skip to main content

Lighting Design Dilemma Kitchens

Kitchen Lighting Layout Scheme

3 years ago

Hi again everyone! Getting ready to drywall the ceiling so last opportunity to move lights around. I am struggling with the best way to place the pennants and recessed lights around the peninsula. Maybe I am focusing too much on symmetry, but I am unsure if the two pennant lights should be centered within the outcropping of the peninsula (four feet long) or the entire stretch of counter to the wall (six feet long). I sketched the lighting out with red being the primary recessed task lights, green being smaller kitchen sink recessed lights, and blue being the pennants. There is also under cabinet lighting for the two wall cabinets, and lighting under the range hood.

If I center with the outcrop I can also center within a rectangle of recessed lights, but the light to the outside edge would only be a few inches from the end of the peninsula.

If I center with the whole peninsula I could get better placement of the pennants but no longer be in line with the recessed lights.

I am going for a fairly utilitarian commercial style look since I am a heavy kitchen user and live by myself. I am considering an Ann Morris style pennant light / pot rack although I would be making something on my own to match it as closely as possible since the real thing is far out of my budget.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
You recessed lighting needs to be further out from the cabinets to allow light to light the counter and not create shadows. This is a good idea of what I am saying also make sure all the bulbs no matter where in the space are all LEDs in 4000K that will keep all the colors you choose true no matter what time of the day.
acm
3 years ago
Totally disagree with Patricia -- the way to remove under-cabinet shadows is to put under-cabinet lighting, and otherwise your lights should be placed so that you yourself don't create a shadow while standing at the counter! I like them just a few inches off the wall cabinets, so I'd move all of yours inward a bit.

I don't think that the pendants need to lineup with your other lights -- they're usually more decorative than task-oriented. But either way, I would place them relative to the whole peninsula if there is any eyeline from the other side of the counter. (I can't tell whether there is continuous room below this floorplan, or just doors from elsewhere.) But neither one would be offensive to look at or to use.

Least clear on the upper-left and lower-right cans -- why not center them with those doorways (if that's what those are)?
Related Discussions
Kitchen lighting plan - need help with recessed lighting layout
Q
Comments (7)
I don't know what the rule is on this, but we put our 4" cans with the edge closest to the cabinet over the edge of the counter. That way, they shine right in front of you when you are standing at the counter. A 6" would get pushed back farther if you use the edge. Stand at a counter where you would work comfortably and look up. My thought is that you want the center of the light just in front of you and hitting the counter in front of the upper cabinets. To close and they wash the cabinet more than light your work space and too far back, the center of the light will hit your head rather than toe work area. Make sense?
...See More
Please review kitchen lighting layout (X Post with Lighting)
Q
Comments (3)
Hi there. I'm by no means a lighting expert, but I can tell you my experience and hope you can benefit from my mistake. As a result of a hasty design and no research, I placed my 6" cans in the wrong spot along my cabinets. If you put the cans behind the counter - like yours are placed in the design, you will get shadows on your counter top...very annoying shadows. I then did some research and discovered that the proper placement for the counter lighting is such that the light is centered over the counter's edge. This does indeed eliminate the shadows. As for distance between cans, the simple plan would be to place your 6" cans, 6 feet apart; 4" cans, 4 feet apart, etc. This is for a standard ceiling. A taller ceiling can have them closer, but I don't know the specifics. This leads me to my next mistake which was to place the 6" cans too close together. My kitchen was too bright and I was never able to find the right combination of bulbs to satisfy my lighting needs. Upon this recent remodel, I did better research and I'm now using 4" cans spaced properly and at the right depth (from the wall out to the counter) and the first round of bulbs (standard 9 watt CFL/50 watt equiv) were perfect. HTH.
...See More
Choosing Color Scheme and Layout for Small Living Room
Q
Comments (1)
I would not do asectional since you will only have one place to put it a sofa nad 2 chairs are a much better choice for seating and a chaise is a useless piece when entertaining because no one wants to sit there. Get an ottoman it act as an extra seat in a pinch . You might even be able to do 2 sofas and 2 smaller scaled chairs on either side of the sliding doors.
...See More
Color scheme & lighting for galley kitchen with black countertop
Q
Comments (8)
do not do large tiles for your splash. look at it. you'll be cutting and wasting large tiles. just get a glass tile you like in a 4x12 or 3x12 size and stack them as for the cab, I'd get them refaced w/slab doors/drawers. you're pretty modern looking especially w/that flooring you chose. painting those shaker style oak cabs is going to look like an afterthought. but, if you want to try the two tone, try this look but with a darker bottom color. (this one is Gautlent Gray) copy the hardware though. Try BM Wrought Iron, shown here w/Westhighland white. (or just use Pure White) or this color. BM Cheating Heart. use gold hardware I wouldn't use white dove on the cabs. too dull. try pure white or Simply White consider adding some boxes to the top like shown in the after. look into have them refaced. shouldn't be that expensive since you don't have many. go to a custom kitchen place, not home depot. Ikea I hope you get a new back door too. something like this when you choose to upgrade to more modern design, everything from the 90's has to go.
...See More
Dave H
Original Author
3 years ago
All four edges of the layout are walls, with the four openings on the vertical walls being doorways and the two openings on the horizontal walls being windows.

