mystery orange tomato in my garden this year

9 years ago

I have a large orange, beefsteak type tomato in my garden that I did not intend. It's really quite gorgeous! And I'd like to grow more of them on purpose next year. The plant is in a row of German Red Strawberry tomato plants and only in the last few days did any from this plant ripen enough for me to really take notice and figure out that it isn't like the others.

I knew where I purchased the German Red Strawberry seeds from, and figuring it was just a strange seed mixed in the packet i received, I looked at other tomato varieties on the seller's site and guessed it to be Dr. Wyche's Yellow. I also compared photos and descriptions from Tatiana's Tomatobase.

I've contacted the seed seller and she has told me, from looking at my pictures, that it isn't a variety she sells and she guesses it is a mutation of the German Red
Strawberry. She suggested I save seeds and try to grow out next year to see if it stays true. My problem is, I did nothing to protect from cross pollination this year and I have 4 other varieties within 10' of this one. Not sure it would do any good to save.

Wondering what you all think. Is this a known variety? If not, is it worth it to save seeds for next year. Honestly, I'd rather it be a known variety so I can buy the seeds and know that I'll get what I planned

Weight of the 3 tomatoes I've picked so far has been right around 1 lb 7 oz each. Plant looks to be regular leaf and indet. Fruit is large, somewhat lobed or ribbed, has green shoulders that went away as the fruit fully ripened. When I sliced it in half I found it to be thick and meaty with few seeds. Flavor was good, texture was smooth.

Thanks!

Barb

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

beephoto
Original Author
9 years ago
here are the 3 ripe or mostly ripe ones
beephoto
Original Author
9 years ago
Here it is, sliced. About as big as my hand.

Thanks for any insight!

Barb
Related Discussions
My mystery tomato (pics)
Q
Comments (3)
My favorite black I grew for the last 3-4 years is called JD's Early Texas Black. I could not find it ANYWHERE this year. Heard it is grown in Conroe...but nothing. I trolled stores, left my phone number... It looks like the one you have. I am SO jealous. If you would send some seeds...please email me I will send you envelope. Here are a few pics from past crop:
...See More
Can you tell what type of tomato my 'mystery plant' is
Q
Comments (13)
This is a voulnteer. I had plums, cherries and beef steaks last year..but I can't recall the names. I got them from a small nursery that did sell heirloom, along with hybrids. I remember trying to select heirloom types versus hybrid. And I rememer that the beefsteak grew pretty large, and wasn't super red when ripe. And it wasnt a perfect "round shape".. **** OK, so it's a volunteer and so any named variety we might come up with is out. Do you remember if any of the varieties you grew last year had potato leaf foliage as opposed to the more frequently seen regular foliage? Other than knowing if any of your varieties last year were PL, and without you being able to remember the names of the varieties you did grow I do think it's going to be impossible to ID what you have, not just to variety but as you asked originally, as to whether it's going to be a cherry or not. And a couple of us have said why we don't think it's a cherry and why, but I do hope you'll come back and tell us how it's developing and what it turned out to be b'c unless you grew a PL variety last year this plant is probably the result of a cross pollination and what you're growing is an F1 hybrid plant. And even that is dicey, meaning the X pollination, b'c in order to get a PL plant from random X pollination both parents would have to be heterozygous for the PL gene, ......, etc,but I'm going too far now, in trying to explain that which is really not necessary to try and explain. LOL What's important is how do you like what you eventually get from this plant. Carolyn
...See More
Here is my list of tomatoes I am growing this year 2015
Q
Comments (5)
From your list I've grown the following: Isis Candy - was nice and fruit was super sweet but prone to cracking; prefer Sun Gold Super Snow White - not much flavor though the fruit was large (2oz); prefer Dr. Carolyn's (ping pong sized white cherries) Stupice - gave me an early harvest but flavor was mushy; my fav for early is "Kimberly" Sungold - classic home run variety. I grow it every year. Thanks for highlighting those two sweet cherry varieties. They certainly sound fabulous. This year as a little experiement I'm going to compare Sungold (F1) and Sun Sugar (F1) with their supposed OP replacements: Ambrosia (OP) and Big SunSelect (OP). Here's my tomato list: smithmal
...See More
Tomatoes for next years garden
Q
Comments (6)
I tend to grow my own plants from seed. I used to buy the plants but one year I was elated to find Golden Jubilee plants for sale (Home Depot). To my dismay they turned out to be all paste tomatoes after I went thru the work of growing them. Now I save my own seed from select heirlooms I tried from Sand Hill Preservation in Iowa. One variety I got from that source produces nicely each year and somehow it escapes the plague of early blight even though I never spray for it. A real winner! I cannot remember the name of the tomato however. I did learn the hard way to always save at least two years worth of seed. Years ago I got a wonderful Italian oxheart tomato from an Italian immigrant who grew them for his restaurant. Sweet, thin skinned and just very flavorful. Somehow the seed I had saved off one crop got tossed out and by the time I realized it, it was too late to get more as the crop was done growing for the season. I lost that variety after having it for many years. Now I always save two years worth of seed so I have a backup in case of some disaster.
...See More
carolyn137
9 years ago
Barb, you know from looking at Tania's site, below, that I was the one who introduced GRS so know it well.

