Should I steer clear of these "fast-growing" shade trees?

9 years ago

I just planted the following fast-growing shade trees in my front and back yards: Royal Empress (Paulownia elongata), Hybrid Poplar (Populus), and Eucalyptus (Eucalyptus cinerea)

After discovering that the Eucalyptus tree is prone to breaking and has shallow roots, I decided it would probably be best to go with a different tree. Upon doing research on the other two trees, I found that the hybrid poplar (or any tree of the Populus variety) is not recommended. I was't able to find any downsides to the Royal Empress.

I live in Northern Utah, right along the bench. Any advice offered will be considered. Thanks!

Featured Answer

jim_ogden_utah

9 years ago

I'm growing eucalyptus gunnii and eucalyptus parvula here in Ogden. I intend to cut them down to about 7' for the first 2 or 3 winters and protect them until the trunks get a bit thicker. I don't want them to freeze dry in a winter wind.

Before I lived here I planted a eucalyptus glauscesens and neglecta at my parents place and they survived unprotected for a few years although they would lose many of there leaves and die back a bit in winter. Unfortunately someone well meaning but ignorant took them out one spring when they were looking a bit bare.

As for paulownia, they can be very messy and I wouldn't plant it unless you have a huge yard, unless you want to keep it small. If you top it off at 12' or so every year or two it will grow very different. It won't bloom but the leaves will grow about 2' in diameter.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

jonathanpassey
9 years ago
I am no help with anything but vegetables. Sorry.

I am glad people are using the Utah forum though. Welcome!

You might have to try one of the other forums here on garden web, if you cant find an answer here. This has been an incredibly useful site for me to get answers and help.

Good Luck!

JP
groem
9 years ago
Generaly fast growing trees are going to be weaker than the slower growing trees. What some people do is plant both fast and slow growing trees. The fast trees give shade sooner. Then as the slower stronger trees catch up and provide shade, the faster weak trees are removed before they become a hazard.

