Interior Designer vs. GC
specialk1978
last year
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (31)
Helen
last yearHelen
last yearRelated Discussions
Architect vs. Interior Designer or Both?
Comments (21)On our house, we began with the architect. He encouraged us to hire an interior designer sooner rather than later. Lucky for us, his wife is an interior designer, and they definitely work well together. We benefit from the opinions of each of them. Also, in our situation, our architect is doing all of the interior elevations and modeling, so it's not split between our architect and a third-party interior designer (one of the reasons we wanted to use his wife). I can't imagine her suggesting anything like moving a wall! She probably looked at the floor plans as he designed them, but she was not involved at that point. Based on what virgilcarter described, it sounds like our architect may be more involved than most - he did the electrical and lighting placement (for the can lights) and stuff like that. In our situation, we are paying the architect a per-foot fee that includes construction administration and 3D modeling. We are paying the interior designer a per-hour fee. We specified what we need her help on, which includes lighting, plumbing fixtures, flooring, tile anywhere and probably some other items I haven't thought of. Things like kitchen design are more the architect and us. We will choose our own appliances (we're really into cooking, and don't need any help in being particular in that category), and will select and purchase our own furniture. Our builder we selected ourselves from some suggestions of the architect; he and the architect have worked together before, and the builder is familiar with the modern design and materials that the architect uses. We really, really like him, and know we will get a lot of helpful advice from our builder once the build starts (just waiting for snow to melt); he's already provided input on some elements such as use of pocket doors. So we're quite confident that he will work well with the architect, but be able to provide us with his independent viewpoint as well....See Morestarting with GC followed by self GC and DIY -- advice please!
Comments (6)What is the scope of the project? If you are not doing structural work and you have some people in mind to do plumbing/electrical etc, I would recommend acting as your own GC. You will need some rudimentary knowledge of the process though so you know what order to do on. For instance, my kitchen had a leak last year which necessitated new base cabs and subfloor/floor. Since the kitchen was 20 years old, we decided to to the whole thing. What I did: Demo, sheetrock walls, hardwood floors, unpacked and placed cabinets, knobs, painted, ran ductwork for vent, installed vent insert and will tile myself. What I paid for: Drywall guy to drywall ceilings (can't do by myself) and tape mud and sand the whole kitchen.($300) Random helper guy (known for his trimwork but knows how to do everything) installed the cabinets, counter height window, repaired cedar siding outside, 3 interior doors and trim in kitchen. ($1800 plus lunch everyday) Electrician ran new wires for appliances, outlets, chandelier and 6 recessed lights. Later he installed all the appliances and lighting ($1800) Plumber ran lines for prep sink and hooked up 2 sinks, installed 2 disposals and dishwasher. ($1400) Counters done by soapstone people Limestone hood installed by mason ($1500) As you can see, I only paid out $6000 in labor for my whole kitchen. I saved considerable amounts of money. It takes longer to do it this way since you have to wait for the one person to finish before making an appointment with the next guy. It took a full 6 months from demo to having a functional sink. There are still 2 small things to do even 15 months later. I was able to purchase higher quality materials with the savings on labor. Figure out what you can do yourself and go from there. Demoing the kitchen can save you a few thousand. I think sheetrocking takes some prior experience. Cabinets can be easy or difficult depending on your walls and floors. Here is a rough order of events in a kitchen remodel. Decide on your appliances so you have the specs before the cabinet design process. Don't actually purchase them until you know they will work in your design. Order the appliances before you order the cabinets to make sure they have them available before you order the cabinets. Have all spec sheets available for the designer. Pick out your sink. Design and order cabinets. Triple check your measurememts. make sure your appliances will fir in the cabinets. Make sure your sink fits in the base. Demo: Order a dumster (at least a 10 yard) Demo a few weeks before the cabinets come in so you have several weeks to get the electrical, plumbing and walls before cabinet delivery. Electrical: Usually done afer the design is done but before the walls are in. (Appliances, Outlets, Overhead lighting, Undercabinet lighting) Have appliance spec sheets and cabinet design available. Ask at what time you should call again and how much notice you need. Plumbing: Sinks and water lines for fridge. Do this before the walls go up. Ask when he/she would like to be called to finish and how much notice they need. Sheetrock after the electricians and plumbers have done their thing. Paint before cabinets go in. Flooring either before or after cabinets depending how you want to do it. Cabinets Unpack immediately to check each piece and order replacements if necessary. Have appliances there for install for clearances Install cabinets. Install counters. Some appliances may already need to be in place or not (i.e. the dishwasher needs to be there if you are getting stone counters unless you buy a dishwasher labeled stone countertop ready.) Once the counters are in, call back the plumber and electrician to finish up. Hopefully now you have a functional kitchen. Now finish up by installing backsplash and misc repairs. Good luck. Learning to do a lot yourself is an empowering experience. I figure if I could get a doctorate, I could do this stuff myself too. Now that I am done, I am thinking of selling and looking for a new fixer upper!...See MoreArchitect vs GC
Comments (6)Yes, my gc came recommended and for the most part, I trust him. It does worry me a that he would completely change the front entry of a two story house without so much as making a phone call to us or to the architect.... He just took it upon himself to make a major changes, which in the end I still don't quite understand... He thought it would "look" better, that is why he was going to change it. I was available and could have been there in 15 minutes, if he had called me. Luckily, I happened by that day and it could be fixed before he went any farther. I appreciate that he wanted my house to look good, but I would like him to run it past me before making changes to our plans that we have worked hard on. We've been in this house for 32 years, I've always disliked the entry and have put a lot of thought into this part of our remodel. The 5 windows alone being used around the front door are costing over $17,000. He was basically rearranging the windows for us. I also want to still be friends with the gc when the job is finished....See MoreArchitect vs general contractor vs interior designer?
