Planting Honey Locust next to old spruce stump

10 years ago

I would like to plant a young honey locust tree (Sunburst or Shademaster Ã¯Â¿Â½ about 10ft tall; fresh from my local nursery) in a spot that is close to an old silver sprice stump.
I had the spruce tree removed in 2012, when it was about 25-ft tall.

I just want to make sure there will be no major issues that would inhibit the honey locust's growth.

Please see the the attached pic - I want to plant the honey locust in the spot marked with the red X. The spruce stump is right behind it - about 3 feet behind it, and it's about 16 in in diameter.

The reason I've picked this particular spot is that it's right next to my driveway/garage (but not too close to the structure), and I'm hoping that, as the tree grows, it will provide some nice shade to this area that gets beaten by the hot summer sun.

Another thing that I like about this spot is that it's downstream from the rain spout Ã¯Â¿Â½ marked with the green circle in the pic. So the tree would be getting a lot of moisture.

I am aware that this little area, as you can see in the pic, still looks like crap, especially with the spruce stump still in there. I'm not too concerend about these esthetics, as long as the honey locust takes in.

The stump, and it's root system, should gradually disintegrate over time, and I can deal with that. I just want to make sure the the spruce dead stump/root chemistry, acidity, whatever, will not inhibit the young honey locust's growth. And, I know that digging a hole righ next to the stump might be rough Ã¯Â¿Â½ we'll see how that goes.

Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

hortster
10 years ago
Soils that were under spruces can develop very low pH (you mentioned acidity). I have seen soil tests from such soils at 4.3-4.5. I would suggest that you have a soil test done to see where yours is at and if lime might be required, or even if you should pick a different location. Honeylocust does fairly well around here (KS) in our HIGH pH soils. I have seen areas where spruces had been removed remain almost bare for years, leading me to question whether I would try what you are thinking about doing.

The US Forest Service and USDA both state that pH tolerance of Gleditsia triacanthos is 4.8 to 8.0. The "ideal" pH is 6.0-8.0. You also might talk to folks at your local extension service since in CO they have probably had experience with this.
0
Smivies (Ontario - 5b)
10 years ago
In regard to pH....it is HIGHLY unlikely that you will have acidic soils in Denver, regardless of the presence of a spruce or not.
0
Related Discussions
dry sterile shade next to deck...stumped
Q
Comments (7)
The problem with the area that you describe is that it isn't CONSISTENTLY dry shade. It "collects rain" in the winter. That rules out most of the plants I was going to suggest. You could TRY one of the following and see if they survive the winter...I would just try a couple before I commited...because I don't think either will tolerate consistently wet feet: Epimedium (barrenwort) Hellebore (Lenten Rose) Both are good for dry shade, and both will spread(eventually), which means you won't need to purchase QUITE so many plants. I think a bed of either would be cool, but they'd also look good planted in drifts. Would a japanese inspired garden work for you? That's where the gravel/japanese maple/steeping stones took my brain...but I think you'd still need to do some minor grading and some sort of rain garden/french drain-esque thing to keep it looking decent during your rainy season. Another thought---this might be the time to try some interesting plants in a grouping of pots. Yes, they still will need water, but they won't be fighting with the maple FOR the water, and they'll be elevated above the wet spot in the winter. Of course, cool pots aren't inexpensive, either...I'm certain others will come up with some practical suggestions. I'm primarily a "plants" girl. Oh, and there's always mulch! melanie
...See More
Honey Locust is leaning
Q
Comments (9)
Would there be enough light for a conifer if it gets shaded late in the day? I'm thinking I will do something like is shown in the link below for the willow once it gets larger. It is currently growing very rapidly. It looks like it worked out really well for them, the photos are on the second page of that link. I'll likely It's not going to hurt anything at this point to wait till fall to remove, so I'll wait till it drops it's leaves and try transplanting it to our property up north where it will have lots of room to do whatever it wants without causing harm to anyone or anything. I'm sure I paid way too much for it, I know it was over $100 2 years ago when I got it and it was on sale. Yes, I've seen the warnings about not growing under fast growing trees. I absolutely believe you that the vast majority of people have a lot of trouble growing under these trees. I give my plants a bit more care than most people can manage... I just figure they are going to consume more resources than they otherwise would if they were under a slower tree. Just like the ones under the green ash consume more resources. Buying your miracle grow in 50# bags helps. I'm on city water, that's the parts that really sucks, prices went up again this year, could have months up to $300. I always have at least a few hosta laying around that are not even in pots, just clumps maybe a bit of soil, with roots astray, many of those grow exceedingly well, that gives you an idea of how often I water. It rains or I water, daily, if it's hot, I water 2-3X (for everything that likes to be moist / wet). I have a little experiment going. I planted 1" tissue culture Stained Glass hosta in full sun in mulch only, 10 days out, all are looking good except for one that is dragging it's feet a little. Biggest slow down was they got burnt a little, but they are overcoming it. They do have excellent root systems and will eventually grow down into the soil. I wanted to see how rapidly they would grow in a very well aerated environment - mulch. -- The drive to test some of these things is carry over from some excellent results I've had with container growing in very fast soils as well as airoponics. If it really gets to be a problem under some of these trees, I'll go to the root bag idea someone suggested. I'll check out the trees you mention. Looking at things more tonight, I may not even need another tree up there to replace it, maybe a Empress Wu Hosta (giant) in it's place! I will wait till fall to make the changes. Thanks! Jamie Here is a link that might be useful: Willow Pruning
...See More
Replanting next to stump
Q
Comments (19)
I don't see any problem planting next to a stump. I do it all the time and have for years. I live in a land of stumps. I like to plant Sedums on stumps. It beats the cost of grinding or the labor to dig them up. Sometimes I cut them as low as possible and then cover them with topsoil. That works just fine as long as I don't plant a lawn over it. Mike...near Seattle Sedums on a Alnus oregona stump. http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i283/Botann/014-2.jpg
...See More
Lost a tree, must we dig out stump to plant new one?
Q
Comments (27)
B, we're in agreement on one thing (I think), that Armillaria is a virulent plant pathogen across many genera, and as such, is something to take into account. In your experience though, do you find lots (Hard to define"lots", I know) of cases where random landscape plant stumps are infected? I'm not discountiing the existence of this species of fungus out in the landscape. Heck, I've seen-and eaten-my share of "honeys". But it's still just a rarity in most home landscape situations, I find. The occasional street tree will succumb. That is, after other factors have rendered said tree low on defenses. But so far as I'm aware, we're not awash in Armillaria......are we? +oM
...See More
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
10 years ago
if you can dig the hole.. the stump is irrelevant ... took you more time to type up the post.. than it would have taken me to plant it ...