The hearts it can give can be blunt or somewhat acute, but can be Ided as hearts, which I don't see in the pictures your show.

I also don't think it's a mutation of GRS. Yes, a variety that is red can mutate to yellow, but it's due to what's called a somatic mutation, that is a mutation of DNA in a plant cell, not in the DNA of a seed, and such somatic mutations can lead to one branch having the different color, or shape or size, or even one fruit being different.

Yellow Riesentraube resulted from ONE fruit on a plant of normal reds appearing.

Marjorie Morris, who sent me GRS also sent me seeds for what she called Orange Strawberry which was a stray seed in a pack of the variety Pineapple.

And I think what you have is a stray seed and could it be Dr Wyche, which I also know well. I have no idea since there are many many varieties that look like what you have.

If it's astray seed then you should be able to ID it from what that seed seller grows, even though she says otherwise.Knowing many seed vendors, they don't always list for sale what they have and having done many seed offers myself, I'm not commercial, I know that stray seeds can, well, just appear. LOL

But I'm quite confident it isn't a mutation of German Red Strawberry.Most seed sellers don't like it when stray seeds appear, why not, but for several years I did a wrong varieties thread here at GW, and they certainly do appear, more so from traded seeds but also from purchased seeds.

Summary? Call it a mystery one and if you like it continue to grow it, but it will just have to be another orphan, as I see it. (smile)

Carolyn

Here is a link that might be useful: German Red Strawberry
Carla1
9 years ago
Those tomatoes look delicious! If I were you, I'd save some seeds for next season.
deadhead61
9 years ago
Nice tomato.I've grown DrWyche's for the last three years,love them,big and meaty.If you'd like some seeds,I have plenty.
lee_71
9 years ago
I'd lean toward the stray seed theory as well.
If you like, go ahead and save seed and regrow next year.
Also, unless you have bees buzzing around your tomato plants, your chance of cross pollination is 0, no matter how close adjacent plants are.

Good luck!

Lee
beephoto
Original Author
9 years ago
Thank you everyone! I think I will save the seeds and give it a whirl next year.

Barb

mystery orange tomato in my garden this year

Comments (7)

beephoto
Original Author

beephoto
Original Author

Related Discussions

carolyn137

Carla1

deadhead61

lee_71

beephoto
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

mystery orange tomato in my garden this year

Comments (7)

beephotoOriginal Author

beephotoOriginal Author

Related Discussions

carolyn137

Carla1

deadhead61

lee_71

beephotoOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

beephoto
Original Author

beephoto
Original Author

beephoto
Original Author