So you could leave them in for now with the plan to remove them at some point, and plant your prefered better suited trees.
Related Discussions
Shade tree suggestion - preferably fast growing
Q
Comments (5)
Bur oak is native to your area and an excellent shade tree. It grows at a reasonable pace, particularly when it's young and will give you shade in a reasonable period of time. You might also want to consider some of the native maples. Do NOT plant norway maple. I also advise against our native silver maple in home landscapes -- it's just too big and ungainly for that setting. That being said, red or sugar maple are nice choices and I wouldn't even be opposed to the red/silver hybrids. Sycamore is also nice and fairly fast growing. I would recommend ash, but the emerald ash borer problem really prevents that these days. Hackberry would be a good choice, however, as would Kentucky coffeetree or perhaps even one of the Dutch elm disease resistent elm cultivars.
...See More
Fast-Growing Shade Trees (Zone 5, Chicagoland area)
Q
Comments (8)
"Unfortunately the last batch of storms gave my monster 100+ year-old pin oak tree a beating, causing it to lean unsafely towards my neighbor's house." Are such windstorms fairly common? I'm think if you often get winds strong enough to hammer a big oak, then you should NOT get a weak wooded tree (e.g.: true Poplars like Cottonwood, or a Silver Maple). In fact, another oak of some sort (likely the red oak group) might be a good balance between size, growth rate and strength of wood. Pin oak are famous for sending limbs down too low for yards. I wonder how a Shumard oak would do in your area? Are acorns unacceptable to you? Richard.
...See More
What kind of fast-growing shade tree should I plant?
Q
Comments (7)
If you want a weeping willow, I would recommend the golden weeping willow. I am sorry, but I am confused about the names of some of the weeping willows. I have seen golden weeping willows called Salix alba "tristis" or Salix albs ""Niobe," and "Salix sepulcralis chrysocoma." I am sure I have seen one or two other names for it. One source suggests there are more than one cultivar involved, another says it is just name confusion--I don't know. But don't let the confusion about the names of this tree confuse you. The one I am recommending has golden color winter twigs, golden color catkin bloom in spring, and if the weather is half-way favorable, wonderful long-lasting gold leaf color in the fall. It is very fast growing and gets quite large. The popular Babylon weeping willow can have some bad dieback in Z6 or 7 during a cold winter. It has greenish twigs. In the south where it is not damaged by cold, it is a fine tree. As for soil and moisture--if you have a good soil that is not too sandy, your willow will do fine. I planted two from a cuttings 5 years ago out in a field that used to be an apple orchard--nothing about the site suggests that it is any more moist than any average site. The largest is now about 20 feet tall and 5" in diameter--the other is almost as large. If you have a willow growing that you really like that has golden twigs and can get some good strong cuttings from fairly high up, come back here and ask me for instructions. --Spruce
...See More
Fast growing hybrid poplars shade trees for garden design
Q
Comments (13)
My Mom's front yard has a center walk to the front door. The previous owners planted 2 red oaks and 2 Arizona Ash, a local trash tree, one of each on each side. The ash were toward the street. When they bought the house, they removed the ash trees. Within two years, the oaks had filled in where the ash had been and were round like they should be. It gets so hot here that shade is very important to livability. I thought it was a great solution to adding shade quickly and then also planning for the future. bk
...See More
arctictropical
9 years ago
I would recommend staying away from fast growing trees. Especially what I consider to be weed trees... most varieties of willow trees, box elder, poplar. One fairly quick growing shade tree that I would highly recommend in any soil type is green ash.
User
9 years ago
The faster trees grow, the shorter their lifespan and weaker they are (at least regarding broadleaf trees....- conifers are a law unto themselves)...but, I do have to wonder why you wanted 3 of them. The hybrid poplars (and, as I garden in a poplar plantation, I know of what I speak) have very little charm to be honest - the timber is weak and without much intrinsic interest, the canopy is negligible (so useless as a shade tree), they have no autumn colouring, take ages to leaf up and are already bare. They sucker.
Eucalypts....I have rarely seen a well-grown gum without severe leaning issues.....so unless you have added in the extra space a 45degree angle will add (Like a gigantic apple cordon....without the benefits), take it out....
Paulownias....are you growing for biomass? I can see few advantages to growing this monster....but will agree that whilst it has few pluses, it certainly does not have the screaming negatives of the former pair of yahoos. I am biassed against this tree since my dimwit neighbour has planted one in her garden....which is 5metres wide, right next door to my 5m wide home garden...it is only 3 years old and is taking half of her alloted space....the chainsaw will be out the second it overgrows my wall).
I don't really hang out here ever so feel free to be blunt and truthful....why, with a hundred better, nicer, more useful and appropriate trees to select, would you go for a couple of thugs. Even the rampant poplar will hang around for 80 years...so these charmless blights are going to be there, huge and visible for a lifetime. Unless the speed of their growing is your only criteria (in which case, top choices), I cannot imagine why you would impose such dullards on your landscape.
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
9 years ago
I can't imagine any of the eucalypts being very successful for you as any sort of a shade tree. Even the very hardy species - E. gunnii, cinerea, etc - are frequently knocked down to the roots in the odd winter around here. They survive, but mostly as shrubby specimens. Very unusual to see a full sized tree even in my very mild climate.

Why not a nice red maple? Or Freeman or Shantung maple? Growth rate is moderate, will get to a decent size and will provide some fall color as well. Or Liriodendron tulipifera, which grows quite rapidly in suitable soils.
jim_ogden_utah
9 years ago
I should have added, if you are growing eucs here please be forewarned that you are seriously pushing the envelope. If you realize there is a strong possibility they will completely die without protection and that doesn't bother you than I say go for it.

Personally I love pushing the envelope. I do it here and I did it in western Washington. Sometimes it's complete failure. Sometimes it's rousing and surprising success. Sometimes you just get to enjoy a unique plant for the area for a few years before it succumbs.

You'll have to listen to the occasional self-appointed world plant cop though who wants to tell everyone what they should or shouldn't plant. I don't give those types a second thought. It's my yard and as long as I'm not planting anything invasive then it's none of their concern.

Should I steer clear of these "fast-growing" shade trees?

jim_ogden_utah

Comments (7)

jonathanpassey

groem

Related Discussions

arctictropical

User

gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)

jim_ogden_utah

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US