Comments (17)General contractor is a given..the rest-it largely depends on you-your funds, confidence what you can/cannot do, resilience, time and energy you can devote, etc. (And experience and passion of your contractor. He won't pick your finishes of course; but he might have an idea to put a window instead of a door for example or some other thing you didn't think of by yourself. Brainstorming is part of the process) we pulled off gut remodel plus addition plus reconfiguring stuff with the help of GC only but I'd say I longed to have a designer not once..would be easier. it's a very trying experience, long as well, you want more professional people by your side. It doesn't get done by itself-and it's a full time job, if nobody undertakes it, you do. So by all means either contact a designer, or maybe look at design-build firms. Just make sure you have a good chemistry with that person. Important with everybody of course, builder as well. You'll spend hours with these people..days..months..hopefully not years but can happen:) Minimize stuff that can go wrong by choosing right people. Some things will go wrong but the better your relationship is the more chance in overcoming obstacles. Architect, I'm not sure you need..your builder may advise with structural engineer if needed for that to be removed wall "Understand that if you are tearing out walls, finalization of the plan occurs AFTER the walls are out and you can see what is behind them"-agreed (we didn't tear down walls though, if anything we added some lol..but as we fully gutted the space-I know some stuff can't be predicted until you touch the wall and know what's there) So yes..the combo of general contractor and interior designer would be best. Whom to contact first? I'd start with a GC to get a feel of a general scope of the work, but I think both can be contacted simultaneously, or one can start with a designer too Whether people do double duty? Rarely. They might want to, but will not be best equipped for it even if passionate or simply won't have time. But you don't neccessarily need them to do double duty, in your particular case. Interior designers, for example, are trained to understand how the house works, so they are not architects but can have great vision and realize the mechanics that are required to achieve it....See Morespecialk1978
last yearUser
last yearmcarroll16
last yearHelen
last yearHelen
last yearmcarroll16
last yearCharles Ross Homes
last yearDiana Bier Interiors, LLC
last yearspecialk1978
last yearCharles Ross Homes
last yearspecialk1978
last yearCharles Ross Homes
last yearPatricia Colwell Consulting
last yearspecialk1978
last yearDenise Marchand
last yearJoseph Corlett, LLC
last yearkandrewspa
last yearKristin Petro Interiors, Inc.
last yearLyndee Lee
last yearDenise Marchand
last yearJoseph Corlett, LLC
last yearmcarroll16
last yearUser
last yearCharles Ross Homes
last yearTakeoutchick
last yearlast modified: last yearJoseph Corlett, LLC
last yearCharles Ross Homes
last yearKristin Petro Interiors, Inc.
last year
Related Stories
EVENTSIndie Interior Designs: The 2015 Interior Design Show West
Homeowners and professionals get up close with boutique brands, independent artists and up-and-coming designers
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVETake a Virtual Tour of an Interior Designer’s Retro-Glam Home
Denise Davies takes viewers inside her vibrant and cozy Connecticut home
Full StoryMY HOUZZAn Interior Designer’s Bright Remodel of Her 1956 Home
The California pro opens up her family’s midcentury house and adds splashes of vibrant color
Full StoryLIGHTINGA Designer’s Top 10 Tips for Interior Lighting
Consider these things when selecting the location, style and function of your home’s lighting
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVETour 2 Stylish, Eco-Minded Rooms in an Interior Designer’s Home
In this video, San Francisco designer Jennifer Jones shares sustainable choices she made in her living and dining rooms
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVEPeek Inside an Interior Designer’s Stylish Home
In this video, Emma Merry takes viewers through her updated laundry room, entryway, home office and boy’s bedroom
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVEVisit an Interior Designer’s Beautiful Beach House Retreat
Watch and read how Karen Wolf created a relaxing family getaway with a durable coastal style
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVETour an Interior Designer’s Casual and Stylish Home
In this video, Katelyn Gilmour shares how she opened up and updated her 1970s ranch home in San Jose, California
Full StoryHOUZZ TV LIVEStep Inside an Interior Designer’s Experimental Modern Glam Home
Watch and read how John McClain used his stylish new L.A. home as a design laboratory to test new materials and features
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESCalifornia Law: License to Practice Interior Design?
A proposed bill that would require a license to practice interior design in California has Houzzers talking. Where do you stand?
Full Story
mcarroll16