skip to main content

Exterior Design Dilemma Remodeling

Roof question: should I change roof tiles to shingles?

2 years ago

We need a new roof & the roofer suggested we shift to shingles since lumber is so costly and our roof tiles are not through-body tiles. So they look a bit tired and seem to have a little algae, but are they tired enough to switch out for shingles? Original roof circa 1978.

Our stucco is very unique. I am tempted to stay true to design of home and redo her as best we can, keeping with her originality. Thoughts? Or are shingles nowadays so much better that it will give her that face lift she needs? She will be painted, as it is just stucco now. Any help or suggestions are appreciated! Roofer said we can do 30-year dimensional shingles or Presidential shingles. He recommends Presidential though it is a lot more costly. Has anyone had experience w Presidential? Worth the cost? I always thought these roof tiles would last 100 years and are valuable especially for resale. But now I don’t know? Thank you!!!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

cat_ky
2 years ago
No, keep the tiles. They can be cleaned. If they really need replacement, then replace with what you have. Shingles are just not right for your house.
tozmo1
2 years ago
Take a look at the Roof Maintenance Guide on this industry trade association page https://tileroofing.org/industry/marketing-materials/

I think finding a roofer who works with tile is your best bet. You also may want to go back to the original manufacturer for any materials warranty if indeed, they are impaired. This aticle says some clay tiles are warranted for 50 years. Can't tell if yours are clay or cement.

There are also some interesting technical briefs here, that speak to what can go wrong with tile and what can be done to correct.

https://tileroofing.org/industry/technical-briefs/
Related Discussions
Question: Roof/Shingle Flashing
Q
Comments (8)
Thank you all for your responses. My gut feeling told me that it was a crappy job. I am going to talk with the GC tomorrow and request that the work be corrected. We will also have a look at the house we viewed to see the standard of quality for the roofers work to see if it is the same as what has been done on ours. I think it was due to the fact that the roofer that was working in that area was a bit lazy. I was up at the house the morning they started and he sat on his butt almost the whole time I was there. I commented to the GC that I was sure glad I wasn't paying him by the hour! That same morning I was meeting with the kitchen designer and the same guy walked right through us while we were talking with a ghettoblaster on his shoulder that was cranked. I just shook my head. Luckily his level of enthusiasm was not the same as the rest of the crew! sierra - We are not in snow country so lack of ice and water shield isn't a problem. I am still disappointed with the color but since we weren't specific about it I will either pay to have it replaced or paint it. This is the only spot on the house where the flashing is visible. lsst - I was considering just painting it so I am glad to hear that it held up well for you. Do you recall which paint you used? mighty anvil - is this what you mean by stepped?
...See More
What should be put b/w roof plywood decking & shingles
Q
Comments (4)
Living in LA with all that rain, we definitely wanted ice/water shield installed. We included it in our contract. Some of the builders here do it routinely, many don't. We used ELK 50 year high wind, shingles over plywood decking (as called for by the manufacturer). Unvented attic, open cell foam also under attic deck. The builder kept wanting to use OSB, even though we had the shingle brand, and plywood roof decking written into our contract. (Plywood was recommended by the shingle manufacturer). We did prevail, but had to constantly watch him as he kept trying to substitute, cheaper materials throughout the build.
...See More
Roofing question....do my ridge caps look weird? Also, wavy roof?
Q
Comments (12)
All of the issues you mentioned are perfectly normal. If the ridge vent continued to the end of the roof it would look like a little cap on the gable peak when someone was facing the gable wall. Heavy laminated architectural shingles cannot lie flat when they are cold. When they heat up they will relax and the seal tabs will stick to the shingles below. What you should be concerned about is if a wind storm arrives before the shingles warm up and hope that the shingles were hand nailed in such cold weather.
...See More
What color roof should I choose?
Q
Comments (5)
I like the Owens product, and suggest you look at Owens Oakridge Flagstone. It has greater dimensional value than the Oakridge Teak and would add more emphasis to the roof. This is in line with the first poster's advise to go slightly darker. It would help the house a lot more than the Teak.
...See More
Laura Lee
Original Author
2 years ago
Thanks @cat_ky I will look into cleaning them. I worry they will still look worn but cleaning anything helps.