I was using the layout advice posted here as it made the most sense to me, similar to what you are saying ACM.

https://www.proremodeler.com/recessed-kitchen-lighting-reconsidered

I only have two wall cabinets and am not overly concerned with shadows created by cabinets, but would be concerned about me myself causing shadows on the counters if I placed the lights only in walkways.

Perhaps I do not need the upper left and lower right lights, I only placed them in those locations because of symmetry. I could potentially get rid of those two and have something like this:
Dave H
Original Author
3 years ago
Ok so after sleeping on it I think this will be what I go with. If I add some open shelving to the left of the refrigerator I can somewhat balance out the difference between counter alignment and recessed light alignment while I think still being in a fairly ideal placement. Since I already have the recessed lights installed I will just keep the two "floating" lights since everything is on a dimmer anyway and it might be nice having a couple of lights over walkways. There will be under cabinet lights under the two wall cabinets and lights under the hood, as before.

Related Stories

KITCHEN MAKEOVERS Kitchen of the Week: New Layout and Lightness in 120 Square Feet

By Jeannie Matteucci

A designer helps a New York couple rethink their kitchen workflow and add more countertop surface and cabinet storage

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: More Light, Better Layout for a Canadian Victorian

By Vanessa Brunner

Stripped to the studs, this Toronto kitchen is now brighter and more functional, with a gorgeous wide-open view

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Layouts: Ideas for U-Shaped Kitchens

By KitchenLab Interiors

U-shaped kitchens are great for cooks and guests. Is this one for you?

COLORFUL KITCHENS Midcentury Kitchen Seen in a New Light

By Camille LeFevre

A once-dark Seattle space brightens up with colorful cabinets, lighter materials, bigger views and an expanded layout

KITCHEN DESIGN A Two-Tone Cabinet Scheme Gives Your Kitchen the Best of Both Worlds

By Toronto Interior Design Group

Waffling between paint and stain or dark and light? Here’s how to mix and match colors and materials

KITCHEN MAKEOVERS Kitchen of the Week: From Dark to Light in Vancouver

By Becky Harris

The U-shaped layout worked well for cooking, but dark finishes were bringing the British Columbia homeowners down

PENDANT LIGHTING Choose the Right Pendant Lights for Your Kitchen Island

By Toronto Interior Design Group

Get your island lighting scheme on track with tips on function, style, height and more

SMALL KITCHENS The 100-Square-Foot Kitchen: A Dark Space Sees the Light

By Mitchell Parker

A new layout and open shelves bring a feeling of spaciousness to a compact New York City apartment kitchen

ADDITIONS Room of the Day: A Light-Filled Loft-Style Kitchen Addition

By Lara Sargent

A period London property embraces industrial style and exposed materials with an open-plan layout

SMALL KITCHENS Smaller Appliances and a New Layout Open Up an 80-Square-Foot Kitchen

By Apartment 46 for the Home

Scandinavian style also helps keep things light, bright and airy in this compact space in New York City

Sponsored

Columbus Premier Design-Build and General Contractor

More Discussions

Help! Suggestions for lighting and mirrors in an asymmetrical bathroom

4

Foyer light assist!

20

What dimensions for a neck for this lamp?

4

pendants for kitchen

7

Do these junction boxes meet code?

2