Help! Need advice. Hardwood or carpet for a master bedroom?
80sgirlatheart
2 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (12)
arcy_gw
2 years agoRelated Discussions
Hardwood flooring in the bedroom or wall to wall carpeting
Comments (38)Hardwood, no question. The happiest day of my home decorating life in this house was the one last summer in which my son ripped out the LAST of the wall-to-wall carpet, in his bedroom, and laid hardwood. Now I have wood in the foyer, LR, DR, hall and all 3 bedrooms. As many others have pointed out it is far easier to keep clean, and I love the clean spare appearance of the wood floors. My son also ran the flooring directly through the hallway and into the bedrooms so there are no thresholds and it makes the space look larger. Someday when I do a full remodel of my kitchen I'll continue the same wood flooring into there and the back contiguous hall. A few months ago as a stopgap we pulled up the horrible homeade vinyl floor in there and laid a laminate floor that looks similar to the wood, just a lot less expensive. My goal is that the only non-hardwood flooring in my house will be tile in our florida room, which is a separate (added-on before we bought the house) space. Hardwood rules! Ann...See MoreHardwood Floor in master bedroom in NE?
Comments (5)Before you go out any invest in sound control think about squeaks in the sub floor. Carpet does muffle some above, but not below. Sound control can help with the second level but if you have a sub floor that squeaks it will be heard below. Won't know for sure until it gets removed. Also flat sub floors are needed before the actual hardwood goes down. Hardwood enjoys a comfortable place to rest. Kind of an odd statement, but I can't find anything else for the moment. Any low or high spots with foot traffic weight can cause them to move ever so slightly; boards rub against one another causing squeaks. The original framing (floor joists) in the house before they put the sub floor material down may have shrunk. That's common with framing in humid summer months. Once the winters arrive along with dry heat things shrink, nails loosen..squeaks occur. Ken Fisher...See MoreCarpet or hardwood in bedrooms....your preference and why?
Comments (50)I had W2W carpet and now have LVP with area rugs. There are pros and cons to both. W2W: Pro: warm underfoot. Not a small consideration in winter, even in temperate Northern CA. Con: Dust sifts thru the weave and the paddings. In 10 yrs it'll be pretty disgusting how much allergy-causing dirt is hidden underneath, where you can't see it or clean it up, but your sinuses will know it's there. Pro: Vacuuming one consistent surface is easier than switching between smooth surface and area rugs. Con: Unless you get 'trackless' carpet, you and everyone else will see the impressions of feet and traffic patterns as soon as you put away the vacuum cleaner. Pro: A tip an estimator told me - even cheap carpet will feel better underfoot and last longer, if you pay for a good padding. He was right. Smooth surface: Pro: Easier to keep genuinely clean.... Con: .....BUT conversely you need to spend some time Swiffering dust up, either wet or dry, or both (I do both, in addition to vacuuming). Con: No matter what smooth flooring you pick, installation is the major cost and quality of your installer is critical. The majority of complaints here are from poor quality installs. Underlayments, transitions, layout design, picking the wrong flooring for your specific environmental conditions - if it can go wrong, somewhere and somebody has experienced that problem! Pro: A smooth surface flooring can show off a beautiful rug, or by itself be an important part of a room's decor, in a way a bland W2W can't do. The difference in the look of our MBR, when we changed from beige W2W to an LVP with a golden oak pattern, was actually a shock. We thought it would be nice, but it was SPECTACULARLY, noticeably better. Con: Even LVP is cool under foot, the way wood or sheet vinyl is, but not as bad as tile or stone. In summer it's great....not so much so in winter, LOL. HTH....See MoreWhat are pros and cons between hardwood and carpet flooring in bedroom
