The Head of Infectious Disease on Swimming In Your Pond

15 years ago

We have pondered this question on this forum in the past. Is it safe to swim in the pond? Today I had the privilage of asking this question to the Head of Infectious Disease Doctor of my Health System. He response:

That depends. "The questions that need to be asked are first what is the environment of the pond. What is the size? Is is frequented by wildlife? Is is filtered? Do dogs have access to it? Is is moving water? "

My response- For the most part let's consider this pond to be a man made liner pond with fish, occasional visits from racoons and birds, with it being filtered and the pond water volume being turned over every hour, no chlorine, and with only fish and occasional frogs as the inhabitants.

The doctor responds "The main concern would be for leptosprirosis, a disease caused by dog urine in the pond. We see a few of these cases every year. Stagnant water is also a concern."

Me- What about filtered ponds that are above ground,or slightly about ground that are not exposed to run off or to dog urine?

The doctor responds: "A pond that you describe that is filtered, that is not stagnant water, without signicant debris, without exposure to dog urine or to frequent wild animal visits would not pose a significant risk to your health".

So that is the skinny on skinny dipping in my pond.

Take it or leave it but I for one am finally reassured that there are no SIGNIFICANT health risks for me to swim in my pond.

Disclaimer: I do however want to caution those with diabetes, chronic health issues, and those with DIRTY ponds that this conversation may not apply to them and the doctor was speaking to me on a personal level and this conversation does not guarentee or imply any health guarentees for anyone who chooses to swim in their or other peoples ponds. To do so is at your own risk.

Regards,

Lisa

Featured Answer

kalevi

15 years ago

Do you ever swim in a river or lake? As long as your pond has a running filter (mechanical or bio) and is healthy, it is pretty much the same as swimming in a lake or river.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

koijoyii
15 years ago
Thanks Lisa for the info. I still don't have enough nerve to get into my pond. I'm afraid I won't be able to get out. It sure it tempting when the temps are in the 90's though.

I didn't forget you asked for current pics of my fish and pond. Don't know if you got a chance to see my recent post (it's on page 5 already). I am linking it here in case you didn't.

Jenny

Here is a link that might be useful: Current fish and pond pics
pond_dragon
15 years ago
Thanks for posting that.

I'm in my pond at least once a week and sometimes up to my neck. I have worked in/around the pond for hours before showering and so far no infections or getting sick from it. But that doesn't mean it won't ever happen. I do feel better now about getting in there.
Related Discussions
Natural swimming pond in zone 4
Q
Comments (3)
I'm in zone 6 but I know there are several ponders here who live in zones 4 and above that have lined water gardens/fish ponds and I don't recall them having problems with the liners in winter.Hopefully one of them will verify this. I would just make sure to research liners thoroughly and to ensure you get a good quality one. Even in Zone 6, the ice here gets thick enough to walk on at least once or twice a winter and I've had no liner damage after 5 years. I'm honestly thinking that perhaps the reason more people haven't responded to your question here (besides the fact that very few people have natural swimming ponds) is that this subject has been brought up before and caused quite a bit of debate-- not about the liner, but about the actual safety of swimming in a "natural" pond. You could try doing a search on this forum for swimming, etc. to see what has been discussed before. The link below is one such thread, but I know there are more "heated" discussions out there as well. The photos I've seen of natural swimming ponds are beautiful and I'd be interested in hearing all the details if you do decide to build one! Sherry Here is a link that might be useful: The Head of Infectious Disease on Swimming In Your Pond
...See More
Pond Maintenance Trick --For BD Ponds.
Q
Comments (8)
Oh, I like that idea. Except for the part about the string going through the water and up to the dock. Knowing my fish, one of them would swim into it and knock off a scale, ending a show career. I think I'd rather tie the end of the string to something that can sit in the bottom of the pond next to the drain cover. Like a piece of PCV pipe or a large stainless steel nut. Anything that won't slip under the bottom drain dome. A large nut might be ideal, because I could hook it with something and pull the string up without even getting in the pond. I had to go swimming yesterday to unclog drains. I knew they were starting to run slow and needed cleaning, but of course while I was away for the weekend my poor DH had to try to keep the filters going with the suddenly even more reduced flow. I wish I had thought to run a string through the actual drain lines and clean them while I was already wet. I am sure the drain lines have a lot of icky stuff on the walls after 5 years in service.
...See More
What is your favorite feature about your pond?
Q
Comments (32)
Nancy, I keep their compartment doors shut until I see them sitting on top of the house each year. They make it very easy for me because they arrive almost the same day of the month every year. Then I open the doors and they set up housekeeping and I don't think any birds we have will bother them then. They are pretty feisty. But you don't want to let some other bird get into their house and set up houskeeping before they do. Then when they say goodbye and leave I clean out their compartments and shut the doors again until the next year. This year hubby and I left for 2 weeks before they left. The day we returned we were out by the pond and they flew down around us twittering, very obviously saying goodbye. The next day they were gone. It was as though they were waiting for our return to leave. I haven't had any problems so far... We are planning to put up more houses for them next year. Glenda
...See More
Why you should never swim in garden ponds
Q
Comments (28)
OMG she can't state what she read, and try to inform people about this? Geez, if you don't have anything nice to say then DONT say anything! If you can get it from a poorly maintained SWIMMING pool, then in my eyes you can get it from a backyard pond in which you NEVER put chlorine.. Supposedly some of you say "only" in "natural" warm bodies of water...well, the way I see it is that if your pond is around long enough you can pretty much call it a "natural" environment for the things that have been living in it for years. With everything we put in our ponds..fish that may have parasitic problems..plants from nurseries where god only knows what was in their water..plants you yourself go into a streambed or wherever and transplant to your pond yourself..birds and other critters dropping by after being in a "natural" pond or lake, ALL of these could very easily bring these amoeba ( and god knows what else) into your lil safe backyard pond. Also, backyard ponds tend to warm up faster than "natural" lakes and ponds because they are smaller, so maybe they can breed there faster...So IMO there is def a chance of these amoeba being in our lil pond sanctuaries in our backyards...unless your ponds are in safety bubbles, anything can be in there. That's just my 2 cents..Oh I could go on , but someone needs to feed these children who call me mom, and for some reason the lil critters claim it's my responsibility, so I'm off.. Daniella :)
...See More
derrickm
15 years ago
I don't worry about going into my pond when I have to. I was in a heck of a lot worse when I was a kid!! LOL....people have become so wimpy these days! ;)
tuder96
15 years ago
Interesting I have been known to get in the pond, snorkle to take some picts and a few weeks ago broke out in little red itchie bumps that went away and it doesnt happen any more
sleeplessinftwayne
15 years ago
Thanks for the info. That is pretty much what I thought with a couple of caviats. The first is to be aware of the critters that visit and make sure the area around the pond is kept clean. Those raccoon roundworms are not funny. If you find fresh scat, remove it inside a sealed plastic bag and forgo the swim that day. I don't know how to sanitize the area but I'm sure it is on some site somewhere. I just don't have time to look for it right now. The second is to make sure there is someone with you or very close by who will respond to loud splashes and possible curses. The liner gets really slippery. Happy swimming, Sandy
frankielynnsie
14 years ago
I have gotten in mine on occasion. The only thing I don't like is the leeches.
timbersmith
14 years ago
My pond isn't big enough to really "swim" in, but I don't hesitate to get in the water for whatever task requires it. Just throw on a swim suit and get to work, though I do try to keep my head above the water at all times.

