skip to main content

Toto Toilet Decision - Lloyd vs Eco Soiree

12 years ago

We are embarking on a bath reno and after scouring this forum had our hearts set on the Toto Soiree Toilet with the 1.6 GPF. Having searched high and low it seems there are no more Toto MS964214CFG toilets (1.6 gpf) in Cotton available in the US. The MS964214CEFG which is the Eco version of the Soiree using 1.28 GPF is widely available. There have been numerous reports of debris being left in the bowl with the Eco Soiree which is not something we are thrilled about. We are now left with the decision of whether or not to stay within the Soiree line and settle for the Eco or switch models entirely and go with something like the Lloyd and would love to hear the thoughts that other members of this forum had on the subject. Any inputs would be greatly appreciated!

Featured Answer

francoise47

12 years ago

We've installed a Toto Lloyd and a Toto Soiree in the past six months.
Both work fine; both look great.

But, I'm surprised how loud both are compared to other non Toto toilets we've had.
Is anyone else surprised/bothered at how loud the Toto toilets are when they are flushed?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

Emily
12 years ago
We ran into the same issue when we redid our powder room last summer. We were told the 1.6 gal was no longer available so we took the risk and bought the 1.28. I was too in love with the soiree's looks to go with something else.

It works great! We really don't have a debris left in the bowl problem at all. We have had it installed now for about 6 months and I can count on one hand the times we have had to double flush b/c of a debris issue.

I was also worried about clogs with the 1.28. That has been a non-issue. I did have to get the plunger out once, but I figure that's pretty good for 6 months use in our most heavily used bathroom. (our previous toilet had to use it about once a week)

The double cyclone technology does its job really well. I wouldn't hesitate to go with the 1.28. It has worked great for us!
cat_mom
12 years ago
FWIW, even the 1.6 gal Soiree will leave debris behind on occasion (definitely NOT all the time).
Related Discussions
Toto Soiree 1.25 vs. 1.6
Q
Comments (2)
I can't comment on the Soiree but we just got a Toto EcoMax which is 1.28, I believe. It replaced a low-flow toilet in my kid's bathroom. We have had it since December and my son has yet to clog it up where as the previous toilet would routinely clog every couple of weeks or so. We also love the softclose seat.
...See More
kateskouros & Others - Comments on Your Toto Lloyd Toilets?
Q
Comments (9)
Hi three_acres - I really like the looks of the Guinevere, but have been leaning toward a 1.6 gallon flush vs. the 1.28 from what I've read here. I'm in the metro DC area, and knowledgeable sales folks here say the Gmax is better than the newer Cyclone, but who really knows??!! Still haven't made a final decision, all I know for sure is that I want an elongated, skirted toilet from Toto, and not something too contemporary looking, as our house is pretty traditional. I need to find a Lloyd so I can see it in person, but it was one of the finalists when I was checking out Toto's website. And then I also saw that kateskouros got these, and I like her style. I likely will make purchases locally, with a 25% discount or so. But I've been price shopping online just to check (and maybe with a call you can get better pricing?) - but the irawoods.com website looks pretty good -- large selection and good pricing. (I have no affiliation, just found them through google and other sources.) I agree, I like the Sanagloss feature, but a lot of folks on Gardenweb have said they can't tell a huge difference (but maybe I've missed some posts on this?) -- let me know what you hear. We are hoping to start construction soon. Good luck with your project, hope it goes well! I think the look of the Lloyd will be perfect for your reno :-)
...See More
Toto Toilets - Guinevere, Soiree, Carlyle, Ultramax
Q
Comments (24)
Hi Vineyard & Pinktoes... The Soiree (mine is an elongated bowl, Sedona Beige) is right up against the bathroom wall. You cannot clean the floor behind the toilet. I just clean the top of that white floor base with a long skinny duster on a stick and wipe down the sides of the toilet. I've had mine about six months now, and not a lick of trouble out of it. Flushes each and every time. I also have a Toto tub - Model 1715. Very happy with it. In my 3/4 bath, I have a Toto UltraMax. Love it; never clogs. I went the distance with Toto products...I installed Toto faucets in both baths and tub. My plumber clued me in to Toto and, IMO, it has proven to be a superior product. Carol
...See More
Tight two-way toilet run-off: Toto vs DXV
Q
Comments (37)
Adding to this thread for anyone considering a DXV... I spent a lot of time considering plumbing fixtures for my home addition. I love the look and feel of the DXV Fitzgerald, and got the console for my powder room and undermount sink for my master, along with the matching toilets. The functionality seems great (nice flush and solid feel) however, on both toilets, the white porcelain is different colors -- the tanks are a grayish white compared to the rest. I'm still trying to work this out with Ferguson and the manufacturer... something to be aware of. When shopping for my fixtures, the Ferguson rep made the point that if you want your whites to match, go with all the same manufacturer (rather than mixing, say a Kohler toilet with a DXV sink). I did that and yet the whites are still not matching. I've had guests comment on my "two-toned toilet" -- not the look I was going for.
...See More
nycbluedevil
12 years ago
Ditto what epressler said. I too was concerned about the 1.28 but our Eco Soiree works perfectly!
maximus123
12 years ago
go with Eco Soiree .......thats the one
microbugs
12 years ago
I am so happy to see this thread! We just had to make the same decision a few weeks ago and I ordered the Soiree over the Lloyd (loved the Soiree look better). I can't say how it works yet as it is waiting to be installed...floor tile is going in today as we speak. But I am happy to see that you guys love it and don't have any issue with it. Thanks!
lolli
Original Author
12 years ago
So it is written, so it is done...Eco Soiree it is.