Comments (5)Carpets are warm and quiet underfoot. The noise dampening of carpet is not to be under estimated. Carpet prevents noise from moving OUT of a room and into another room as well as prevents noise ENTERING from underneath (ahem...the family room). That being said, the carpet is NOT the part that offers the noise reduction....it is the HIGH END PAD that offers the noise reduction. To get the noise reduction properties of carpet, you have to work with a more expensive carpet pad. Simply throwing down commercial grade berber over plywood (as an example) will not offer any form of acoustic properties. A hardwood floor can be used to reduce noise with SEVERAL requirements being Added to the installation. Of course, first and foremost the subfloors for those bedrooms need to be assessed to ensure a happy install. You might find that the hardwood install requires a LOT more preparation (ahem...costs and materials) than you anticipated. OK, assuming things are ready to role without much effort (rarely happens but let's just play along for a moment) the hardwood will need an acoustic underlayment (such as 6mm or 12mm cork underlayment). It is the underlayment (again...it is all about what sits UNDERNEATH the floor) that absorbs the noise, not the wood itself. The underlayment can add 1/4" (6mm) or even 1/2" (12mm) worth of floor-height raise onto a hardwood that might already be 3/4" thick. Oh dear. Check your door clearance. Most doors can handle a floor that is (roughly) 3/4" thick. That means most interior doors can handle 3/4" hardwood or a thick carpet + thick pad or even laid tile (can sit roughly 3/4") without having to remove/trim and rehang the darn things. But let's imagine this isn't going to be so easy. Let's imagine the hardwood needs a STIFFER subfloor which might mean another 1/2" of plywood. And now you want to add in 1/4" of cork for noise dampening. And then you choose a 3/4" solid hardwood. Uh Oh. You have just added 1 1/2" worth of floor height in those rooms. Hmmmmmm. Now the doors have to be trimmed and rehung. Oh wait and now the hallway floor sits REALLY low which means a BIG transition in the doorways. Whew. A beautifully thick carpet and thick pad will max out at 3/4". Doors and baseboards should be able to handle that thickness without much issue. The real trick will be the hardwood. What is the flooring OUTSIDE the bedrooms? What is currently INSIDE the bedrooms? What are your door clearances CURRENTLY sitting at? What is the subfloor thickness? How much noise enters/exits those rooms with the current set up?...See Moreanj_p
2 years agoUser
2 years agochispa
2 years agoYvonne Martin
2 years agoSammie J
2 years agoeinportlandor
2 years agoJen K (7b, 8a)
2 years ago80sgirlatheart
2 years agoworthy
2 years agolast modified: 2 years agosuezbell
2 years ago
Related Stories
BEDROOMSRoom of the Day: Master Bedroom Makeover on a Lean Budget
Creative use of online retailers helps transform a lackluster room into a light and beautifully finished space
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESHow to Lay Out a Master Bedroom for Serenity
Promote relaxation where you need it most with this pro advice for arranging your master bedroom furniture
Full StoryBEDROOMSRethinking the Master Bedroom
Bigger isn’t always better. Use these ideas to discover what you really want and need from your bedroom
Full StoryCOTTAGE STYLERoom of the Day: Cheery Cottage Style for a Master Bedroom
Reinvented antiques and other personal touches create a comfy, cozy vibe in a couple’s sleeping space
Full StoryBEDROOMSSoothing, Restful Master Bedroom That Functions Well
An Oklahoma couple work with their designer to create a relaxing retreat with new furnishings and built-ins
Full StoryBEDROOMSInside Houzz: A Guide to Updating Your Master Bedroom
Using data from a new Houzz survey, we share how you can better navigate the task of tackling a bedroom project
Full StoryBEDROOMSThe Cure for Houzz Envy: Master Bedroom Touches Anyone Can Do
Make your bedroom a serene dream with easy moves that won’t give your bank account nightmares
Full StoryBEDROOMSRoom of the Day: Bringing Intimacy to a Big Master Bedroom
A smart and well-detailed design makes a spacious master bedroom feel cozier, warmer and more inviting
Full StoryBEDROOMSSoft Touch: How to Choose Carpet for Your Bedroom
Sumptuous wall-to-wall carpet is an appealing choice for bedrooms. Here’s how to buy with ease and confidence
Full Story
Melissa R