Should I install a preformed pond or pond liner?

13 years ago

Hello, I am interested in having a pond installed, but not sure if I should go with a preformed pond or liner pond. I had a 15 x 8 pond with waterfall, that used the aquascape system at my old house. I had problems with the pumping housing separating from the wall when the ground freezed and thawed, creating leaks. Also, the maintenance seemed to get pricer over the years, due to shifting and settling of the rocks. Is the maintenance less with the preformed ponds? Do the preformed ponds shift or push up from the ground due to the freezing and thawing? What are the pros and cons of both? I got a price of approximately $10,000.00 for a liner pond approximately 12 x 8. That seemed a bit pricey. Is that what ponds are going for these days?

Thanks so much for your anticpated response. Susan

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

nkm56
13 years ago
If you're planning to have someone dig the pond, lay the liner, and add a few tons of rocks, then the price you were quoted is probably an average cost. There are ways you can do it for less.

When I put my pond in, the liner and equipment (skimmer, waterfall bio box, plumbing hoses, pvc glue, waterfall foam, and other assorted equipment, cost a grand total of $1,200.00. The catch? I dug the pond myself, got some friends and relataives to help me lay the liner in the hole, and did the plumbing work myself. It isn't hard. The rocks cost extra, but I ended up taking the rocks out anyway -- it looked great, but too much maintenance for my taste.

I personally wouldn't use the aquascape system. I'm sure their equipment is probably good, but they dump a ton of rocks in there and their calculations are often way off the mark, leaving you with less water volume than promised. I also don't like the stair-step shelf rings that invite predators.

If you want a liner pond and don't want to wield the shovel yourself, look into renting a mini excavator. They're fairly easy to operate, and you should have the job done in one day. The cost should not be much, compared to the price you were quoted for installing the pond.

Or, if you know some teenage boys who would like to earn a few hundred bucks for some hard labor, ask them to dig it for you. I have a friend who hired her garden men to dig her pond, and they had it done in one afternoon.

Some people are perfectly happy with their little preforms and stock tanks, though, so it's all in what you're looking for. For me, I like large koi, which cannot be placed in a small preform.
karenrf
13 years ago
Go with the liner. ...and do it as big as you want it the first time.
Your biggest expense is going to be the liner.
Also, go with bottom drains. Makes things a lot more easy on you and safer for the fish not to have a pump inside the pond.

We put in a 15'x 32'x 3.5' pond and the cost was under $2000. (sorry I can't remember the exact amount right off) The liner was around $500. + shipping = approx. $600. BUT we did the work ourselves.
There's LOTS of info on the web. Lots of great koi pond websites and forums.

You can save money by hand digging the hole with shovels but if you can afford to have someone come in and use a backhoe I would.
Research first, then install the pond. Know exactly what you are getting into before you start.

I also agree with Nancy. I would not go with an Aquascapes system. Too many rocks. Then someone, either you or someone you hire(extra yearly expense), has to come in and clean the bottom of the pond every year. Just like a big ol fish tank that all of the crud settles in the rocks.

BTW, $10k is terrible for such a small pond; but then you are paying for labor when you have someone install it.