@tozmo1 thanks for the link. I looked it up. I will be seeing if there is a long warranty on my roof tiles. I think my tiles are cement. Hopefully armed with this new knowledge, my roofer and I can come to great solution. With wood prices as high as they are, turns out resetting the tile and using new shingles prices out similar. New tiles would add another 40%, which he says would look best. But we shall see. That’s quite a lot to swallow!

Appreciate your input
PRO
CoolAir Inc.
2 years ago
Cleaning the roof tiles are way better and budget friendly if you are not considering a redoing.
PRO
Beth H. :
last year
Derek, old post.

Laura,,,what did you end up doing?
Shei Mun
last year
last modified: last year
If you're not sure whether to stick with your current roof tiles or switch to shingles, it might be helpful to get some opinions from roofing experts in your area. Have you checked out any of the roofers in Port St. Lucie? They might be able to give you some advice on what would work best for your specific situation.

As for the type of shingles, it's always a good idea to do some research and read reviews before making a decision. If you're considering Presidential shingles, it might be helpful to see if any other homeowners in your area have used them and what their experiences have been.
Helen Potter
last year
last modified: last year
It's understandable to want to stay true to the original design of your home, but ultimately, the decision to switch to shingles or stick with roof tiles will depend on several factors. First, it's important to consider the condition of your current roof tiles. If they are worn and showing signs of damage, it may be more cost-effective to switch to shingles rather than continuing to repair the tile roof. Additionally, if lumber prices are a concern, shingles may be a more affordable option. Secondly, you should consider the aesthetic value of shingles versus roof tiles. While your stucco may be unique, a new shingle roof can give your home a fresh and updated look. Be sure to look at different shingle options and colors to ensure that they complement the style of your home. And of course you should invite a few more contracting companies near me who can either confirm the words of the first or offer you other options. I have not used Presidential though, so I will not tell you how cool it is or not. I know as well as you that it seems to be better and definitely more expensive.

Related Stories

ROOFS Roof Materials: Get an Old-World Look With Clay Roof Tiles

By Matt Clawson

The ancient roof material of choice remains the modern-day ideal for authentic Italian, Mediterranean and Spanish home styles

EXTERIORS Roofing Materials: Slate Makes for Fireproof Roofs That Last

By Rachel Grace

It stands up to weather and fire without losing its high-end look. But can your budget handle it?

ROOFS No Substitute for the Natural Beauty of Wooden Roof Shingles and Shakes

By Matt Clawson

This natural, renewable roof option brings weathered character and nostalgic appeal to traditional-style homes

ROOFS 8 Alternative Roof Materials to Buck the Mainstream

By Matt Clawson

Looking for something to raise your roof in the neighborhood? Consider synthetic tiles, recycled composite shingles, green roofs and more

LANDSCAPE DESIGN How to Incorporate Your Roofing Into the Landscape

By Jay Sifford Garden Design

Choose hardscape and plantings that work with your roof’s color, texture, shape and line

MATERIALS The Most Popular Roofing Material is Affordable and Easy to Install

By Matt Clawson

Asphalt shingles, the most widely used roof material in the U.S. are reliable and efficient, and may be right for you

ROOFS This Long-Lasting Roofing Material Works With Many Styles

By Matt Clawson

With their durability and wide range of colors and molded shapes, concrete roof tiles are worth a look

REMODELING GUIDES 8 Ecofriendly Roof Options for Low Budgets and Up

By Laura Gaskill

Save resources with a cooling or sustainable roof or add-on that looks great and fits your price range

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: Winged-Roof Home Soars to Capture Desert Views

By Nora Burba Trulsson

In Paradise Valley, Arizona, a house of rammed earth and concrete gets its shade from dramatic, angled rooflines

REMODELING GUIDES Materials: The Advantages of a Metal Roof

By Becky Harris

Metal reigns in roofing style, maintenance and energy efficiency

Sponsored

Buckeye Basements, Inc.

31 Reviews

Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21

More Discussions

Home Addition Design Help

7

Bathroom vanities

0

Need help converting a closet to a bathroom please!

8

Granite veining direction on countertop "L"

7

Critique my new floorplan! Master bath and kitchen

4