if you hit some dead old root.. work smart.. and dig your hole a few inches away from the root ..

the downspout will most likely wash soil away from the tree .. rather than provide water... as it will run right past it ... you will need to divert it.. and figure out how to slow it down ... to soak in, before it runs further down hill .. or better yet.. just water it properly..and dont rely on rain ...

see link for planting instructions...

do you see any other honey locust in town.. thats my usual indication of its tolerance to native soil ... also .... the same.. if purchased locally ... rather than mail ordered in.. most good nurseries.. dont sell things that wont live ... a quick call to your COUNTY extension office will also get you a fast LOCAL answer ... [if buying from a hardware store.. good luck with that]

ken

EDIT: fir typos.. lol .. FOR typos ... crikey ...

Here is a link that might be useful: link

This post was edited by ken_adrian on Wed, Apr 30, 14 at 9:39
0
bengz6westmd
10 years ago
Tough tree -- should be fine. Quite drought/heat tolerant once established. It's the only tree that grows non-stop thru the hottest, driest periods on my lot. Mine's 35' ft tall after 10 seasons.
0
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
10 years ago
heat and drought tolerance.. has nothing to do you new tree ... prior to a recently planted tree get ESTABLISHED ... which.. depending on size.. could be 2 or three years .. for those 2 or 3 years.. you are responsible for all watering.. and deeply thru the root mass planted ...

the easiest solution to avoid soil erosion.. would be to extend a 4 inch perforated pipe... past the tree ... then some water would shed.. and the remainder carried further on....

do not confuse yourself about how the big old pine coped.. and then make presumptions that the new babe.. will do the same.. immediately ... it will.. but it will take time ..

good luck

ken
0
hairmetal4ever
10 years ago
Honeylocusts are usually recommended for adverse conditions, but most of the ones around here look like hell. Some bug disfigures the leaves and a lot have dieback.

FWIW, the gutter drainage could be made to benefit the new tree if you can somehow "slow down" the flow of water and maybe trap it.

In my climate, it would probably be too much water, but in yours it might be "just right".

One trick I've seen is to let the downspout hit the top of a large rock, and the water will then run down the sides of the rock, slowing it down enough to at least somewhat soak in.

I doubt the soil pH would be an issue. Your soils there are rather alkaline to start with, so even if acidified by the spruce, it won't be to a level where you'd have any concern.
0
hortster
10 years ago
Folks, we make calls based on our own experiences. Admittedly, I have only seen two soil tests from soils under old, large spruces, and as I said, they were 4.3 and 4.5 pH. The normal pH around here is typically high.

There is a ton of info on this if you google "soil acidification under spruce."

Here is a link that might be useful: Soil acidification
0

Planting Honey Locust next to old spruce stump

Comments (7)

hortster

Smivies (Ontario - 5b)

Related Discussions

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

bengz6westmd

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

hairmetal4ever

hortster

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US