Ask all the questions you want. We can talk you through it.
~Karen
Related Discussions
Best preformed pond source?
Q
Comments (8)
I have a couple of preformed ponds, small one is some 50 or 80 gallons, next to it a larger one of 180-200 gallons. They sit next to each other with a bridge over the dirt between giving the illusion of one large pond. They are on their 3rd year now, they make it fine thru the winter's freeze here on Long Island NY. While I got the liners for free they are similar to the liners I've seen at Lowes. Home Depot has some too but Lowes seems to keep more on hand by me. I've never been able to keep the small one as I'd like it so it tends to get used just for plants. Last spring I did use it for a few weeks when draining/cleaning the main pond and something came along one night and ate 3 of 4 large goldfish in there. My friend with the same size pond lost fish in his too. I never lost a fish from the larger pond. I don't know what got the fish, the only predators around here are cats and the occasional possum. The larger pond has a shelf on either end I place large pieces of slate over to make a hiding place. I run a Pondmaster pump & filter to keep it clean; the one I have is about 12x12" and I made a holder to keep the pump attached to the filter (otherwise it tends to fall over). It needs to be cleaned out every 3-4 days as the filter clogs. I keep two filters so I have a fresh one to put in while I hose off the other. I also run a large aquarium air pump to keep the O2 levers up. Winters all I run is the air. The water gets green early in the season until I can get water lettuce (WL) in there. The WL out competes algae for sun & nutrients so the water stays clear. I do have a UV light too, but only turn it on when things get murky early in the season. These ponds are simple to install, just dig a big flat hole, drop em in, and back fill the edges. Use a level or you will have spots on the sides too high or low. Took me a few years of trial end error to drain, pull up a low spot, drop in some dirt, then refill for the season. Apart from size I doubt there is much difference in brands. You should be happy with the 2-300 gallon one. One trick I used: I had no place to get rid of the dirt I dug out, so as this was a corner pond I lined the corner with rail road ties, dug out only partially to seat the ponds, then used the dirt to contain the tops in a now raised bed with sloped front. No one has yet to notice my "natural ponds" are actually on the highest ground in my yard!
...See More
??'s - Retro bottom drain, pond liner, & moving fish to new pond
Q
Comments (3)
I also remember you mammabird. I usually don't use the forum much in the winter but come back on in the spring just to catch up on what's new etc. I have a retrofit bd as well mine is some modifications on the Tetra through the liner drain (which froze) but I used the cap from it for my drain. I am replacing that this year with the Aqua Art Drain as it sits flatter than mine. Not sure if I understand your "hump" but you usually put the bd in the deepest part of the pond. Avid koi-keepers like to do TPR's--but that also means cutting a hole in the liner. With your pond dimensions you might want two bottom drains one for each deep section. That would mean two bulk heads (I did pipe boot connections) through the liner on the side of the pond wall nearest your settling chamber. My drain has a 4" line reduced to 3" just before it enters the sc followed by a 3" knife valve (there much cheaper!). I take my drain out for winter because of my climate. Water inside pipes in my climate not a good idea. My settling chamber is a liner chamber (kinda like a pond beside the pond)350 gals-my pond is 2500 gals. They say sc should hold at least 10% of your pond volume. I really like this system as use sc for water changes. I have 3-4 ft square matala mats in my chamber which is also my mechanical filitration. Good luck with your new pond and move. Patti
...See More
Cutting into hard preformed pond liner
Q
Comments (8)
Shelly, I have mated quite a few preformed ponds together and also added a fifty gallon drum onto the side of a preformed pond or two through the years. After cutting the desired size of area out with a jig saw/saber saw, I bolted the two sections together around the perimeter of the cut with 1/4" nuts and bolts to hold them securely. Prior to bolting them up tight I laid a bead of Plummers Goop between the two sections as a sealer. Using splicing tape, as suggested by taralynna, is also a good way to seal up the joints. Insead of buying it from a pond store, try going to a hardware store and ask for skylight/roof flashing, sealing tape. It is the same seaming tape used for EPDM pond liners, but is sold a lot cheaper as skylight/ roof flashing tape. You can get it double or single sided and it comes in a strip about five feet long. "Horton"
...See More
The difference between a liner pond and a REAL pond
Q
Comments (40)
dang it....I had a really well though out response all done, and my internet explorer crashed. So I'll try again...lol!! First...a few comments regarding how koi ponds compare to aquariums. Normally, aquariums are lightly stocked with small fish. It's really easy to keep the ammonia/nitrite/nitrate cycle operating perfectly in a correctly stocked environment. Same as a rock bottom pond...lightly stocked and properly maintanied it can work. In a pond's bio filter, ammonia is converted to nitrite and then to nitrate. Nitrate is most easily removed froma koi pond by way of regular water changes. Ever try to keep an aquarium with goldfish? Many goldie keepers I know keep no gravel in the tank at all, because of maintenance. That gravel gets really filthy very fast. I had a lovely goldie tank once....and gave it up. the maintenance was a nightmare! I'd rather deal with a huge koi pond any day of the week. Some people are reporting sucess with rock bottom ponds and no maintenance. Again...it is directly related to stocking levels. I hope these ponds continue to perform well for years to come, but for the vast majority of people, they will not. Most watergardeners install their ponds (and rocks) and then run out and buy a bunch of adorable little 5" long koi. The koi grow.....fast. They produce mountains of fish waste, which all gets trapped in the rocks. But because the pond looks clean, the owner is lulled into a false sense of security and does not think that there is a thing wrong, until the fish start dying or the fins start rotting off. Then they do one of two thing....they learn where they went wrong and correct their mistakes, or they just buy new fish (which is unfortunatly what most people do). Matt...you are on the right track with your new pond. You certainly can install your bottom drain now and add the rest of the system later. But instead of using a pipe cap, install a 4" ball valve on the end of the line. The water can't be permitted to sit stagnant in the unused drain line for too long or it will start developing the dreaded hydrogen sulphide gas. Opening that valve every couple of weeks and allowing the water to flow out for a couple of minutes will prevent the problems. I am attaching a link to the Atlanta Koi Club's web site. They have an excellent pdf that explains a lot about how a koi pond works, water quality, stocking levels, how much biofiltration is needed and many other wonderful facts. Cindy
...See More
ccoombs1
13 years ago
By all means, go with a liner pond. A preform is suitable only as a small water garden with possibly a few goldfish. It should never be used to house koi since they get so large and need a lot of space and filtration. And since you are in the planning stages, you have a wonderful chance to do it right. Bottom drains are such a wonderful thing. My big pond is 9000 gallons and 4' deep and I NEVER have to clean the bottom of it. It stays perfectly clean all the time, because the bottom drain carries off all of the fish waste to the filters. If you are worried about the sides shifting and settling, then build the pond either with a solid concrete collar around it (like a footer) or even better....a concrete block wall. The liner is then installed over the blocks and the rocks sit on top, fully supported by the block wall. I have built all of my ponds this way and they look wonderful.

Should I install a preformed pond or pond liner?

Comments (3)

nkm56

karenrf

Related Discussions

ccoombs1

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US