Is oakleaf a bad idea?

14 years ago

Hi all...I'd love to plant an oakleaf hydrangea and would like your opinions if you think it will work or if I should choose something other than a hydrangea. Here are the details...

- zone 5a (central Indiana)

- fairly protected site; planting location would be on the north side of my house in a corner created by the house and a 6' wood fence. The south side of neighbor's house is approx. 16'ish feet away.

- I believe it will be entirely shaded all day from the shadow of the house. As it grows (assuming it grows!) it may eventually extend past the shade then may get some afternoon sun

- Soil is hard Indiana clay but I can amend if necessary

- Moisture is probably more on the dry side if I had to choose, but I have hose

- Should be plenty of space for it to fill in the entire corner (up to approx. 8' in diameter, then will have to prune if it gets bigger)

I'd love to plant this but I'm a little worried about my zone as I think zone 5a is marginal. If this shrub is not ideal, any suggestions out there? Also, I'm not too familiar with the different oakleaf varieties so perhaps one would work better than another.

Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

whaas_5a
14 years ago
There are plenty of other shrubs you could plant but if you really like the Oakleaf Hydrangea than go for it. As you mentioned above, they need a protected site for zone 5.

The only thing you can't really count on is the flowers. It you have a harsh winter I believe the flower buds die off below -15 degrees.

Also count on slow growth in your clay soil.
phyl345
14 years ago
i am in the northern suburbs of chgo. ~~ i have two oakleaf shrubs planted next to the northern wall of our house (no sun)

i also have two planted at the same time (two yrs. ago) on the east side (several hrs. of sun)

all four look absolutely wonderful!

from my reading & asking questions at the nursery i came away with this:

i improved my soil with: composted manure, spanghum peat moss & pinebark fines ~~ then planted them so that they would be elevated ~~ they are very finicky about having their feet wet; and, IF i understand everything i've been told, if they don't make it thru our brutal winters, it is actually NOT the brutal winters ~ but our wet & soggy springs ~ excellent drainage is key to their survival ~

hope i said that in a way that is understandable???

