Here's what BM suggests.... http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/rockportgray Here is a link that might be useful: BM site

What did you end up going with? I'm choosing colors right now. Stucco is Rockport Gray, garage doors and some accent siding will be Grays Harbor (blue gray).

Left - Accessible Beige (husband thinks it's too bland/light). Debating if I should try one shade darker. Right - Anew Gray (thanks @Sabrina Alfin for the suggestion). I actually really like this one compared to Mindful Grey, my original frontrunner. Leaning towards this one but would love to hear your thoughts. Trying to figure out shutters and door. Does it have to be the same color? The two colors I tried so far (SW Dried Thyme and Smokey Blue) aren't working. Trying SW Sea Serpent tomorrow but any other colors I should consider? Thanks!

Your house is a bungalow style, so if you haven’t already, do searches for ’bungalow exterior colors’ … ’stucco bungalow exterior colors’ … ’stucco cottage exterior colors’ … terms like that. Once you get a few ideas, just look up any stucco house style … ’stucco exterior colors’ for more that could work on yours. Limitless possibilities with a house like this — what looks do you like? What feel are you going for? Charming cottage, stark black and white, organic and natural, beachy, earth tones, funky boho, whimsical, quiet, etc? The roof is a non-entity, anything can work around a gray metal roof. I’m in Texas, they’re used often here, and are just a neutral background. I like these greens, but without knowing your preferences it’s hard to advise. Narrow it down for us. :) This is a good-looking color scheme … white body with taupe trim: https://www.houzz.com/photos/wilton-whole-home-renovation-transitional-exterior-atlanta-phvw-vp~12401900 I love red with cream: Classic yellow: Black and white (or do reverse): Ideas from Kelly Moore paints: https://kellymooreshop.com/blogs/our-blog/sweet-16-bungalow-style Lots of nice colors here: https://nextluxury.com/home-design/craftsman-style-homes/ From that link, I like this a lot. Dramatic, but earthy: If you’re feeling unsure about bolder colors, you can’t go wrong with using a white or off-white for the body and color of choice for trim/accents. Or tan or gray body with accent colors. I always like this look of two accent colors: