My go-to used to be brushed. For me, as it it doesn't look good. I’ve switched to chrome.

However, you have warm choices. I'm wondering if a gold type finish would work.

For the "cooler" metal tones, we have been loving using Polished Nickel fixtures! They are beautiful and have a timeless look to them.

I'm going to vote for brushed nickel. I just did polished chrome in my master bath, but that was with white and gray. I think the gold finish is more trendy and I'm also just not feeling it with what you're showing. But if you have chosen a pull style and can't decide on a finish, get some of both and try them. Once you drill holes you're committed to a particular size, but not a finish. As long as they're returnable you have nothing to lose.

@jck910 I think that's it! just pulled up a polished nickel and it looks better than either of the other two

I love chrome in bathrooms is has clean look and the bit of shine is nice IMO poished nickel does the same but at a premium price usually. I cannot see gold tones with that counter .

Chrome for longevity in bathrooms. I have it in my baths even with warmer tones. classic