good luck, phyl

p.s. the chicago botanical gardens are very helpful 1-847-835-5440
Related Discussions
Modifying an online plan from vendor? Good idea? Bad idea?
Q
Comments (10)
Okay, it sounds as if you just want a house with a front elevation that looks very similar to the Southern Living plan but which would have the interior rearranged so significantly that it would be an entirely new plan. If so, your local architect would only be using the image of the Southern Living plan as "inspiration" for the front elevation and would probably not be infringing copyright - unless he made the front of the house look identical to the SL plan. So maybe you don't really need to purchase a license to the SL plan after all. But it sounds as if your local architect doesn't "get it" even after seeing your inspiration picture. Perhaps you need a different architect. Or is is possible that the room arrangement you want simply won't fit into a farmhouse with a tall narrow front elevation (which is a good part of the charm of the SL plan). If you want a house that is tooooooo big, or you want too many rooms facing either the front or the back views, then your architect probably keeps winding up with something that is broader than it is tall... and therefore cannot possibly be made to look like the elevation you picture. I had a friend who once insisted that she wanted a nice compact basically rectangular one-story "cottage." But then she started describing all the rooms that just had to have a view of the lake on one side of her property and it quickly became obvious to me that there was no possible way to meet her desires. Her vision of the interior was just incompatible with her vision of the exterior. Ultimately she wound up building a long thin boom-a-rang shaped home that was mostly one room deep. It looked nothing at all like the "little cottage" she originally THOUGHT she wanted but every major room in the house has a view of that lake and it is a gorgeous home. If your interior floor plan vision isn't totally incompatible with your exterior inspiration picture, there is probably already a farmhouse design out there somewhere that comes close to meeting your needs and, when finished would look similar to the SL plan. Why don't you post your "program" (how many bedrooms? baths? garage bays? master upstairs or down? laundry upstairs or down? open plan kitchen/great room or not? office? media room? playroom?) here on GW? Maybe someone here will know of a perfect or near perfect plan that could be modified more easily than the SL plan. I know that finding the perfect plan is very difficult and when you hire an architect and he doesn't seem to be able to "get it", it can be extremely frustrating. BTDT, so you have my sincere sympathy.
...See More
24" sink cabinet - Good idea? Bad idea?
Q
Comments (24)
Lots of useful points here, thanks. After doing some measuring, we would up tentatively deciding that we'll put in a 36" sink cabinet. We'd have so little room in a 24" cab around a garbage disposal (assuming same model we have now, and assuming the drain is in the center) that we'd be hard pressed to store trash under the sink. So with a 24" cabinet, we'd probably wind up losing 15" somewhere else to making a dedicated trash pull out. Thus it's actually efficient to just go to the 36" sink base. (The 30" doesn't work as well as 24 and 36 sizes, for various reasons involving window placement and ikea sizing.) If we stay with this decision, it seems we'll have a lot of latitude in selecting a sink size / configuration. I'll almost certainly go ahead and move to a larger sink - the question will be whether to maximize the potential of the large cabinet or keep the sink scaled to down a bit since the kitchen is smallish and the window in front of which the sink will be set is just 30". With the current cabinet choices open to me, my main work areas in the kitchen will be 33" to the right of the sink cabinet base, and 54-61" on the left of it. Plus however much smaller the sink opening is than the 36" span of the base cabinet. A little more prep space is always a good thing, but so is making dirty mixing bowls disappear.
...See More
Double owners' suits: good idea/bad idea?
Q
Comments (20)
Well sure, nobody can predict the future. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't try! Our first home was intended to be short term. It was in an area with questionable schools, but we didn't have kids yet. Our plan was to be there 5-10 years and move before we had a kid in kindergarten. We were there seven years and moved when our eldest was four. Our second/current home was intended to last us "until the kids were in college" but we lacked the foresight to know we'd LOSE OUR EVER-LOVIN' MINDS and decide to have two more kids. And we realized when our dog developed a disability that it's extremely unfriendly to the mobility-impaired. (Plus side: she weighed 100 lbs so we got a LOT of exercise the last year of her life. :/) So we're moving forward and applying what we've learned over the years towards our best guess is about what will work for us. What more can you do? Important to note: I've come to love this plan (which isn't very bright, not yet knowing if the BRs will fit upstairs yet, but what can you do?) The only reason I wanted a first floor master was for eventual mobility issues (3/4 of our parents have health problems which make stairs difficult), not because I want my bedroom on the main floor now. The major drawback to the rough sketch we started with http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/4345095/floorplan-feedback-very-early-stage is a lack of playroom space on the main level which means, IME, all the toys will end up in the living room. A main level master would make an excellent playroom/craft room. It's close enough to the action that it would actually get used, plus there's a door. At this point the biggest drawback I see is the possibility that both we and an elderly parent might need to avoid stairs in which case either a small guest room on the main or planning for a future elevator might be a good idea. (Could whoever has the crystal ball please pass it my way?)
...See More
Glass Greenhouse; Good Idea or Bad Idea?
Q
Comments (8)
Yes, you can build a nice little working greenhouse from old windows. We did a 10x16 one about 15 years ago and I am still using it. Here it is in it's original configeration...All windows were wood framed salvage material. We cleaned them up, removed all old hardware. The roof windows are old double glazed, french doors. They were tempered glass. The side windows were old single glaze, storm windows. The north side did not have many windows and all solid walls were insulated. There is an automatic roof vent and a small exhaust fan on a thermostat. It is wired for electricity but I use a 50 gallon barrel filled from a hose as my water supply. I used to keep it modestly heated in the winter and covered it with a clear solar pool cover for those months.Because most of the windows were already 100 years old and the french doors were never meant to be roofing material, after a dozen years there began to be some rot. We did a major renovation of the south side roof and front wall. I found 2 used commercial skylights for $25 and bought some used modern vinyl windows from a salvage yard...a couple of them open and have screens. The building is still very useful as a greenhouse and also retains heat better now.
...See More
tina_2
14 years ago
Hi - I fell in love, when I first saw one
....hope to get another someday.....
All, I know is once planted - they hate to be moved.
That is how I lost mine. They are exquisite in my
opinion!!! Good Luck. tina_2
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
14 years ago
Interesting. I don't find them any more difficult or resistant to transplanting than any other type of hydrangea. Perhaps it was the timing or damage to the root system that caused the problem.

FWIW, if I was limited to only one hydrangea in my garden (heaven forbid!!), it would be an oakleaf without question. However, I do not live a similarly cold zone so have no firsthand experience on how well they do in zone 5.
mxk3 z5b_MI
14 years ago
I'm in zone 5b/6, and my oakleafs perform beautifully. They are planted in a shady area on the south side of the house, so are protected from the winds from the north in the winter, though they do catch some wind from the west. It was not easy to get them established in this particular spot, and I had a fair amount of die-back the first two seasons, even though I protected them with burlap screens. I'm not sure if it was because of the not-so-great soil (which has improved quite a bit over the years) or because they are "tricky" to get established here (that's what I've heard, but not sure if that's actually true, though).

In any case, I no longer protect them and don't have to water them as much, and they are gorgeous, just gorgeous! They suffer very little die-back now, but they are now mature/established. I have noticed that the two bushes that catch more sun out of the five in that grouping do produce more flowers and have better fall coloring - a beautiful rich red (the other three in less sun turn an "eh" deeper burgundy color) and are a little lusher in terms of foliage.

