Since the first one also comes in fabric - maybe to soften the look find a color that works w/your drapes, rugs, etc. My kitchen is similar in wood tones as yours, but my floor is dark hazelnut wood. I may go w/something that matches the cherry island/peninsula but put fabric on it.

Thank you Countrycottageklutz! I really like that one! I am going to do some more searches to see if I can find any reviews on that company's products- quality, etc. The bottom part of the one you found has an orb look but hard to tell from the picture if the top is more red? The name says "Rust" but as you know there are so many variations to colors. Maybe I can try to find a local dealer that carries this line. My other concern is how deep the stools are. As I said in my original post, my overhang is only 11". The one stool I liked was 25.25" deep- that seemed large for my bar! The one you found is only 22.25" so that is a little better. I may put another post out for members with raised bars and see how deep their stools are. Thanks again for your search- it was very thoughtful and I REALLY like the stool you found!!

The one on the right! it is the most modest and blends in the best with the kitchen as a whole. The other two become focal points of the space.

Hi Melissa, Here's a couple of stools I thought of right away: ^ It's called the Pablo by the Amisco brand. You can select your metal finish for the legs (comes in 10+ colors) and fabric or vinyl for the seat and back cushion. So you can get the colors you want! ----- ^ Here is the Melrose stool, also by the Amisco brand. The only difference is the leg style, but it comes with the same customization as in the first stool. If you're looking for a stainless finish, I recommend the 24 Magnetite. It's slightly darker than stainless, but it's the optimal choice for any kitchens with stainless.