Low profile (height) hood--baffles or mesh really superior?
julieste
10 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (27)
weissman
10 years agojulieste
10 years agoRelated Discussions
Baffles, Mesh, Both and Best
Comments (14)Mls99 - yes, the squirrel cage or "Magic Lung" that VAH uses is an alternative to both mesh or baffle. I have the VAH, and really like it. It just makes logical sense to me. There should be less noise due to less air turbulence that occurs when air goes in and out of baffles and mesh. In any case, Cfm's are all relative to your ducting - the manufacturer can cite, e.g., 900 cfm's till the cows come home, but if your ducts have a long run, a lot of turns, or are too narrow, the spec'd 900 will definitely NOT be there. Setting aside VAH, and just deciding between mesh and baffles, I'd choose baffles over mesh any day. I used to have a hood with mesh filters and it was a poor performer. The mesh got clogged easily, often with just one meal, and was just kinda gross. Also, you would never find a mesh filter hood in a restaurant kitchen due to its inefficiency. In case you haven't seen it, I am linking below the Appliances Forum FAQ on Vent Hoods. Here is a link that might be useful: Appliances Forum FAQ on Vent Hoods...See MoreVent A Hood Height
Comments (27)One comment among those above that was passed over needs some expansion. Range manufacturers can only make requirements for distances to flammable materials (typically 30 inches), so their advice to the AHJ applies to cabinets and hood surrounds. It would wisely be considered relevant to hood motors also. Hood manufacturers provide (or should provide) height requirements based on capture and containment, along with a minimum safe height for fire resistance of any exposed grease on meshes or baffles (probably where the 24 inches comes from). The meshes and baffles are supposed to provide a firestop for interior grease. Most hood materials are stainless steel (very high melting point) except aluminum meshes (not so high) and wiring (degrades at fairly low temps). So one should think about having a grease fire on the stove top and what it means for all the materials within range of the heat and flame. kas...See Morerange hoods- baffles- how superior?
Comments (21)I am in love with some of the hoods on futuro futuro's site. We went to a local appliance store to see if they had the choices I was finding online. Prefer to get it locally since that is once less installation person to find. (I am not vvery clear on who does what ) We may go with a high btu burner range. The appliance store guy categorically shot down futuro futuro and said they dont carry it because of servicability and that the only sleek model they had on the floor ' a zephyr' was no good because its coverage(hmm I think he used some other term) was not good for my kind of cooking. I do a lot of eastern cooking/wok/spicy etc., He said only hoods with some "air holding capacity" - (reads clunky to me) would be good. How accurate is this assesment ? Do I give up on getting shiny/sleek glass hood I've been looking at ? Is futuro futuro such a bad no name brand ? BTW do they have local dealers ? Thanks much ani...See Morehoods - baffles vs. centrifugal and other issues
Comments (6)Reading all the ventilation posts on this forum, (and I wouldn't suggest limiting yourself to mine) would take many hours. Selective reading may be more cost-effective. The posts may provide a sort of intuition about what makes sense and what doesn't. With respect to the questions above, here are some stream of consciousness thoughts. If possible, consider changing cabinets above the unit so a taller unit can be utilized, particularly for baffle systems. It will provide more room for baffle tilt, and will allow better uniformity of the air flow through the baffles. Using an external fan or a fan in-line with the duct will reduce the required hood height. For centrifugal fan systems, such as the VAH, the air flow is determined by the fan layout, but they cannot easily be thin and still get a fan and squirrel cage in the space. They may be non-uniform across the aperture no matter how much height is provided. Persons owning VAH systems on this forum have complained about the annoyance of cleaning the units. I don't have one so I cannot qualify just where in the annoyance range they might be placed. My guess from what I've read is that they are more annoying than standing in line for an hour, but less annoying than repairing a door lock inside an Audi door. They would seem to be more annoying than cleaning baffle or mesh hoods. For baffle systems such as my Wolf Island Pro, it is true that the baffle assemblies and the strips they drain to can be cleaned externally, such as in a dishwasher. However it is still necessary in my view to reach up in the unit and wipe the remaining sheet metal surfaces to remove any grease that has precipitated on them. This brings up another related point, working in a hood over a cooktop risks putting undue pressure on the cooktop. If the cooktop is a semi-pro gas range with cast iron to lean