Hell, I've voluntarily swam in the Ohio River, and it's a pretty safe bet that the river is worse than my pond.
riverspots
14 years ago
Gee, I don't agree with his comment at all. Your pet dog won't be a problem if it gets its annual distemper+ shot that has a leptospirosis component. Around the Middle Atlantic states, lepto is rarely seen and when outbreaks do occur, they're usually linked to city rats.

On the other hand, commercially raised fish can carry mycoplasm, and visitors, like heron, may introduce blue-green algae. Both can cause serious skin infections in humans. I stay away from pond water if I have open wounds and always wash skin after handling pond water or plants.
goodkarma_
Original Author
14 years ago
Riverspot- You don't have to agree. It is a free country. :) But......we are talking about an experienced, well trained, infectious disease doctor for a major health sytem that include 3 major hospitals with 4 joint venture hospitals. So I tend to think he may know what he is talking about. Just sayin........:)
bluelake
14 years ago
That was an interesting read! The original post and then the follow ups. I NEVER hesitate to get into my pond. I have my hands in there just about every day, up to my elbow. When I'm done, I never feel compelled to go wash my hands right away! The 1-3 times per year that I have to fully get into it, I love it. The fish play, I play and get the items out, or repair this or that. Even then I don't run and take a shower. However, my pond is crystal clear with the exceptions of some string algae. I see clear liner when I look down.
hecht7_hotmail_com
13 years ago
We just bought a trailer by a fairly big pond. I'm itching to beable to swim in it but don't know if it would be safe to do so. There are a lot of Canada Geese around and in the pond and some ducks. Also a lot of Geese excrement all around the pond. Does anyone know if it is still safe?? It is a man made pond with still/stagnant water. The size I estimate 500 meters long by 50 meters wide.
Thank you for any response.
Bettina
groundbeef
13 years ago
@ Bettina

I think you answered your own question.
1. Stagnant Water
2. Full of Goose/Duck crap.

Sounds like a great place to swim if you are looking to get really, really sick. I can only think that perhaps a sewage treatment pond might be worse. Maybe.

The Head of Infectious Disease on Swimming In Your Pond

kalevi

Comments (13)

koijoyii

pond_dragon

Related Discussions

derrickm

tuder96

sleeplessinftwayne

frankielynnsie

timbersmith

riverspots

goodkarma_
Original Author

bluelake

hecht7_hotmail_com

groundbeef

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

The Head of Infectious Disease on Swimming In Your Pond

Comments (13)

Related Discussions

goodkarma_Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

goodkarma_
Original Author