what did google tell you???

is it even possible...???? or i should say.. are the odds of success probable??? .. i am sure one in a million will root.. so it would be possible ...

ken

ps: it should have stayed in the bag for months ... a mini greenhouse.. to maintain tissue moisture .. until it may have rooted ...

I actually cut it first, and once I was home I googled the information. if you search "root ash tree cuttings" there are many sites that make it sound so easy, but im guessing I made some mistakes along the way bc it's of course not rooted yet.

The bag for 1, I was worried that mold could cause the plant damage oops. Do you think it's too late to replace it & have success later with more humidity?

Since the cutting is so long, and thankfully still green in color. . . should I remove an inch or so off the bottom to start a fresh cut?

I'm wondering would roots grow from the bottom, like the end of a flower, or would it root from one of those brown knobs that are burried beneath the soil? Should any of the brown knobs be broken off to stimulate growth?

Dirr's Propagation Book shows no Ash species propagated from cuttings rather shows all propgation of clonal trees via grafting; otherwise ash are grown from seed which will produce different offspring than clonal propagation.

As Ken suggested the odds of rooting an Ash are going to be in the 1:1000 or 1:10000 categories or possibly in the millions.

If you want a vegetative clone, it's going to have to be grafted.

Dax

@gardener365 Thanks Dax. I'm not really set that it has to look like the parent plant, not a big deal. Im more experimenting with growing fun trees for my patio or front door area. Although the leaves that were present looked identical to the mother, if that makes any difference. They fell off a few days after the piece was cut though.

I googled "propogate ash tree" and heres one article I remember reading at the start. Theres many others. How do these folks succeed, is it a green thumb & good patience? *bah* it seems like my plant projects dont turn out that great.

Here is a link that might be useful: DoItYourself.com - 3 Ways to Propogate Ash Tree

@gardener365 I'm understanding a lot better now how a piece could be properly cut. The tree is not close by, and that was the only growth (or sucker possibly?) its well maintained. It was a spur of the moment adventure thats winding down now : )

I will cut the bottom, replace the bag, and leave it in the same spot & keep the soil moist. It's not really in my way, so I guess it wouldn't hurt. I'll post if it develops any roots.

Why will you cut the bottom? I doubt it will root anyway but if you cut off the bottom it will have to start all over again. Ash grows easily from seed so if you really want one you could wait for Autumn and start some seeds.

"How do these folks succeed, is it a green thumb & good patience? *bah* it seems like my plant projects don't turn out that great." Take heart. There is no such thing as a green thumb. people who grow stuff successfully can do it because have done a lot of reading, listening and observation. And they've practised. There is no innate magical ability.

Are you aware of emerald ash borer, and it is an issue (or likely to become one) in your area, and for whatever species of ash tree you are trying to propagate?

Richard.

what floral said...some folks talk about *my* green thumb - but if they knew of all my failures, and how many hundreds of plants/trees I've killed...well...they likely wouldn't have that same feeling of awe or envy...