Even if they never threw a flower, I would still grow them for the outstanding foliage effect. :0)

I recently purchased a couple Pee Wee dwarf oakleafs, and I plan on protecting them over winter because they are right next to the driveway, and I'm afraid the snow throwing will crack the branches - mature oakleaf branches are rather brittle and can break easily, just bumping into a branch the wrong way sometimes causes a branch to snap, so dumping snow on them will more than likely wreck them (not because of me, but because DH pays no attention to much of anything let alone aiming the output of the blower away from the bushes....)
ditas
14 years ago
Hi mxk3 - How old are the ones you don't have to protect? My Alice is now a good size (4' all around & tall/3rd season). Snow Queen & Pee Wee were planted May'08 ... none bloomed this '09 due to decimating Winter & upside-down Spring but OK, as they are all thriving & beautiful!!! Â;) I posted pics of all 3 in your coloration ? post.

Last Winter all were protected w/ a chicken-wire surround, dumped w/ leaf mulch ... observed only a few old canes that suffered. Alice has out-grown her wire fence ... am wondering if she can now be left, to fend for herself? I still intend to provide a tent for still smallish SQ & PW (located in N-foundation bed, a corridor of the NW wicked winds). PW has sprawled wider now has out-grown his wire cage, as well. I might just drive some stakes, dump some leaves & top w/ burlap. A local nursery said ... just mulch heavily at the base. You're a bit warmer than where I am ... what do you think?
TIA mxk3

Gardengal148 - I'm with you, if OL Hs can have all the character traits of Paniculatas!!! I guess we can't *have our cake & eat it too* huh?! LOL *No pains no gains* doesn't always work either ... only patience ... Ma Nature controls, even in right growing zones!
mxk3 z5b_MI
14 years ago
Ditas: Regarding the ones I don't protect, most of them are at least 7 years old, and one is 4 years old, I believe.
goodhors
14 years ago
I would agree that getting the Oakleafs going is a slow process. I have one Dwarf type, was tagless so no name. The Nursery guy said it was a dwarf, should only get up about 5-6 ft tall and wide. I did a cage around it, covered wire with old, clear shower curtain to break the wind for a couple winters. I piled lots of shredded real oak leaves around the base for mulch. My ground is a bit dry there, so watered regular if we got no rain. It is on the NW side of house, exposed to the west wind all winter.

Blooming was a bit erratic the first couple years, the buds may have gotten wind dried or frozen, not sure. Usually had some bloom, but might only be one that year.

About the 4th year, it seemed to suddenly take off, with new sprouts, gaining height and fullness. I quit doing anything special for protection then, just keep it mulched well each fall and spring with the oak leaves.

Early blooming is very pretty, and usually a nice effort. Cold and wind don't seem to bother it anymore. Did real well this spring, even with the long, cold winter of 08-09.

Not always a tremendous flowering, but nicely covered with good size panicles, which I can accept because it is in the shade until about 3P. I really like the foliage, leaves are so attractive among smaller leaved shrubs beside it. Fall color of bright red is tremendous, even if weather is warm or cold. Still has most of his red leaves right now. It was my first Hydrangea. Well worth the little extra time and work to get it going here.
ditas
14 years ago
Thank you very much for the responses to my ??? mxk3 & goohors!!! Â;) ... I went ahead & got another roll of those plasti-coated garden wire fencing as several of my real Garden Divas & minor Divas have grown & despite bundling, past season's cages got a bit too confining.

Goodhors - I think a couple of years ago I got the idea from your post on, how you wind-protected your beautiful Oakleaf H ... BTW wasn't it finally ID'd as Vaughn's Lily?

Any way I followed your lead & wrapped Ol H-Alice's wire cage w/ an insulating plastic sheet & dumped leaf-mulch to the top ... might just proceed with the same for younger SQ & PW this Winter ... now that this is their 2nd Winter.

November gave us a better than average warmer days(upper40s-60s) ... had to do incremental layering of their Winter protection ... the nurseries here, are in agreement, as far as when to finally finish up ... *wait for the few days of hard freeze* ... after T'g Day as a rule of thumb in our zone. 9 out of my 12 Divas were done last week I'll just wrap cages w/ landscaping fab as windbreakers ... gets a bit hectic & crazy w/ all the holiday to-dos!!!

Thanks again very much for tips & reassurances ... Happy Holidays ahead!!! Â;)

Is oakleaf a bad idea?

Comments (9)

whaas_5a

phyl345

Related Discussions

tina_2

gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)

mxk3 z5b_MI

ditas

mxk3 z5b_MI

goodhors

ditas

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US