How about something like this but in dark sage green black trim and a new door.

Thank you, I love the look but it would be too different from the other houses in my neighborhood.

May be some kind of with dark bronze trim, white/off-white/ivory body and beige/tan siding?

I would paint it all the same color, like Patricia's example above but in a medium color. No contrasting garage door, trim etc.

Or with cedar siding and beige body with bronze trim

with taupe and off-white

With greige body, light greige for wood and bronze trim.

I prefer a single color because there is already a lot going on with all the angles on your house. I find the resulting play of light and shadow very attractive, but I think it is too busy if it is given additional complexity with a mix of colors, or contrasting trim. A greige color would look very good. You will have a very different (better) look than if you had a flat-style house painted all the same color, which would be boring.

Thank you celerygirl for all of the color combos, it really helps to visualize the different options. And partim, I think you are right about all of the angles and details going on and adding different colors on top of that. It looks like monochromatic is the way to go. Thank you!!

I also suggest a small change to your landscaping. To give your front entrance more oopmph, add a bed to the right of the walkway, planted with the same plant as the smaller bed between the walkway and the driveway. Don't aim for mixed flowers or anything like that. Grasses would look great with your house style. The matched single-plant beds will draw the eye towards your front door in a very pleasant way.