on, this won't be a problem, except perhaps to one's back. For potentially frangible Ceram used with coil and induction units, some care to not weight the glass too much is needed while leaning under the hood. For general perspective on ventilation, consider what is going on in the ventilation system. A pot or pan on the cooktop emits a thermal plume of effluent, mainly comprising water vapor and grease particulates. The grease particulates have a range of diameters (grease spectrum). The purpose of filtering, whether mesh, baffles (which act centrifugally), or centrifugal fan designs, is to remove the larger particles so they won't coat the ducting farther up. All these filter schemes are only partially effective, and the amount of each part of the grease spectrum that they collect varies. Spectrum efficiency information is published for many commercial filters. The particulates not filtered rise with the moving air in the duct, and depending on duct configuration, air velocity, and duct wall temperature, either are transported outside or coat the duct. Properly designed and functioning residential systems tend to have very slow build up of grease on their ducting. The moral of this story is that when generating a lot of greasy effluent, one wants to run the fan on a high enough speed to make the baffles or squirrel cage effective in centrifugal slinging, and keep the velocity of the air in the [properly sized] duct above 1000 ft/min. If the air flow at high fan speed is low due to a fan too small for the aperture area collecting the effluent, a properly designed [clean] mesh filter nay be more effective. Impingement by particles is more certain with overlapping meshes. These have to be cleaned more often than baffles, for which cleaning is an aesthetic issue rather than grease collection efficiency issue. While a too small centrifugal fan design will still sling a portion of the grease spectrum passing through it onto its collecting wall, too little air flow will likely result in the hood not containing the [initially] captured effluent, with the result that the plume enters and then curls out of the hood, or just impinges on the mesh and flows sideways without fully flowing through it. Last, I would argue that to get relatively uniform flow, the height of a hood assembly needs to be similar to its shorter aperture dimension, at least with baffles. If a mesh is used to choke the aperture, then the irregular flow of a thin height design can be evened out. However, actual flow in this case will not be very high unless a fan designed for significant pressure loss is used. kas...See Morefoodonastump
10 years agoshannonplus2
10 years agojellytoast
10 years agojulieste
10 years agoweissman
10 years agojellytoast
10 years agofoodonastump
10 years agojwvideo
10 years agojulieste
10 years agodoctheokie
10 years agodoctheokie
10 years agojulieste
10 years agojellytoast
10 years agotexasgal47
10 years agojwvideo
10 years agofoodonastump
10 years agotexasgal47
10 years agofoodonastump
10 years agotexasgal47
10 years agokaseki
10 years agojellytoast
10 years agosleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
10 years agoaussie49er
10 years agojwvideo
10 years ago
Related Stories
KITCHEN DESIGNHow to Choose the Right Hood Fan for Your Kitchen
Keep your kitchen clean and your home's air fresh by understanding all the options for ventilating via a hood fan
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNWhat to Know When Choosing a Range Hood
Find out the types of kitchen range hoods available and the options for customized units
Full StoryKITCHEN APPLIANCESWhat to Consider When Adding a Range Hood
Get to know the types, styles and why you may want to skip a hood altogether
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNShow Us Your Best Kitchen Innovation
Did you take kitchen functionality up a notch this year? We want to see your best solutions for the hardest-working room in the house
Full StoryMODERN HOMESHouzz TV: Seattle Family Almost Doubles Its Space Without Adding On
See how 2 work-from-home architects design and build an adaptable space for their family and business
Full StoryTASTEMAKERSPro Chefs Dish on Kitchens: Michael Symon Shares His Tastes
What does an Iron Chef go for in kitchen layout, appliances and lighting? Find out here
Full StoryGREAT HOME PROJECTSHow to Remodel Your Fireplace
Bring your fireplace design up to snuff with this makeover lowdown
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESTransition Time: How to Connect Tile and Hardwood Floors
Plan ahead to prevent unsightly or unsafe transitions between floor surfaces. Here's what you need to know
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Pushing Boundaries in a San Francisco Victorian
If the roll-up garage door doesn’t clue you in, the blue cabinets and oversize molding will: This kitchen is no ordinary Victorian galley
Full StoryMOST POPULARFind the Right Glass Door for Your Patio
It’s more than just a patio door — it’s an architectural design element. Here’s help for finding the right one for your home and lifestyle
Full Story
venmarfan