Thinning fruit on a small mango tree

11 years ago

I have a mango tree (Nam Doc Mai #4) that's very young and has set a lot of small fruit (probably close to 100). I bought it last spring and planted it in the ground. Early this spring, I decided that I had chosen the spot poorly and dug up the tree and potted it. It then flowered and set a ton of fruit, obviously way more than it will carry. It's only about a 3' tall tree. It has about a 1.5" diameter trunk, with four scaffold branches where it was pugged.

I've read that mangoes will self-thin by dropping fruits they can't carry, but I'm wondering if it would be beneficial for me to thin some of the fruit early, since there's so many. Should I thin to 1 mango per branch (this would mean about 10, which I'm guessing is still too much), or 1 per scaffold (4), or maybe just a couple total? Should I just leave it alone and see which fruit drop on their own? I'm pretty new to this.

Thanks!

Featured Answer

gnappi

11 years ago

I have 5 mango trees, three of them fruiting. One I pugged severely, the other gave me crummy fruit and I'm probably going to pull it next season if they are not better.

Anyway... My experience with mango is that they do drop all the fruit they cannot support, BUT allowing this they suffer a growth cycle too. In January I bought a little Pickering in a container and it had blooms all over it, I let it drop everything it didn't want. Two came to edible size.

I am glad I did this. because I don't want a tree in the ground for three or more years only to find out that I'm not crazy (see above) about the fruit. Now that I know that I like it, I'll put it in the ground and wait. Maybe it will have several growth flushes this coming year, and next year it may hold more fruit.

Gary

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (15)

BestDay23
11 years ago
I'm pretty new to this also but that sounds like a small tree to carry any fruit. We'll have to wait and see what the more experienced people say.

Bill
Related Discussions
New to apple trees: fruit thinning, bugs
Q
Comments (2)
Most often the fruit will thin itself down to what the tree can handle. It probably won't do it for the best sized or tasting fruit but most varieties will readily thin. It's known as June Drop. Some varieties would rather overbear which leads to biennial fruiting. I can't tell on the beetle. It looks like one of the curculio I get except I can't see a snout. I can't tell if it doesn't have one or I just can see it in the picture. If it has an elephant snout it's curculio.
...See More
Do all fruit trees need to be thinned?
Q
Comments (28)
estreya, In my experience those smaller yellower plumlets in your first picture will fall off by themselves whether you want them or not. You can see that event their stems are thinner and yellower than the larger green plumlets. Congratulations. My plums seem to be off to their best start in the last 3 or 4 years. My apples are very sparse. It may be something with our weather, or you and I may be on the same biennial cycle. I have the same quince as Larry and that thing is the most precocious fruit tree I've ever seen. Geez, its less that 4 feet tall and must have had at least 100 flowers that all wanted to set. I pulled off all but maybe 10 near the trunk and may get the rest too. Apparently if you want to improve the biennial bearing of pommes by thinning you need to get them VERY early, well before the fruit are big enough to tell which are the good ones.
...See More
Anyone growing mango trees or avocado trees(that produce fruit)
Q
Comments (7)
I won't claim to be an expert but I do have some experience with avocado trees. I do know you need 2 avocado trees to pollinate the blooms to produce fruit. I started my trees from seed in the early spring of 2009, so they've been through 2 seasons of growth. They are about 3-4 feet high, have multiple branches, and this is the first year they are expected to bloom. I've noticed a few budding blooms on both trees already and I hope they produce fruit. They will not survive outside during the winter so make sure they have a sunny window to hang out by during the cold months. Avocado trees are a tropical tree so don't overwater, and you might have to provide shelter if there are too many days of rain. Good luck and I'll post in a few months if there are any fruit.
...See More
Which 3 small mango trees to choose?
Q
Comments (30)
@mango_kush yes we have problems with fruit flies here also, but they don't attack the Ruby Supreme guava. They do attack other guava varieties with a strong guava smell. I have even picked rotten guavas off the ground and inspected them for maggots and found none just sugar ants. The soursop has been that height for over 3 years now. When it reaches the height of the house the cold weather kills that wood. All I ever do is trim any dead wood when it goes dormant. This soursop is a Filipino variety. I planted it about 2 feet from the house on purpose so that it could survive the cold weather since its extremely sensitive to cold temperatures. @pulglvr1 you can try contacting the company that makes the product using the link below. When I first saw the product I knew that it was perfect for protecting plants and this past winter definitely proved that to me. Be aware that just covering your plants using this product alone may not enough. You must also provide a sustainable heat source such as a light bulb of sufficient wattage. I did lay this bubble blanket along the ground to the window sill on the west side of the house to protect sugar apple and pineapple plants. From the picture you can see that all the plants below the bubble wrap survived without any damage even though I did not use a heat source. The bubble blanket was able to trap the heat from the ground and the cinder blocks to keep the plants alive. If you look closely you can see that 3 of the pineapple plants have fruited. In front of the wood fence at the far end of the house are the rolls of the bubble wrap ready for duty this coming winter. Here is a link that might be useful: Astro Cooler
...See More
julia42
Original Author
11 years ago
Well, I went ahead and thinned the fruit yesterday. I just figured it would save the tree some energy. I thinned to the 2 largest fruit per branch, and then I'll thin further once they've grown a little more and I can pick better. I'd really like to let it set at least 1 or 2 fruit.
mangodog
11 years ago
Julia - where do you live? If you are in SoCal or some place without the long growing season of say, Florida, I would advise to take them all off, as it sounds like it is a grafted tree. I just did with most of mine because this developing of fruit takes ALL the energy of the tree until they are picked.

