (0)
I saw a product yesterday that is new to me. It is a permanently sealed natural marble bonded to porcelain. The marble was a crema marfil. It is georgeous. I was looking for a 24 x 24 porcelain colored and veined to coordinate with adjacent crema marfil floors in the home we are building. I want the porcelain for the laundry, my art studio, and the studio's bath/wet studio area. The price point on this product (quoted at $4.70 per sq ft) is very acceptable, but I am leery of the claims that this product is permanently sealed and will withstand the abuse of the area I need it for. The flooring man told me they use this marble in airports and car dealership showrooms very successfully. Has anyone used this type of product? I do not know the name of the manufacturer. The closest thing I can find on the Net is at Leeza. They do not claim to have a permanent sealer on their product. http://www.leezadistribution.com/products-accolade-marble-info.html Please post with any advice you can give! Thanks!
...See More
Granite question -To seal or not to seal..
Q
Comments (36)
I love my black galaxy! Looking into it is like 3-D, such depth! One of the most bullet proof stones around. I have mine in the master bath but am trying to convince DH to do the kitchen too. It is the most easy care counter I have ever had. People complained about it showing dust and fingerprints but I haven't noticed any problem at all. Once in a while, one of the kids makes a mess with toothpaste and soap but it just wipes off so easy with plain water. Just FYI, no sealer! If you get hard water spots, the best thing to do is scrape them off gently with a razor blade and remember, no abrasive sponges, you know the kind that have the one rough green or blue side. They will scratch our granite but I was told the round loose scrubby things are okay, they are just nylon. Now, lets see PICTURES! What edge did you pick?
...See More
Sealing marble: anyone use the Dupont sealer w/ 15 year warranty
Q
Comments (9)
Mine is Stone Tech -- made by DuPont. Not sure if it's the same one you are talking about but I've had it down just short of 4 years. I have no complaints with it. I would just get the sealer and don't worry about the warranty. Not only is it like buying a tire and thinking they'll replace your car, you don't want the counters replaced, the cabinets and slash possibly damaged, your sink and plumbing upset (which I'm sure they won't cover), and that's assuming you overcome the it wasn't applied correctly and it wasn't maintained correctly exceptions. They said repair or replace, and chances are the only thing they will do is tell you that you that the sealer either wasn't applied correctly or that it is a wear area where you should have reapplied sealer and then apply a poultice and tell you to reseal the area. I doubt they do pay out on any replacements. But it sounds good. Marble is a very durable stone and can be worked with. Most sealers will do a fine job of protecting from stains. They do need to be reapplied, especially in your heavy traffic areas. I've only spot resealed in some wear spots, but I've had tomato sauce, chocolate and other stuff splattered in places I didn't see and clean until the morning after. No stains. In the wear area by my sink, I had a light tea stain, but it came right out with any special efforts -- a little cleaner and a light buffing. If it were worse, I'd have been here looking for a poultice to put on it. To me, that's less of an issue than waiting around to have someone come do it for me, dealing with the dogs while they do it and having to listen to "don't you know this about your marble, honey." Get the marble and enjoy it -- or don't. Don't get it thinking miracle products will change the nature of the stone and make it okay for you. Be okay with the stone itself if you are going to get it.
...See More
nikinikinine
11 years ago
We are using q seal on our marble shower floor and bathroom floor. Our marble shower seat and countertops will not be q sealed as they are not tile, but are slabs from a stone yard. It is $3.50 a sq ft and guaranteed for life/never needs to be resealed and anything can be used to clean the stone. We figured the expense was worth the protection. I won't be able to give feedback until late fall though ;)

Our stone vendor said that spilling something like nail polish remover would kill the tile even with q seal on it but I figure that's what the guarantee is for. Let my tile vendor deal with it if it comes to that...
User
Original Author
11 years ago
Bill - your work never fails to amaze me. Absoulutely beautiful! And I agree - marble has been around way longer than any of us and is definitely not a fad.

For some reason I haven't been able to figure out, there are many porcelain look alikes for calacutta, but none for cararra. Calacutta is too gold for my project. Do you know the manufacturer of that tile? Maybe they make a carrara look alike?

I don't see myself spilling nail polish remover in my shower :-) But, I hear what you are saying. The Q-seal stuff is intriguing though. I started looking for porcelain subways that are not marble look alikes and I think I found a winner. It's the Villery and Boch Bernina series. Will probably do a strip of decos in cararra to get my marble fix and just have to deal with keeping that sealed which hopefully won't be a big deal. May still do floor in honed marble because it was just so beautiful I can't resist. Shower is small (32x48) so sealing that shouldn't be a big deal.

Holly - I think you misunderstood. I do not want faux stone. I want real stone without the maintenance. I actually do not like faux stone at all and most of the time it looks fake to me and my even more picky husband (Bill's job above is definitely the exception!). The Q-Seal is not faux stone made with real stone. It's real stone. Any stone. And then they apply a sealer and bake it in.

nikinikinine - thanks for the info. Please come back and let us all know how it goes. Would really love to know more about this stuff and how it holds up over time. Good luck with your project!
elljays
11 years ago
Bill, can you share the name of the manufacturer of that faux calacatta tile? It really does look beautiful!
KevinMP
11 years ago
The only sealer recommended by my local marble yard for use on white marbles such as calacatta gold was SenGuard (made by Cosentino). It is a permanent sealer (i.e., 15-20 years) and is fully breathable, unlike many. Although it's the same sealer used on Silestone and Sensa granite, you can only buy it online from one dealer or from granite and marble yards that are able to purchase it directly from Cosentino (or so I'm told). It's expensive (~$200) and you only get a tiny bottle, but it covers about 150 square feet.

Water beads right up on my tile (honed calacatta gold), and I haven't had any problems. I applied the sealer myself, and there was no discoloration.
rckjansen
10 years ago
Q Seal is awesome!From what everyone is commenting on are miss informed.The chemical is not baked.It is cured by light/oxygen/nitrogen.This stuff won't mold it has antimicrobials in the chemical.You can't use plain grout.Must use Quartz Lock,Fusion Pro or similar that won't let water penetrate through the grout.Permanent marker can be wipped off with acetone/laquer thinner and comes right off and will not affect the finish.It's child safe,food safe.You can clean with bleach amonia,etc. but don't use anything abrasive ie softscrub,ajax,etc.It enhances the stone brings out it's rich beauty and the finish is a medium gloss.Recommended tiles are travertine,tumbled,honed,marble,stone nothing polished.Never have to re seal.Water based sealers requier resealing,oil based sealers you must strip before resealing.That is costly and time consuming!

Q-Seal to permanently seal stone - anyone use?

bill_vincent

Comments (8)

bill_vincent

User

Related Discussions

nikinikinine

User
Original Author

elljays

KevinMP

rckjansen

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Q-Seal to permanently seal stone - anyone use?

bill_vincent

Comments (8)

bill_vincent

User

Related Discussions

nikinikinine

UserOriginal Author

elljays

KevinMP

rckjansen

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

User
Original Author