No question the second set is a better selection IMO.

Totally agree with BeverlyFLADeziner -- second set is better.

Agree! Second set definitely!!

@BeverlyFLADeziner @suezbell @Jamie Schroeder Thank you all for the suggestions. May I ask you why? I initially thought the first one is better even thought that is not the best choice. But I want to choose one between these two because of the price. I do not want to spend over $2000 for it.

I'm not a pro .. just my opinion.

To me, the first one seems more ornate whereas I think of a Tudor home as having a more geometric square/angled look -- more compatible with the second one.

The second one also appears to be frosted so there is likely more privacy than the first one but with plenty of light.

If you add a curtain or shade to the inside of the second one, it will likely make for a more uniform appearance no matter how open or closed you might want the window treatment , whereas

A glass with a centered pattern/design such as the first one means if you don't have the window treatment all the way open or closed, you risk "cutting" the pattern/design in half.

While I love (and have) glass double entry doors (mine are iron for Spanish-inspired house), in my opinion neither of the doors you show seem appropriate for your beautiful Tudor home. A search for Tudor entry doors shows wood doors, some with glass in the upper third, some with the little 'speakeasy' windows/doors, and some solid wood.

@suezbell Thank you very much for all the comments. I attached some pictures from buyers of these two doors. I will do a darker color on the frame. Probably dark brown or black.

I like the dark brown glass caming finish of the first one better. It makes the pattern stand out more.

The current door seems more Tudor than these. Are you changing because you want light?

Cooper Woods Modern Tudor · More Info

I'm not sure I like either option. I'd go for something more like this:

Neither, no, no, no. The glass is a terrible representation of leaded glass windows. Put up with me, because I am ranting about what I see as a garish reproduction/copy cat of what was authentic/true. Here real leaded glass:

Unless you found a door at a salvage lot, Investigate. Example: Anderson.

https://www.andersenwindows.com/ideas-and-inspiration/home-style-library/tudor/

Fun article for you to read:

https://www.bobvila.com/articles/tudor-style-home/

You have a beautiful home. I actually like the door you already have. Why you're considering changing matters. If your current door is real wood and in good shape, you might consider keeping it rather than settling for fiberglass. If you're planning to paint your new door anyway, consider whether or not painting the door you have would be a better option than a cheaper door with paint.

If, true "Tudor" style doesn't matter and instead of a double door you might like a single door with side lights, do at least consider those as well.

Home Depo has both the second double door and a similar single door with sidelights but neither are wood -- both are fiberglass.

https://www.homedepot.com/b/Doors-Windows-Exterior-Doors-Front-Doors/Single-door-with-Sidelites/N-5yc1vZar90Z1z0sfpk?storeSelection=

Follow your own instinct -- your door, your budget, your choice.

@suezbell Thank you very much. That is not my house^-^. I attached the picture I found online in order to show the style. We currently have painted solid wood door I believe. There are two reasons I wanted to exchange the door. One is that I feel the entry door without glass is kind of outdated. Second is that I like some natural light in the foyer, otherwise it is too dark.

The next picture is our current door.

@houssaon Yes. I do want some light in the foyer. Also I feel our door is way outdated. I attached a picture of our door above.

@Sabrina Alfin Interiors How about this one with half glass?

@elcieg Wow. That is a lot of info. Thank you very much. Let me take a look.

That looks very Arts & Crafts to me, not Tudor. I would skip the leaded glass.

yz00 - I originally answered the question you were asking as to which of the two door options might look better on a Tudor house. My FIRST thought was that neither really looked like a great fit. I, too, own a beautiful Tudor house. My front door is the original from 1939 - solid wood with vertical grooves (just like yours above) and stained very dark brown. It DOES have real leaded glass but only on top in the middle and it is rectangular. The hardware is almost identical to yours. Can I make a suggestion? Might be a crazy idea, but is it possible to keep your original wood door and have a window cut/made in it like you see in a traditional Tudor door? :/ IMO, that would be the best of both worlds, and probably much less than $2,000. Just food for thought......

And now that I look closer at it - your door hardware IS identical to mine! :)

Tudor Doors

I wonder it there is beautiful wood under all that paint. It is not out of style. It goes with the style of your house. I think the hardware looks original. My neighbor had her Tudor door refinished and it looked stunning. I would want to keep the original door. Please reconsider getting a new door. Spend the money to get it and the hardware restored.

I love Diana Bier Interiors suggestions. When I was stationed in England ( I am a retired US Air Force Captain), most of the Tudor styled homes had entry doors with stained wood and very little glass. Your home is lovely❣️

@Sabrina Alfin Interiors When you say leaded glass, do you mean any type of decorative glass?

Will this type of glass work?

Leaded glass has that "rippled" or "wavy" quality to it. The doors you just posted would work fine, IMO. Use regular clear glass.

@Jamie Schroeder It is possible to add glass I think. I do not know if it is worth the money for our current door which is very simple and it did not get a nice painting job inside and out making it very ugly to me. I believe the previous owner painted it right before he put the house on the market.

@Diana Bier Interiors, LLC Thank you for all the pictures. Lots of them have arched top. But our current door is rectangle. I think I will stick with that to avoid the extra cost.

@houssaon Do you think it is worth to remove the paint? The inside of our door is just a flat surface. Is it possible it is not solid wood. A sales person told me it is a wood door though.

@kculbers Thank you for your kind words. I may need to reconsider wood looking finish. Just feel the painted door is more popular right now.

If having glass for light is important -- more important to you than the Tudor style -- forget the Tudor style for your pending door purchase and go with your favorite style. YOUR style should be the front door to YOUR home.

You could save the current door in the attic or basement or garage -- putting it back in place if you later want to sell the house specifically as a "Tudor".

If you want double doors and glass, choose that.

I don't understand these supposed (extremely low) "prices" unless this is for toy doll house doors -- know what you're getting and from whom you're getting it ... and what info you're giving out to do so ... would be wary of this site. But. I do like the look of this double door.

https://eoutlet.shopsfashion2021.com/content?c=wooden%20front%20doors%20with%20glass%20panels&id=28 

I am a little late to the discussion but the door you have is beautiful and matches the architecture of your house. You could have a light added to make it even more special. Here’s a photo of my door with a leaded glass light. Credit goes to my parents for helping me restore it, and surprising me with the leaded glass insert.

Noreen - Absolutely gorgeous!