I'm getting the Medallion, Brookhill, for the kitchen and something a little different for the master bathroom, haven't decided on powder room yet as I want to pick out the limestone first and then the cabinet after that. HD seemed pleased with the construction, etc. Had Brookhaven and Woodmode in my previous home, was very happy with them but the KD told me I would double the price so........... Originally started out with someone our builder uses, custom, but I didn't like his design at all, changed things, asked for a certain thing, he ignored me and I wasn't thrilled with him. Then the builder told me that he has a hard time dealing with women, they should be seen and not heard and apparently the builder's wife had a problem with him as well and finally told him it was HER kitchen and she wanted the dishwashers where she wanted them, etc. So we went elsewhere and KD showed us Medallion..............

I am in the process of having my Dura Supreme Alectra (frameless) cabinets installed. They look beautiful, and the quality was as good or better than any cabinet I considered. If you have any specific questions, I'll be happy to answer you.

I didn't see P&F here, but from what I've read here over about 3 years I would expect it to be high quality and high satisfaction. I had the same impression of Brookhaven. I would have had the impression that they would cost more than Brookhaven, but it seems there is some variance in how Brookhaven will price out depending on where you are and whop you are dealing with. There are also little details that can have bigger impacts on your pricing than you might expect. And again, I don't think they are sold anywhere in this area. I have Brookhaven frameless. I have seen a number of folks here who also have them, and I've never seen complaints about them. Mine have been in over 2 years and I'm very pleased with them. I do have some cherry, but it is Woodmode -- the finish was gorgeous and it was a near match to our breakfast room set. If possible, I would price out more than one line in at least a basic configuration before you make a decision.

apples to oranges- they should not be in the same comparison-the prices you differences are close to what you should expect (even though all are pocket hole constucted frames etc). If WBF best suits your budget then fine. But if you can even consider affording DS then ... Sounds to me like one of the dealers misread where your at. DS comes in two price groups, and offers both framed and frameless as well as inset. Even the lower priced DS will be a good bit more than WBF DS vs. Kraftmaid- DS has a very nice finish and will have better wood grading, quality control, along with more design flexibility. KM makes a competant cabinet that will last and has a good selection. You may need to have a door or two replaced to get where you want to be, they might be a tad trickier to install. But bottom line they will hold up for a long time- lots of GWbers have em and are happy- that might be said for the others too though. I'm not a fan of Chinese cabinets so not big on JSI- there is a thread on that where you will find some more positive thoughts by others (along with my personal rant) There is another thread on cabinet priorities worth a look too.