That is, unless you are like gnappi and want to taste a fruit or two before you decide if you want to keep it. I just know with my Keitt last year, I let 3 fruit stay on it and it had a total of 4 inches of growth last year AFTER i picked the last one. This year, they've all been recently picked off and I wish I had done it 6 weeks ago when they were forming....

I've been told that a grafted tree THINKS it is a much older tree because it came from another,more mature tree, and thus will think it's OK to fruit....

That's my opinion anyway. We jsut don't have the 12 month growing season that Florida has - more like around 8 months or so, with much overall colder winter temps to also delay the onset of growth....

MangoWoof
puglvr1
11 years ago
Gnappi, which mango variety gave you crummy fruit...out of curiousity?

Hi Julia, Mangodog is right...its best to let the tree concentrate and put all its energy to growth. I can't believe your 3ft. NDM's has around 100 baby mangoes, that's amazing! Having said that I can't blame you for wanting to taste at least 1 or 2) fruits and we certainly won't hold it against you,lol...We've all been in the same boat. Good luck!
mangodog
11 years ago
boy....we sure have!

mangodog
gnappi
11 years ago
"Gnappi, which mango variety gave you crummy fruit...out of curiousity? "

I don't know, it was here when I got here hidden in a pair of "binary avocado" trees' foliage. Jeff tasted it and we looked for a graft line and found none so it looks like it was grown from seed.

It has been opined that it was a "turpentine" mango but for the life of me I have no idea where the previous owner would get one.

IMO, the answer is to buy grafted trees, but if you do grow one, use it as root stock or work the top to different cultivars.
gnappi
11 years ago
I wrote above: "Maybe it will have several growth flushes this coming year, and next year it may hold more fruit"

Well new news, I cut the tips off of all the branches and all are now erupting new growth! YAY!!!
puglvr1
11 years ago
Congrats Gnappi!! Tipping mango trees works really well for me also.

I tipped this Glenn tree June 4 2011

Here is it 3 weeks later...June 25 2011
charleslou23
11 years ago
puglvr, by tipping, you're basically trim or prune the top branches?
tropicbreezent
11 years ago
Grafted trees are basically the same tree as the one the graft came off. If you remember the cloned sheep "Dolly" of a number of years back. Although it started off going through the lamb stages it died early because genetically it was the same age as the one if was cloned off. In the same way, a graft is a clone of the original tree, biologically having the same age. That's why they fruit virtually straight away.

Another point, Nam Dok Mai is a cooking mango and I don't think it's much good eaten as fresh fruit anyway. So it would be best to take off all the undeveloped fruit to give the root stock a chance to grow to a decent size to be able to support a lot of fruit. Leaving the fruit to fall off itself means the tree gets stressed to the point where a survival mechanism kicks in. (Mind you, stressing trees to produce fruit is another whole new topic.)

Tip pruning is usually done during harvest when the fruit stems are cut back into the supporting branch. Although, on a commercial scale it's done with 'helicopter-type' blades afterwards which trims and shapes the whole tree. But you also need to thin out some of the branches to allow more sun and air into the centre of the tree. This reduces fungus problems and produces better fruit.
charleslou23
11 years ago
cooking mango? None of online nursery websites describe NDM as a cooking mango, more so a dessert mango...
tropicbreezent
11 years ago
Charleslou23, I replied on the other thread. They are often referred to as "Nam Doc Mai or Cooking Mangos".
puglvr1
11 years ago
Charles, sorry for the late reply. YES, tipping is basically
light pruning. Just nipping a few inches off the "tips" off...

Pruning is a little more in length...longer branches are cut.
gp02
7 years ago
The Nam Doc Mai from Thailand is easily one of the best eating mangoes in the world. They outsell all others in the Thai markets and are great when green in salads or when ripe to simply eat. We have four trees in Miami and the neighbors love them. Whoever called them "cooking mangoes" must have never tried eating them.

Thinning fruit on a small mango tree

gnappi

Comments (15)

BestDay23

Related Discussions

julia42
Original Author

mangodog

puglvr1

mangodog

gnappi

gnappi

puglvr1

charleslou23

tropicbreezent

charleslou23

tropicbreezent

puglvr1

gp02

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Thinning fruit on a small mango tree

Comments (15)

Related Discussions

julia42Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

julia42
Original Author