Thank you everyone for your inputs they have been really helpful!
dianne47
12 years ago
My Soiree (1.6gpf) is the most quiet toilet I've ever had, also very efficient and no clogs. We bought ours as a floor model from a plumbing supply store. If you really want the 1.6, try phoning around all the showrooms and supply houses in your state. You just might find one.
lee676
12 years ago
You can turn several of the Toto 1.28g commodes into 1.6g simply by replacing the 3" flapper with one made for their older "power gravity" toilets, which don't have a hole in them and thus stays open longer. They are interchangable but differenty shaped. Don't have time now to check on the part number.

Related Stories

TROPICAL STYLE My Houzz: New York Chic and Laid-Back Hawaiian Style on Maui

By Ashley Camper Photography

A relocating New Yorker designs an island home influenced by her former city life

BATHROOM DESIGN 12 Designer Tips to Make a Small Bathroom Better

By Charmean Neithart Interiors

Ensure your small bathroom is comfortable, not cramped, by using every inch wisely

BATHROOM DESIGN Room of the Day: A Family Bath With Vintage Apothecary Style

By Becky Harris

A vintage mosaic tile floor inspires a timeless room with a new layout and 1930s appeal

SAVING WATER 11 Ways to Save Water at Home

By Carol Crotta

Whether you live in a drought-stricken area or just want to help preserve a precious resource, here are things you can do to use less water

REMODELING GUIDES How People Upgrade Their Main Bathrooms, and How Much They Spend

By Erin Carlyle

The latest Houzz Bathroom Trends Study reveals the most common budgets, features and trends in master baths. Now about that tub …

LIFE The Top 5 Ways to Save Water at Home

Get on the fast track to preserving a valuable resource and saving money too with these smart, effective strategies

REMODELING GUIDES Why Marble Might Be Wrong for Your Bathroom

By By Any Design Ltd.

You love its beauty and instant high-quality appeal, but bathroom marble has its drawbacks. Here's what to know before you buy

BATHROOM DESIGN How to Choose the Right Bathroom Sink

By Anne Ellard Design

Learn the differences among eight styles of bathroom sinks, and find the perfect one for your space

SMALL HOMES Microunits Are Coming to NYC. See the Winning Design

Say goodbye to only arm-and-a-leg Manhattan rents. This plan for small prefab units opens the door to more affordable housing

Sponsored

Everingham Design

Columbus' Home Design Experts Specializing in Custom Cabinets

More Discussions

Bath remodel with walk in shower

1

black faucets in bathroom

2

Is it possible to change a color of a granite countertop

2

Bathroom exhaust vent placement

3

Renovation tub already taking a beating

1