Awww I think its a sweet little house - siimplicity is a GOOD thing, IMHO. Some of these McMansiony things you see on this forum - too busy and visually chaotic for my tastes with their multiple roof lines, and 15 different exterior finishes thrown together. When was it built? You could go in a 1920s cottage direction with it, or something more 1940s-50s midcentury. Once we can see the roof, I would think of 3 colors - 1 for the siding, 1 for all the trim + window sashes + garage door, and 1 for the front door + the trim around the front door. And make sure these all relate well to your roof, since it is prominent. Door - replace front door with something jazzier, but keep it simple. Something like this perhaps - https://www.homedepot.com/p/Builders-Choice-36-in-x-80-in-Elite-Atlantis-Etch-Glass-Contemporary-Left-Hand-4-Lite-Satin-Painted-Fiberglass-Prehung-Front-Door-HDXD189450/300922903 Thats the beauty of a small, simple house. A simple little tweak like a new door goes a long way.

Thanks everyone. We are thinking we want to go lighter on the body of the house. What do you think of the same color - carrington beige for the siding and the trim? The windows would have to stay the same color that they are as they are vinyl clad. Also looking for a color slightly darker than the carrington - maybe a beige on the gray side. Thanks again for your suggestions!

I would clear coat the cedar, and also add a wood door, so that you have a few things, that look like they belong together. Cedar is expensive, I wouldnt want to cover it up.

There are a few nice options, here is one of them. Muted greyish green with black trim and doors. You can paint your gutters and downspouts in black and install large black sconces.